Two of us got cappucinos on a Sunday afternoon and they were the worst cappucinos we've ever had, and this is not an exaggeration.
I was horrified when I saw the barista pouring the milk from the pitcher into the cup. It had been oversteamed to the point that the foam had completely separated from the milk, and after pouring the milk into the espresso the barista proceeded to use a spoon to scoop the residual foam in the pitcher and place it on top of the drink. And of course the cappucinos were scalding hot since the milk had been oversteamed and tasted terrible.
The barista was extremely friendly but had no idea what he was doing. Maybe he was just covering a shift on a Sunday afternoon? I was really shocked by this experience since this cafe is so well-rated.
Sarjeel Zaman
Mid food. Decent coffee. Overpriced. Expect to drop $9 on an iced latte. No complaints about the staff, they've very friendly and helpful.
That said, I kind of respect the hustle. It feels like poetic justice in a way, charging premium prices in a rapidly gentrifying neighborhood, and the clientele doesn’t even flinch. The place is staffed entirely by POC, so it almost feels like a quiet form of resistance. Serving avocado toasts and cheese sandwiches with a smile while hearing about these customers rave on and on about their surfing trip to Pleasant Point beach.
Jim
Very expensive for what you get. Coffee was not good at all and sandwiches were small. Bagel was tasty but again too expensive.
Michael Netherland
Charming and cozy. Great product, prices and service. My go to spot in the neighborhood. Open earlier and later than most of the cafes in the area. Service is always warm and welcoming. Highly recommend
Idk Idc
Great coffee, good food, excellent customer service, Mahmoud was out cashier/server very nice human being and all the staff is friendly, greatly recommend
Patrick Dormer
The workers were super friendly and they quickly filled our order One of the few places in NY that can actually make a cup of tea
Nasirbek Ismailov
Just discovered Penny House Cafe and it's awesome! Delicious food, top-notch coffee, and super friendly service. Perfect spot to relax with free wifi and a chill vibe. I'm definitely coming back!
Nicole Khusid
NICEST people working here!! Delicious sandwiches and coffee, amazing vibes inside, I take literally all my friends here! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Or Rochlin
I highly recommend you to visit Penny House Cafe! Mahmoud a charming person, attentive, nice and knows how to provide service, I ate the Bagel Lux. And it was perfect, everything was delicious and fresh.
Great service, super nice host, tasty, friendly. I highly recommend it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie Cooper
Had the best lunch here! Great prices, great quality, and the BEST service. Everyone was so nice and they clearly take pride in their food. Highly recommend and would come again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paige Tyson
Good vibes and good food! Mahmoud was wonderful! He was welcoming and accommodating. The sandwiches were fresh and delicious! Indoor and outdoor seating available. Clean and well maintained bathroom.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ulf Johnsson
This is a café gem in Brooklyn! One of the best bagels I've ever had and super friendly staff! Chill vibe and a must-go!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tyler
Really tasty sandwiches (but grab a couple extra napkins). Good coffee and friendly staff.
Great service in a relaxed atmosphere.
Two of us got cappucinos on a Sunday afternoon and they were the worst cappucinos we've ever had, and this is not an exaggeration.
I was horrified when I saw the barista pouring the milk from the pitcher into the cup. It had been oversteamed to the point that the foam had completely separated from the milk, and after pouring the milk into the espresso the barista proceeded to use a spoon to scoop the residual foam in the pitcher and place it on top of the drink. And of course the cappucinos were scalding hot since the milk had been oversteamed and tasted terrible.
The barista was extremely friendly but had no idea what he was doing. Maybe he was just covering a shift on a Sunday afternoon? I was really shocked by this experience since this cafe is so well-rated.
Mid food. Decent coffee. Overpriced. Expect to drop $9 on an iced latte. No complaints about the staff, they've very friendly and helpful.
That said, I kind of respect the hustle. It feels like poetic justice in a way, charging premium prices in a rapidly gentrifying neighborhood, and the clientele doesn’t even flinch. The place is staffed entirely by POC, so it almost feels like a quiet form of resistance. Serving avocado toasts and cheese sandwiches with a smile while hearing about these customers rave on and on about their surfing trip to Pleasant Point beach.
Very expensive for what you get. Coffee was not good at all and sandwiches were small. Bagel was tasty but again too expensive.
Charming and cozy. Great product, prices and service. My go to spot in the neighborhood. Open earlier and later than most of the cafes in the area. Service is always warm and welcoming. Highly recommend
Great coffee, good food, excellent customer service, Mahmoud was out cashier/server very nice human being and all the staff is friendly, greatly recommend
The workers were super friendly and they quickly filled our order
One of the few places in NY that can actually make a cup of tea
Just discovered Penny House Cafe and it's awesome! Delicious food, top-notch coffee, and super friendly service. Perfect spot to relax with free wifi and a chill vibe. I'm definitely coming back!
NICEST people working here!! Delicious sandwiches and coffee, amazing vibes inside, I take literally all my friends here! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I highly recommend you to visit Penny House Cafe! Mahmoud a charming person, attentive, nice and knows how to provide service, I ate the Bagel Lux. And it was perfect, everything was delicious and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service, super nice host, tasty, friendly. I highly recommend it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the best lunch here! Great prices, great quality, and the BEST service. Everyone was so nice and they clearly take pride in their food. Highly recommend and would come again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good vibes and good food! Mahmoud was wonderful! He was welcoming and accommodating. The sandwiches were fresh and delicious! Indoor and outdoor seating available. Clean and well maintained bathroom.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a café gem in Brooklyn! One of the best bagels I've ever had and super friendly staff! Chill vibe and a must-go!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really tasty sandwiches (but grab a couple extra napkins). Good coffee and friendly staff.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...