Love the pepperoni slice in this neighborhood pizza joint. The guys are super nice in the shop
Maddie Reehl
Superb pizza. A real New York gem.
Natalia Paulino - Realtor
$10 and change for a slice and a can of lemon tea. Over priced.
Carlos Hernandez
Great local pizza joint with history in the neighborhood. Get my pizza All the time here.
Wanda Flores
It’s been a while since we have had good pizza, this place rocks. We also order pasta and it too was delicious. We truly enjoyed it. Also, love the fact they do local delivery, saved us money. Thanks Sal for keeping it real.
David Yee
Enjoyed a yummy thick Sicilian slice with a Manhattan Special Original in a nice small restaurant. Various flavors of Manhattan Special available. Its factory is nearby to buy direct. Took home lasagna, and it was just as good cold the next day. Totally love the Italian colors of the light post and hydrant outside this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
B. Evans
October 2024 AINT WHAT IT USE TO BE!
I called and asked for half eggplant pie and since it was 9:30pm- close to closing, I asked if it was too late. The girl asked the counter guys, then said it was fine, took my order and my money. I received an “ end of the day” pizza, that they cleaned off the cheese and slapped on eggplant and cold-uncooked ricotta cheese. It’s dry underneath and cold. The cheese was dry and hard. For $37 bucks.
I liked it better when Mimo and Nino were there. That’s how long I’ve been a customer. I’m going to Russ pizza from now on. What a shame!
P.S forgot to mention it was also burnt!
Read less
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jay Mar
This pizza died with all the flop in the world ? and I just bought it 6 mins ago. Not even warm. RIP to my pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Slice
maachinima maachinima
Great pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Lee
Sal’s is a spot I’ve been really enjoying. The staff is always super friendly and the pizza is delicious. I would recommend a slice of their white any day.
A slice being around $5 is a deal and I look forward to going to Sal’s again.
I always enjoy Sal’s pizza. I’ve been eating pizza here for many years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Lucas G
Way too expensive, $6 for an average slice of pizza
Bermise Alvarez
I ordered a chicken marsala and to say I was disappointed, is an understatement! This is far from chicken marsala! I am not even Italia and I am offended!! Posted a picture as proof
Food: 1
Joe John
Best pizza in NY
John Nunziata
Ordered a sandwich they sent the wrong one called back to tell them told me there's nothing they can do plus the people can't seem to understand englishWill never order from them again
Love the pepperoni slice in this neighborhood pizza joint. The guys are super nice in the shop
Superb pizza. A real New York gem.
$10 and change for a slice and a can of lemon tea. Over priced.
Great local pizza joint with history in the neighborhood. Get my pizza All the time here.
It’s been a while since we have had good pizza, this place rocks. We also order pasta and it too was delicious. We truly enjoyed it. Also, love the fact they do local delivery, saved us money. Thanks Sal for keeping it real.
Enjoyed a yummy thick Sicilian slice with a Manhattan Special Original in a nice small restaurant. Various flavors of Manhattan Special available. Its factory is nearby to buy direct. Took home lasagna, and it was just as good cold the next day. Totally love the Italian colors of the light post and hydrant outside this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
October 2024
AINT WHAT IT USE TO BE!
I called and asked for half eggplant pie and since it was 9:30pm- close to closing, I asked if it was too late. The girl asked the counter guys, then said it was fine, took my order and my money. I received an “ end of the day” pizza, that they cleaned off the cheese and slapped on eggplant and cold-uncooked ricotta cheese. It’s dry underneath and cold. The cheese was dry and hard. For $37 bucks.
I liked it better when Mimo and Nino were there. That’s how long I’ve been a customer. I’m going to Russ pizza from now on. What a shame!
P.S forgot to mention it was also burnt!
Read less
Food: 1
Service: 3
This pizza died with all the flop in the world ? and I just bought it 6 mins ago. Not even warm. RIP to my pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Slice
Great pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sal’s is a spot I’ve been really enjoying. The staff is always super friendly and the pizza is delicious. I would recommend a slice of their white any day.
A slice being around $5 is a deal and I look forward to going to Sal’s again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I always enjoy Sal’s pizza. I’ve been eating pizza here for many years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Way too expensive, $6 for an average slice of pizza
I ordered a chicken marsala and to say I was disappointed, is an understatement! This is far from chicken marsala! I am not even Italia and I am offended!! Posted a picture as proof
Food: 1
Best pizza in NY
Ordered a sandwich they sent the wrong one called back to tell them told me there's nothing they can do plus the people can't seem to understand englishWill never order from them again
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...