I had an unpleasant experience at Saraghina Café on Dekalb. I walked in and politely asked for a coffee, but the manager responded with an attitude, saying they were closed and that the coffee machine was down. His tone was unnecessarily rude and dismissive. Even after a brief back-and-forth, he showed no willingness to remedy the situation or communicate respectfully. As a Black customer, I couldn’t help but feel that I was being treated differently — it didn’t feel like a simple misunderstanding, but rather a lack of respect that may have been racially motivated. I hope the management reflects on how they treat guests of all backgrounds.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Louisa St. Pierre
Saraghina Caffe is a true gem in the heart of Fort Greene. We were warmly greeted by the owner, who I noticed chatted and laughed with many of the guests. I took my most Italian of Italian friends and they vouched for the authenticity and sheer deliciousness of the food. I opted for the beets and citrus starter, the salmon main course, and shared both tiramisu and probably the best chocolate mousse I’ve ever had. The impeccable timeless classic design, with wood paneling, brass, and a well stocked bar as centerpiece, has just the right amount of lighting, creating a cozy ambiance, perfect for a date or dinner with family / friends / colleagues. This is definitely in my top 3 in all 5 boroughs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Serita Wesley
This is about the manager! I don’t want to give this place a bad mark, but the manager was incredibly rude and presumptive to myself, my friend and our two dogs. Without us getting a word in, he abruptly approaches and says to us, who are stand on the other side of the gate and perhaps not waiting for a seat “no, absolutely not, your dogs are too big!” First of all, my dog is not too big…please see the photo of myself and my dog enjoying a lovely meal there just two weeks ago. I was taken aback by his tone, and after he thought about it, he did decide to accommodate us, but it was too late, we went to Evelina, and they were angels! The food was good too!
The servers at the caffe are great, the manager sucks!
MY REPLY -
I would like to edit my review in reply to the owner’s reply. Please be clear, the table you suggested was beautiful and perfectly fine. We did not accept due to the fact that you were extremely rude and abrupt, which is not an attitude I am accustomed to when dining at either location. Furthermore, your attitude and tone were highly inappropriate and almost ruined a beautiful Saturday. Have a blessed week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Alex Alvarez Claudio
Had a pizza which was great and the drinks were ok. However, the service was horrible. We never knew who our server was and were treated like second class in an EMPTY restaurant. Servers on their phones and had to wait upwards of 30 minutes to order, so ended up leaving. We asked for the check and left without ordering food. They were perplexed by it, even though they neglected us the whole time. Service has much room to be improved, hope they work on it cause the food was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Mike Ongkeo
Loving it 😍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jasmine Pierik
They tried but I could not help but leave a review…. We ordered a bunch of food and took NOTHING home after only a few bites of each…. Just inedible. Won’t be going back. Should have listened to the bad/real reviews apparently.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ash Yo
Cozy, but in the best possible way, neighborhood spot. Well stocked bar, great music, and a good mix of people in the restaurant. Vegan cheese option for the pizza if that’s your thing. Jamie at the bar was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amal
Brooklyn is known for its pizza, but this spot truly stands above the rest. From the first bite, you know you’re experiencing something special. The crust is perfection, crispy on the outside, light and airy inside, with just the right chew. The sauce tastes fresh and balanced, tangy with a hint of sweetness, and the cheese is rich, gooey, and melts into every corner of the slice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ann Wehren
Absolutely love this place for any time of day and any occasion! Romantic oysters, crudo, and martinis at the deco bar or for a family brunch with kids over pizzas, burgers, and spritzes. Best hollandaise around. They do not phone it in at brunch whatsoever. Best GF pizza in NY and I love how they differentiated the vibe and menu from their original location which I also frequent. For pizzas, go to the Bed Stuy location, for a bit more upscale experience with rawbar, treat yourself to the FG caffe. Love the staff. Only impeccable experiences! We need these independent gems that make our neighborhoods vibrant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Monica E Dingle
We scheduled ladies night in Bklyn. The restaurant we originally scheduled turned us away. We went to saraghina Caffe. What an amazing surprise. The service by Sophia was attentive. The swordfish was fresh. Branzino popped. Asparagus tasty, and gelato perfect. We will be back.
amazing location but terrible brunch. overcooked eggs with overly dry flavorless prosciutto. very small overpriced portions. aloof absent staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Juan Escobar
Saraghina Caffè is an amazing hidden gem just next to Fort Greene in Brooklyn. This Italian restaurant offers brunch until 3 PM, which gave us the perfect chance to mix things up—enjoying dishes like rigatoni, artichoke pizza, and avocado toast all in one sitting.
