Last night I tried food from Sally's for the first time and it was pretty good. We got take out and the service was really nice.I had the curry chicken which I was hoping to be cooked in a more Caribbean way, but it was still nice, spicy and the chicken portion was very decent which I was pleasantly surprised by. I had a taste of my friend's jerk fish and it was so good, sweet and spicy, but I wouldn't call it jerk. She also let me try the crab Rangoon dumplings and they were my favorite! I wish I had them hot and with the sauce provided, but they were still great.I got the matcha rum cake and there wasn't a hint of rum. I was really disappointed by this, and the size was also pretty shocking and small. At least if there was any taste of rum I would've said ok, the price is for the rum and not the size. But I felt cheated. The cake which was like a mini bundt cake was sweet and good just not for $12.The Caribbean and Asian flare wasn't really pulled off very well for me. It would've been nice if the cultures were better represented and fused in the food, but for me the food across the board leans more Asian inspired like maybe Thai. The food was fine just not what it claimed to be.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curry Crab Rangoon
Rocco Cuccurullo
had the kale & arugula salad, short ribs, chicken sandwich, & pork belly bowl and was so good! service was great, I can't remember our servers' names but they were so pleasant and helpful with the menu. cocktails were beautiful and tasted great as well! I definitely recommend if you're in Brooklyn.Dietary restrictions: lots of vegetarian options with great flavor palette!Parking: lots of street parking nearby
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Symone Powell
I went here for Galentine’s Day with my friends. It was lively. The bartenders/waiters were lovely and attentive. The Hangover Nachos were the star of the show! Everything else was just okay to me. I was disappointed that there weren’t any vegan brunch options on the menu. We should’ve been more diligent on checking before arriving but because the regular menu has vegan options we assumed brunch would as well. Overall, it was good. I’d return for dinner but maybe not brunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Andrew Viglione
Good food, mean
Service: 1
Guerschmide Saint-Ange
The food is incredible. The drinks are trash. The drinks used to be great. Every time they add a great drink to the menu, they change the menu and remove the best drinks. The drinks are not only weak from an alcohol content, they literally do not taste good— at all. Seriously, get water. The space is small, so unless you’re in a booth or outside, you feel like you are sitting on top of strangers. I still go here because the food redeems everything.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Joseph “Joey” Noga
Wow. The food is incredible. Great small bar/diner vibe. Great drinks. I loved the old fashioned and the espresso martini best. The Jerk ribs blew my mind. Guac and chips was a great take on a classic. And we ate every spec of everything. Sleeper right here. Check out Sally’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole
A C
The menu is pretty extensive and I only ordered about three things but what I ate was deeply unsatisfying, unfortunately. The Ramen was bland, the tacos were tiny for the price, and the dumplings were super soggy. All the cocktails I had were amazing though, so maybe just come here for a drink. The service was amazing, all servers and bartenders were extremely friendly and helpful plus there was a great DJ. The vibes were perfect, good place for a drinks date.
Taylor K.
WOW was this place good! I'm giving it a 4.5 because I personally didn't like the drinks but I LOVED the food here.. The oxtail dumplings were so juicy and flavorful, the Dan Dan noodles were great. I can't wait to come back here because the food was stellar and they have a menu with a ton of delicious options that I can't wait to try in the future. The inside of this place is dark and cozy, but has seating as well as a bar. The service was also nice.
Alexis R.
Love the food here and the atmosphere. Food had a nice kick so beware! The chill vives are great
Fronimakis Anastasia
What an amazing spot. Small but perfect menu with amazing flavors. Great drinks, great food and friendly service! Still dreaming about the steamed pork buns! They did tonight! All in all super cool place, will be a regular for sure!
The waitress was sloppy, unprofessional, and had the audacity to charge an automatically charged gratuity of 20 percent. Never going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Delphine Ettinger (Ashes57)
Nice atmosphere and cocktails.
Frankie Garbado
Was there for a birthday party. Everyone was so lovely and the food was awesome. Thank you Sallys team! Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elli Cherry
I am very unhappy with this place because they added a 20% gratuity to the bill without my permission and requested tips when paying the bill. I don't recommend such places because it's just unacceptable. The customer should decide how much tip to leave based on their assessment of the service, and they provided no service yet included a 20% gratuity in my bill, plus requested tips! Are they even in their right mind?! I came here to relax after work, not to be taken advantage of! No way! I've definitely told all my friends in the area not to visit this place! I've never experienced such disrespect anywhere. Unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Guacamole
Christopher Wilson
My friend and I had lunch at Sally's and while the food was good, it wasn't exceptional. Our server, however, was attentive and prompt. We found the cost to be expensive - $90+ for lunch for two wasn't worth it. Moreover, we did not like the mandatory 20% gratuity (which we would have left regardless) that was not disclosed unless it was on the menu and we overlooked it which was highly unlikely. Unfortunately it was an experience that neither of us would repeat.
