Puerto Plata Fish Market

391 Arlington Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 607-0656

Recent Reviews Order Online

Picked for you
Fulton Steeet
4 snow crab leg clusters, 1 pound of shrimps, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Mini Fulton Street
2 snow crab leg clusters, 1/2 pound of shrimp, 1 lobster tail, potatoes, and corn.
Mini Salmon
1 piece of salmon, potatoes, and corn.
Mini Atlantis
1 piece of salmon, 1/2 pound of shrimp, 1 lobster tail, and mixed veggies.
Atlantis
2 pieces of salmon, 1 pound of shrimp, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 2 people.

Raw Bar
Steamed Mussels (1 lb)
Cape cod.
Blue Point Oysters (6pc)
Long Island. (Served with Green Lime & La Dona del Sazon's Hot Sauce)
Malpeque Oysters (6pc)
Canada. (Served with Green Lime & La Dona del Sazon's Hot Sauce)
Cherry Stone Clams (1pc)
Long Island.
Little Neck Clams (1pc)
Long Island.

Mains
Mini Fulton Street
2 snow crab leg clusters, 1/2 pound of shrimp, 1 lobster tail, potatoes, and corn.
Mini Salmon
1 piece of salmon, potatoes, and corn.
Mini Atlantis
1 piece of salmon, 1/2 pound of shrimp, 1 lobster tail, and mixed veggies.
Lobster Roll
Lobster claw and knuckle meat dressed in light mayo and herbs. Served chilled on a toasted garlic butter potato bread roll.
Crab Roll
De-shelled Alaskan king crab and snow crab meat mixed in light mayo, herbs, and diced peppers. Served chilled on a toasted garlic butter potato roll.
Salmon Burger
Baked wild caught Alaskan king salmon served on a garlic butter potato bread with lettuce, onions, and our homemade secret sauce.
Shrimp Roll
Ecuadorian wild caught shrimp and masago capelin roe caviar in a creamy Asian fusion sauce. Served chilled on a toasted garlic butter potato roll.

Perfect for 2 People
Fulton Steeet
4 snow crab leg clusters, 1 pound of shrimps, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Atlantis
2 pieces of salmon, 1 pound of shrimp, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 2 people.
Athena
1 pound of shrimp, 1 pound of mussels, 1 pound of calamari, 2 snow crab leg clusters, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Apollo
1 piece of salmon, 1 pound of shrimp, 4 snow crab leg clusters, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
La Poderosa
Made to order. 1 whole lobster stuffed with crab meat, 4 Peruvian scallops, 1 pound of shrimps, 1 king crab leg, 1 snow crab leg cluster, broccoli, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Olympus
1.5 pounds of king crab legs, 1 pound of shrimp, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Crab Madness
8 snow crab leg clusters, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 2 people.
Boca Chica
1 Caribbean red snapper, 1 pound of calamari, 1 pound of scallops, 12 clams, 1 pound of shrimp, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 2 people.

Perfect for 5+ People
Big Papi
5 lobster tails, 2 pounds of shrimp, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Salmon Special
Made to order. 10 pieces of salmon, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Neptuno
10 snow crab leg clusters, 2 pounds of shrimp, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Atlantic Ave
Made to order. 5 pieces of salmon, 2 pounds of shrimp, 6 lobster tails, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Midas
Made to order. 1 pound of shrimp, 1 pound of calamari, 2 pounds of mussels, 2 pieces salmon, 2 lobster tails, 3 snow crab leg clusters, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Poseidon
8 snow crab clusters, 8 lobster tails, 2 pounds of shrimp, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 5 plus people.
King's Feast
Made to order. 4 snow crab leg clusters, 4 lobster tails, 2 big lobster tails, 3 pieces of king crab legs, 2 pounds of shrimp, potatoes, and corn. Perfect for 5 plus people.
Oceanus
2 pieces of salmon, 1.5 pounds of king crab legs, 2 pounds of shrimp, 2 snow crab leg clusters, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. Perfect for 5 plus people.

Extras
Homemade Garlic Butter Sauce (Large)
Colossal Shrimp (1 lb)
Sopa Revive Muertos
La Dona's Ceviche
Side of Potatoes & Corn
Mixed Veggies
La Dona Del Sazon's Hot Sauce
Salmon (2 pcs)
Steamed Mussels (1 lb)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+29 photos
Photo credit: google
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I love this place and would highly recommend. I’m unable to eat corn due to serious diet restrictions and they always go out of their way to substitute mixed vegs for me. I’m not sure if you guys recognize my Uber eats order but if you do thank you for accommodating me I truly appreciate it!
August 2025
I love ordering seafood from here! The food is always super fresh and there's such an axing variety of mix and matches. Honestly some of the best lobster I've had in NYC🦞
July 2025
I had a fantastic experience at Puerto Plata Seafood! Melanie was incredibly nice, greeting me warmly and taking my order with such friendliness. The food was absolutely delicious, bursting with amazing flavor, and I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. My only suggestion would be to include some plastic eating gloves next time for added convenience. Can’t wait to return! Highly recommend!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Puerto Plata Restaurant - 3123 Fulton St
Dominican, Bar, Seafood
El Pulgarcito de America - 3133 Fulton St
Salvadoran, Vegetarian
Chimichurri Mobil - 3115 Fulton St

Puerto Plata Fish Market

391 Arlington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208
(718) 607-0656