We were a party of six, including two kids, and the food came out quickly. Our server was fantastic, especially with the little ones, keeping them entertained with silly jokes and making the experience even more enjoyable. I’d definitely recommend this place for a relaxed, high-quality brunch with a friendly vibe.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bas Debbink
Lovely restaurant for breakfast and lunch and brunch. Outdoor seating is fantastic on a nice day and the food was exceptional. Service was fast and friendly. Will definitely be back here again and try some of the other dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Arensberg
Such a lovely experience! Our waiter was great and the food was delicious. My favorites from all that we ordered were the elderflower spritz, sbagliato, brussel sprouts, mushrooms & black truffle pizza, Milanese summer risotto, chocolate & hazelnut gelato, tiramisu, and the affogato. The gazpacho, ricotta, and spaghetti alla chitarra were also good. Saraghina is the perfect place for a relaxed and unhurried dinner experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marie Hagman
Stepping into this gem feels like entering a more delicious dimension, where the ingredients do all the talking. It’s refined without being fussy and somehow both casual and elegant at once.
We ordered with abandon and thank God we did! Every dish was a masterclass in restraint, balance, and so much flavor.
The burrata pizza was the showstopper, with its charred, chewy crust and creamy burrata pooling like mozzarella’s silkier cousin. It struck the perfect harmony between indulgent and airy. The bits of zesty sausage really made it sing.
The fritto misto was crisp perfection, light, not greasy. The wasabi mayo was so fresh and added nice zing.
Then came the saffron risotto, which was rich, golden, and impossibly comforting. It delivered big flavor with delicate technique, a warm hug in the form of rice. This is my new ultimate comfort food.
The meatballs were tender and pillowy, swimming in a tomato sauce that tasted like someone’s nonna made it.
We finished with mango passionfruit gelato and a tiramisu that could double as a religious experience. The gelato was tropical and vibrant, like sunshine in dessert form. The tiramisu was pillowy, not overly sweet, and laced with just the right hit of espresso. Hidden at the bottom was a crunchy surprise that added texture and flavor, completely unexpected and completely genius.
This is a place true foodies will appreciate. High-quality ingredients, cooked with love, presented without ego. Saraghina is what happens when someone takes Italian classics seriously but not themselves.
Already dreaming about our next visit. Or at least another round of that saffron risotto!
I had an unpleasant experience at Saraghina Café on Dekalb. I walked in and politely asked for a coffee, but the manager responded with an attitude, saying they were closed and that the coffee machine was down. His tone was unnecessarily rude and dismissive. Even after a brief back-and-forth, he showed no willingness to remedy the situation or communicate respectfully. As a Black customer, I couldn’t help but feel that I was being treated differently — it didn’t feel like a simple misunderstanding, but rather a lack of respect that may have been racially motivated. I hope the management reflects on how they treat guests of all backgrounds.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Saraghina Caffe is a true gem in the heart of Fort Greene. We were warmly greeted by the owner, who I noticed chatted and laughed with many of the guests. I took my most Italian of Italian friends and they vouched for the authenticity and sheer deliciousness of the food. I opted for the beets and citrus starter, the salmon main course, and shared both tiramisu and probably the best chocolate mousse I’ve ever had. The impeccable timeless classic design, with wood paneling, brass, and a well stocked bar as centerpiece, has just the right amount of lighting, creating a cozy ambiance, perfect for a date or dinner with family / friends / colleagues. This is definitely in my top 3 in all 5 boroughs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is about the manager! I don’t want to give this place a bad mark, but the manager was incredibly rude and presumptive to myself, my friend and our two dogs. Without us getting a word in, he abruptly approaches and says to us, who are stand on the other side of the gate and perhaps not waiting for a seat “no, absolutely not, your dogs are too big!” First of all, my dog is not too big…please see the photo of myself and my dog enjoying a lovely meal there just two weeks ago. I was taken aback by his tone, and after he thought about it, he did decide to accommodate us, but it was too late, we went to Evelina, and they were angels! The food was good too!
The servers at the caffe are great, the manager sucks!
