Puerto Plata Fish Market

391 Arlington Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 607-0656

Recent Reviews

Sort by
PUFFZ 93

I love this place and would highly recommend. I’m unable to eat corn due to serious diet restrictions and they always go out of their way to substitute mixed vegs for me. I’m not sure if you guys recognize my Uber eats order but if you do thank you for accommodating me I truly appreciate it!

Michael Hanna

Good prices good seafood

GREGNYCE

If you need a seafood fix come out to ENY and visit Puerto Plata . You won’t be disappointed .

Jaida Foreman

I love ordering seafood from here! The food is always super fresh and there's such an axing variety of mix and matches. Honestly some of the best lobster I've had in NYC🦞

Darien Liriano

I had a fantastic experience at Puerto Plata Seafood! Melanie was incredibly nice, greeting me warmly and taking my order with such friendliness. The food was absolutely delicious, bursting with amazing flavor, and I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. My only suggestion would be to include some plastic eating gloves next time for added convenience. Can’t wait to return! Highly recommend!

William Meed (pushback860)

Food is exceptional. Fast service. A must have.

Daniella Adams

I ordered the mini Fulton and spent around $65. The lobster tail and crab legs were on the small side and I was provided with 7 shrimp. Didn’t seem worth the price.

Veronixa Weber

I started eating the mussel already lol but Imma give it a three star rating only because it didn’t have much sauce . I put the sauce I had from the other trey left over & I ordered off the uber app it was cold . It was buy one get one free . Don’t get me wrong they was good but it needs more flavor . It taste like butter and alittle obey . I feel like they need to put more seasoning and give an option to make it spicy because I love spicy and I’m pretty sure a lot of people do but it was good . I need to try it when it’s hot and ready .

Gricel Mateo

UNBELIEVABLE best crab legs, shrimp, lobster tail etc.. so we'll seasoned makes you want to eat the shells..

BRITNEY ALPHONSE

I don't like writing reviews, but it was my first time ordering from you guys. I don't care about the 19 bucks I paid but this has no taste at all ontop of that the sauce was very little and watery. I won't be coming back there..im sorry

Frank White

Way overpriced for a medium container of ceviche and a even smaller container of rice 38$ crazy

ernesto tineo

Yo to be completely honest Im not even mad bout the money or nothing, but 90 for 3 lobster rolls is crazy work when they small as hell. To top it off the bread was supposed to be like garlic bread and it was not toasted or nothing. Low-key sad.

Caly M

I love this place BUT the line be super crazy. I tried ordering before hand and that was also a mess. I would definitely give them a five but their customers service and organization sucks!

Naney S

Best seafood in Brooklyn hands down! I'm late to the party but I'm a fan! The presentation alone is impressive! The flavors are on point!

Rose Vallejo

I visit frequent with family either for seafood or Spanish food. Very nice and pleasant. Every time we go the bill is more than $100 because we enjoy drinks entree apps etc. check out my TikTok for food review on this spot @excuseurosee

Loading...