People's Bakery Pastry Shop

2355 86th St, Brooklyn
(718) 372-2839

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shanita Li

I called them to order a Oreo cake with grey letters and Happy Birthday KELLY! When we opened the box the letters were in RED and they misspelled her name! We scraped off the I as they spelled it KELLI! We called them twice to confirm, I don’t understand what happened. They also didn’t let us confirm the cake when we picked it up. Very disappointing

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Courtney Kwong

best butter and jelly cookies in the world. I bring them to every event. everyone is always hooked and can’t wait for the next time I pull up with them. even had them at our wedding!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wolfie Surfn30s

My family always gets their birthday cake here. I went there for the first time very very nice lady. I did call before I went there and they didn’t pick up two times and then third time the charm and they picked up. They do accept debit card. It looks real nice, but it is small… not that pricey either recommend

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rainbow Cookies, Birthday Cake

j g

I ordered a tres leches cake and got a regular cake with strawberry filling. Then when I brought it back the baker was trying to tell me that’s how he makes his tres leches. It was dry and there’s was no milk in it, and they were also rude. As you can see on the pictures I took. There is no milk.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Candice B

Bought carrot cake and some mini pastries. Everything was stale! Waste ot time and money!

MIND Jash

I LOVE THE PEOPLE-SHAPED COOKIES THEY'RE SO GOOD!!!
i also tried the cream puffs they are good too
super yommy ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Earl GreyKun

This place has been here for YEARS. Small-ish place and simple, all your options are nicely displayed. To be honest I've only ever liked their cookies. Not too sweet and a tad on the dry side but that's why I like them. Perfect as side for coffee or milk. I've tried all their cookies, I really like the ones half dipped in chocolate, biscotti, holiday sugar cookies, the one with little chocolate chips on top, and the one with a cherry in the middle.The pastries are fine and the cakes are just okay, I personally find them more on the sweeter side. Not too crazy about that. The cannoli's and rainbow cakes are good though.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

gui vacdyb

I LOVE THE PEOPLE-SHAPED COOKIES THEY'RE SO GOOD!!!
i also tried the cream puffs they are good too
super yommy ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Pino

Layout/atmosphere*Small shop with display caseFood/drink*Cannoli - good; candied fruit with chocolate chips in the cream; shell little too flaky (chocolate version held up better)

Arrhythmia Jash

I LOVE THE PEOPLE-SHAPED COOKIES THEY'RE SO GOOD!!!
i also tried the cream puffs they are good too
super yommy 🤑

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

agent

I LOVE THE PEOPLE-SHAPED COOKIES THEY'RE SO GOOD!!!i also tried the cream puffs they are good toosuper yommy ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Double You

Came in just to take a look and saw their little serving size cakes and asked about the pricing. The worker told me $2 and I thought wow great! Came right back to purchase and the same exact worker charged me $4. I thought it was because I asked him how much were the “little” cakes but all the cakes were the same size. Came online to see other reviews and seen someone say it was $3. Wonder if they’re just making up prices… Anyways cake was nasty taste very old like all reviews say.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gina Dowd

The best thing in the store is the canoli cake. Omg to die for. We get it every birthday we can. If you order ahead of time it is as fresh as can be.

Sarah Jacob

Delicious cakes , and fast perfect service . Nice and polite stuff. But no negotiation here.

Peter Fusco

Cookies left a nasty aftertaste in my mouth. It's not worth the price. The pies looked good with the exception of the dying bug that was desperately trying to find its way out of the display case.

Loading...

People's Bakery Pastry Shop

2355 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214
(718) 372-2839