Sal & Jerry Bakery (Wholesale)

53 Mahan St, West Babylon
(631) 920-5959

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Aastha Budhathoki

"I drove quite a distance and looked for a good bakery place on google where I found this place..and it was absolutely worth it! As soon as I arrived, I could smell the freshness from afar—such a warm and inviting aroma.
The staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful, making the experience even better. The cake I purchased was not only fresh but also absolutely delicious! They also offer freshly baked cookies and bread, which looked amazing. I highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for high-quality baked goods. Thank you for the wonderful experience!

Barbara Schehr

Was lucky to find a vendor selling their baked goods at the Westbury Gardens event last weekend (Frank was so helpful and nice).
I bought the prosciutto bread, rice balls and the raspberry lemon dessert. Everything was delicious! My friends bought the sausage bread and said it was delicious as well.

Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)

Sal and Jerry's Bakery, which recently opened a location in West Babylon after starting in Brooklyn, offers a delicious variety of baked goods including pound cakes, cookies, pastries, and more. I tried their Arancini (rice balls) at the Farmer's Market in Farmingdale, and they were absolutely delicious. I highly recommend giving Sal and Jerry's a try - you won't be disappointed.

Corianne Wolf

Got Them Rainbow Little cakes so good they melt in your mouth..

Diane L

I am a New Yorker living in South Florida. There are just somethings you can not get down here. One of them is Lard bread. I ordered 2 round loafs. They did not disappoint! Packed well. Fast service (arrived in 3 days) So fresh!! Perfect amount of pepper. Defiantly will order again. Thank you!

scotts mlla

I ordered 7 layer (rainbow ) cookies and assorted butter cookies. It was still 100 degrees where I reside, and the order was shipped without ice. The 7 layers were melted and couldn't even be separated. In the garbage. The butter cookies were in shambles. I worked at a many Brooklyn bakeries in my teens and we would have gotten fired for making clumsy looking butter cookies. I emailed S &j and they never responded. Couldn't be more disappointed and disrespected..And they were expensive.

Clara Rossilli

Best Lard bread! I'm from. I'm from Bensonhurst and now live in Lindenhurst. Was at a street fair in Betpage last wkk and came across your booth. I almost fainted. I bought 2 beads and then come to find out ur in Babylon ?

Kali Black Mother

with ingredients like that, they probably want to poison people. and they taste like trash

Joseph Spinella

The best bakery around hands down!

Jarne C

I love jelly cookies, but I hate that some of these bakeries are chintzy with the jelly. May be a few cookies have some jelly when the rest are somewhat bare. Not so with Sal and Jerry’s bakery their jelly cookies have an ample spread of jelly. All of them! I definitely will be buying more of this delicious product.

pbrig

The couple of products I purchased at my local Food Emporium was good and fairly priced especially compared to my local bakeries. Because this is not a local bakery but a warehouse out on Long Island. The only thing Brooklyn is the logo ?

Peter Briganti

The couple of products I purchased at my local Food Emporium was good and fairly priced especially compared to my local bakeries. Because this is not a local bakery but a warehouse out on Long Island. The only thing Brooklyn is the logo ?

Lois Berry

Best cookies!!! I can’t believe the flavor of these cookies. They have everything! About 70 different varieties, and they not only taste wonderful, but are gorgeously decorated! Pignoli, rainbow, jelly-filled, chocolate-filled, almond cookies…I want to try them all!

Elle Bee

Best cookies!!! I can’t believe the flavor of these cookies. They have everything! About 70 different varieties, and they not only taste wonderful, but are gorgeously decorated! Pignoli, rainbow, jelly-filled, chocolate-filled, almond cookies…I want to try them all!

Steve Meadows

Stumbled on this at the Port Jefferson Farmers Market, immediately HOOKED. Been back for a few weeks now and seems like it will be a regular stop on Sunday mornings.

Loading...

Sal & Jerry Bakery (Wholesale)

53 Mahan St, West Babylon, NY 11704
(631) 920-5959