Sal & Jerry Bakery (Wholesale)

53 Mahan St, West Babylon
(631) 920-5959

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Loretta Russo

Their cakes and cookies are amazing!

Suzanne Krispin

Theres a guy who has your stuff in pennsylvania at hometown-10/10 so delicious

Kiara Krishnani

There was a line of people at farmers market so we decided to give it a try. It was nothing special and the babka was super hard and stale and eggy. Very disappointed

Dina Marinello Judge

Found the Sal and Jerry’s booth at the Tully Farmer’s Market and then, again, at the NYU Langone Farmer’s Market and I am OBSESSED!!! The eggplant bread is unlike anything I’ve ever tasted!! It is AMAZING!!! Today I bought the spinach bread as well and it is to die for too!!! So fresh and delicious! Thanks for making my day!!

Vito Ancona

Wow! Simply, Wow! Two great tastes that taste great together! I'm not talking about the old commercial about a certain candy. I'm talking about a Chocolate Chip Cookie wrapped around a 7 layer (Rainbow) Cookie. Just a perfect combination! Sal & Jerry's 7-Layer Cookies are the best. When ever I need a taste of home (NYC), living in Central Florida I hop over to their site to order some of the freshest and tastiest Italian cookies around and have them delivered to the Sunshine state. Nothing here in the Orlando comes close. I will be ordering again, hungry for more.

John Nochisaki

cookies are delicious, staff is friendly & family like w/ accommodating last minute special orders and changes.

Aastha Budhathoki

"I drove quite a distance and looked for a good bakery place on google where I found this place..and it was absolutely worth it! As soon as I arrived, I could smell the freshness from afar—such a warm and inviting aroma.
The staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful, making the experience even better. The cake I purchased was not only fresh but also absolutely delicious! They also offer freshly baked cookies and bread, which looked amazing. I highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for high-quality baked goods. Thank you for the wonderful experience!

Barbara Schehr

Was lucky to find a vendor selling their baked goods at the Westbury Gardens event last weekend (Frank was so helpful and nice).
I bought the prosciutto bread, rice balls and the raspberry lemon dessert. Everything was delicious! My friends bought the sausage bread and said it was delicious as well.

Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)

Sal and Jerry's Bakery, which recently opened a location in West Babylon after starting in Brooklyn, offers a delicious variety of baked goods including pound cakes, cookies, pastries, and more. I tried their Arancini (rice balls) at the Farmer's Market in Farmingdale, and they were absolutely delicious. I highly recommend giving Sal and Jerry's a try - you won't be disappointed.

Corianne Wolf

Got Them Rainbow Little cakes so good they melt in your mouth..

Diane L

I am a New Yorker living in South Florida. There are just somethings you can not get down here. One of them is Lard bread. I ordered 2 round loafs. They did not disappoint! Packed well. Fast service (arrived in 3 days) So fresh!! Perfect amount of pepper. Defiantly will order again. Thank you!

scotts mlla

I ordered 7 layer (rainbow ) cookies and assorted butter cookies. It was still 100 degrees where I reside, and the order was shipped without ice. The 7 layers were melted and couldn't even be separated. In the garbage. The butter cookies were in shambles. I worked at a many Brooklyn bakeries in my teens and we would have gotten fired for making clumsy looking butter cookies. I emailed S &j and they never responded. Couldn't be more disappointed and disrespected..And they were expensive.

Clara Rossilli

Best Lard bread! I'm from. I'm from Bensonhurst and now live in Lindenhurst. Was at a street fair in Betpage last wkk and came across your booth. I almost fainted. I bought 2 beads and then come to find out ur in Babylon ?

Kali Black Mother

with ingredients like that, they probably want to poison people. and they taste like trash

Joseph Spinella

The best bakery around hands down!

Loading...

Sal & Jerry Bakery (Wholesale)

53 Mahan St, West Babylon, NY 11704
(631) 920-5959