Last night I tried food from Sally's for the first time and it was pretty good. We got take out and the service was really nice.I had the curry chicken which I was hoping to be cooked in a more Caribbean way, but it was still nice, spicy and the chicken portion was very decent which I was pleasantly surprised by. I had a taste of my friend's jerk fish and it was so good, sweet and spicy, but I wouldn't call it jerk. She also let me try the crab Rangoon dumplings and they were my favorite! I wish I had them hot and with the sauce provided, but they were still great.I got the matcha rum cake and there wasn't a hint of rum. I was really disappointed by this, and the size was also pretty shocking and small. At least if there was any taste of rum I would've said ok, the price is for the rum and not the size. But I felt cheated. The cake which was like a mini bundt cake was sweet and good just not for $12.The Caribbean and Asian flare wasn't really pulled off very well for me. It would've been nice if the cultures were better represented and fused in the food, but for me the food across the board leans more Asian inspired like maybe Thai. The food was fine just not what it claimed to be.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curry Crab Rangoon
had the kale & arugula salad, short ribs, chicken sandwich, & pork belly bowl and was so good! service was great, I can't remember our servers' names but they were so pleasant and helpful with the menu. cocktails were beautiful and tasted great as well! I definitely recommend if you're in Brooklyn.Dietary restrictions: lots of vegetarian options with great flavor palette!Parking: lots of street parking nearby
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went here for Galentine’s Day with my friends. It was lively. The bartenders/waiters were lovely and attentive. The Hangover Nachos were the star of the show! Everything else was just okay to me. I was disappointed that there weren’t any vegan brunch options on the menu. We should’ve been more diligent on checking before arriving but because the regular menu has vegan options we assumed brunch would as well. Overall, it was good. I’d return for dinner but maybe not brunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Good food, mean
Service: 1
The food is incredible. The drinks are trash. The drinks used to be great. Every time they add a great drink to the menu, they change the menu and remove the best drinks. The drinks are not only weak from an alcohol content, they literally do not taste good— at all. Seriously, get water. The space is small, so unless you’re in a booth or outside, you feel like you are sitting on top of strangers. I still go here because the food redeems everything.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Wow. The food is incredible. Great small bar/diner vibe. Great drinks. I loved the old fashioned and the espresso martini best. The Jerk ribs blew my mind. Guac and chips was a great take on a classic. And we ate every spec of everything. Sleeper right here. Check out Sally’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole
The menu is pretty extensive and I only ordered about three things but what I ate was deeply unsatisfying, unfortunately. The Ramen was bland, the tacos were tiny for the price, and the dumplings were super soggy. All the cocktails I had were amazing though, so maybe just come here for a drink. The service was amazing, all servers and bartenders were extremely friendly and helpful plus there was a great DJ. The vibes were perfect, good place for a drinks date.
WOW was this place good! I'm giving it a 4.5 because I personally didn't like the drinks but I LOVED the food here.. The oxtail dumplings were so juicy and flavorful, the Dan Dan noodles were great. I can't wait to come back here because the food was stellar and they have a menu with a ton of delicious options that I can't wait to try in the future. The inside of this place is dark and cozy, but has seating as well as a bar. The service was also nice.
Love the food here and the atmosphere. Food had a nice kick so beware! The chill vives are great
What an amazing spot. Small but perfect menu with amazing flavors. Great drinks, great food and friendly service! Still dreaming about the steamed pork buns! They did tonight! All in all super cool place, will be a regular for sure!
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The waitress was sloppy, unprofessional, and had the audacity to charge an automatically charged gratuity of 20 percent. Never going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Nice atmosphere and cocktails.
Was there for a birthday party. Everyone was so lovely and the food was awesome. Thank you Sallys team! Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am very unhappy with this place because they added a 20% gratuity to the bill without my permission and requested tips when paying the bill. I don't recommend such places because it's just unacceptable. The customer should decide how much tip to leave based on their assessment of the service, and they provided no service yet included a 20% gratuity in my bill, plus requested tips! Are they even in their right mind?! I came here to relax after work, not to be taken advantage of! No way! I've definitely told all my friends in the area not to visit this place! I've never experienced such disrespect anywhere. Unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Guacamole
My friend and I had lunch at Sally's and while the food was good, it wasn't exceptional. Our server, however, was attentive and prompt. We found the cost to be expensive - $90+ for lunch for two wasn't worth it. Moreover, we did not like the mandatory 20% gratuity (which we would have left regardless) that was not disclosed unless it was on the menu and we overlooked it which was highly unlikely. Unfortunately it was an experience that neither of us would repeat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Tostones