MY REPLY -
I would like to edit my review in reply to the owner’s reply. Please be clear, the table you suggested was beautiful and perfectly fine. We did not accept due to the fact that you were extremely rude and abrupt, which is not an attitude I am accustomed to when dining at either location. Furthermore, your attitude and tone were highly inappropriate and almost ruined a beautiful Saturday. Have a blessed week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Had a pizza which was great and the drinks were ok. However, the service was horrible. We never knew who our server was and were treated like second class in an EMPTY restaurant. Servers on their phones and had to wait upwards of 30 minutes to order, so ended up leaving. We asked for the check and left without ordering food. They were perplexed by it, even though they neglected us the whole time. Service has much room to be improved, hope they work on it cause the food was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Loving it 😍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They tried but I could not help but leave a review…. We ordered a bunch of food and took NOTHING home after only a few bites of each…. Just inedible. Won’t be going back. Should have listened to the bad/real reviews apparently.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cozy, but in the best possible way, neighborhood spot. Well stocked bar, great music, and a good mix of people in the restaurant. Vegan cheese option for the pizza if that’s your thing. Jamie at the bar was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooklyn is known for its pizza, but this spot truly stands above the rest. From the first bite, you know you’re experiencing something special. The crust is perfection, crispy on the outside, light and airy inside, with just the right chew. The sauce tastes fresh and balanced, tangy with a hint of sweetness, and the cheese is rich, gooey, and melts into every corner of the slice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Absolutely love this place for any time of day and any occasion! Romantic oysters, crudo, and martinis at the deco bar or for a family brunch with kids over pizzas, burgers, and spritzes. Best hollandaise around. They do not phone it in at brunch whatsoever. Best GF pizza in NY and I love how they differentiated the vibe and menu from their original location which I also frequent. For pizzas, go to the Bed Stuy location, for a bit more upscale experience with rawbar, treat yourself to the FG caffe. Love the staff. Only impeccable experiences! We need these independent gems that make our neighborhoods vibrant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We scheduled ladies night in Bklyn. The restaurant we originally scheduled turned us away. We went to saraghina Caffe. What an amazing surprise. The service by Sophia was attentive. The swordfish was fresh. Branzino popped. Asparagus tasty, and gelato perfect. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
amazing location but terrible brunch. overcooked eggs with overly dry flavorless prosciutto. very small overpriced portions. aloof absent staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Saraghina Caffè is an amazing hidden gem just next to Fort Greene in Brooklyn. This Italian restaurant offers brunch until 3 PM, which gave us the perfect chance to mix things up—enjoying dishes like rigatoni, artichoke pizza, and avocado toast all in one sitting.
We were a party of six, including two kids, and the food came out quickly. Our server was fantastic, especially with the little ones, keeping them entertained with silly jokes and making the experience even more enjoyable. I’d definitely recommend this place for a relaxed, high-quality brunch with a friendly vibe.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely restaurant for breakfast and lunch and brunch. Outdoor seating is fantastic on a nice day and the food was exceptional. Service was fast and friendly. Will definitely be back here again and try some of the other dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a lovely experience! Our waiter was great and the food was delicious. My favorites from all that we ordered were the elderflower spritz, sbagliato, brussel sprouts, mushrooms & black truffle pizza, Milanese summer risotto, chocolate & hazelnut gelato, tiramisu, and the affogato. The gazpacho, ricotta, and spaghetti alla chitarra were also good. Saraghina is the perfect place for a relaxed and unhurried dinner experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stepping into this gem feels like entering a more delicious dimension, where the ingredients do all the talking. It’s refined without being fussy and somehow both casual and elegant at once.
We ordered with abandon and thank God we did! Every dish was a masterclass in restraint, balance, and so much flavor.
The burrata pizza was the showstopper, with its charred, chewy crust and creamy burrata pooling like mozzarella’s silkier cousin. It struck the perfect harmony between indulgent and airy. The bits of zesty sausage really made it sing.
The fritto misto was crisp perfection, light, not greasy. The wasabi mayo was so fresh and added nice zing.
Then came the saffron risotto, which was rich, golden, and impossibly comforting. It delivered big flavor with delicate technique, a warm hug in the form of rice. This is my new ultimate comfort food.
The meatballs were tender and pillowy, swimming in a tomato sauce that tasted like someone’s nonna made it.
We finished with mango passionfruit gelato and a tiramisu that could double as a religious experience. The gelato was tropical and vibrant, like sunshine in dessert form. The tiramisu was pillowy, not overly sweet, and laced with just the right hit of espresso. Hidden at the bottom was a crunchy surprise that added texture and flavor, completely unexpected and completely genius.
This is a place true foodies will appreciate. High-quality ingredients, cooked with love, presented without ego. Saraghina is what happens when someone takes Italian classics seriously but not themselves.
Already dreaming about our next visit. Or at least another round of that saffron risotto!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...