A little pricey but the pasta is great and there is a variety of pizza options.
Abe Abuhamdeh
We ordered a cheese pie, we got the delivery and as soon as we opened the box. There was aluminum foil on 4 out of the 8 slices. We called the location to let them know. They did not give 0 care. This pizza was made yesterday, over night they wrapped it in foil and reheated for delivery for next day. Again management gave 0 care about this situation. They did not offer a new fresh pie, or a refund. DO NOT GO TO THIS LOCATION.
Food: 1
Essa Hamda
Pieces of Aluminum foil all over the pizza. The kid at the pizzeria says its fresh pizza made. I am sure, it was wrapped in foil and thrown in the freezer. Never offered to remake a fresh pizza. Horrible, trust me not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christopher Z
The meatball pizza wasn't that bad, but it wasn't good enough to order a second time. Just average.
Food: 3
Adam Lord
Got two large cheese pies delivered. Maybe the worst pizza I've had in brooklyn. I would rather grab a slice from a high school cafeteria
Food: 1
Danica J.
This is probably the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I got four pies (BOGO) on uber eats, and I regret ordering from this place. Not only did the delivery guy handle my pizza poorly (see pics), but the pizza is not tasty. In fact, its just disgusting. I ordered a spinach pie and they clearly used frozen spinach, which is fine. But there's barely any cheese on the pizza, the.crust is soggy and it just.tastes terrible. I do not recommend this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Uzoma Emuchay
Order this from uber eats. This might be the worst tasting pizza I've had. I usually don't leave reviews. It was a by one get one free. I saw the rating, but still decided to give it a chance. Not worth the extra pizza.
Food: 1
Dark Blue Moon
Staff is unprofessional I paid 9.24 for two slices and garlic knots and I noticed a sign that says lunch special Mon-Fri 11-3 I bought my food at 2pm and the lady says since I already ordered 2 slices and 3 garlic knots I don’t get a drink, avoid this place not worth it for the disrespect you’ll receive
Belinda Uzcategui
Went Sergio pizza for first time sunday 5/4 the margarita pizza pie was delicious today Tuesday 5/6 order by phone to pick up there another margarita pizza and ii had a completely different flavor, it was really bad pizza. I called to ask if the pizza who made the pizza was a different guy from Sunday and the lady that work there need a customer service training. Never again
Cameron Finley
I live nearby so it’s easy for me to pop into Sergio’s. Unfortunately the person who’s usually there these days is rude and doesn’t do their job. I get it, I’ve worked some jobs like this and it can be taxing. I’m a polite customer and I tip really well and am always friendly. They’ve overcharged me and seem to always burn my pizza, or in some weird retaliation, not heat it at all.
As a local I've ordered from here for years from getting the 2 pizza deal for dinner to stopping in after school with the kids for lunch so to have a difficult time just getting a half cheese half pepperoni pizza is just bad service lol. It was already overpriced and tasteless, but not being able to accommodate customers on basic pizza orders in a world where some people don't eat pork is disrespectful.
Laurel Lenahan
Someone at this address stole my credit card info. Trashy, sketchy people own and/or are employed at this restaurant.
Crappy pizza, crappy people.
Tommy H
I love grabbing a few slices from here. I go with the kids after school. The pizza is really good. It's actually flavorful pizza 🍕. Top notch quality.
jose paulino
Pizza is extremely small for $3.50 each but they have a special that’s 2 slices and a drink for 7.88 after taxes it that helps
Wanda Johnson
I was in the mood for pizza, my spot I regularly go to was about to close soon so they ran out. I'm not a fan of Sergio Pizza. Their not consistent at all. Sometimes it's OK. I went there the other day, the crust was thin and hard and the pizza had no taste. Plus I don't know why their charging 3.88 for a slice of pizza that should be 99 cent. I won't be back.
A little pricey but the pasta is great and there is a variety of pizza options.
We ordered a cheese pie, we got the delivery and as soon as we opened the box. There was aluminum foil on 4 out of the 8 slices. We called the location to let them know. They did not give 0 care. This pizza was made yesterday, over night they wrapped it in foil and reheated for delivery for next day. Again management gave 0 care about this situation. They did not offer a new fresh pie, or a refund. DO NOT GO TO THIS LOCATION.
Food: 1
Pieces of Aluminum foil all over the pizza. The kid at the pizzeria says its fresh pizza made. I am sure, it was wrapped in foil and thrown in the freezer. Never offered to remake a fresh pizza. Horrible, trust me not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The meatball pizza wasn't that bad, but it wasn't good enough to order a second time. Just average.
Food: 3
Got two large cheese pies delivered. Maybe the worst pizza I've had in brooklyn. I would rather grab a slice from a high school cafeteria
Food: 1
This is probably the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I got four pies (BOGO) on uber eats, and I regret ordering from this place. Not only did the delivery guy handle my pizza poorly (see pics), but the pizza is not tasty. In fact, its just disgusting. I ordered a spinach pie and they clearly used frozen spinach, which is fine. But there's barely any cheese on the pizza, the.crust is soggy and it just.tastes terrible. I do not recommend this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Order this from uber eats. This might be the worst tasting pizza I've had. I usually don't leave reviews. It was a by one get one free. I saw the rating, but still decided to give it a chance. Not worth the extra pizza.
Food: 1
Staff is unprofessional I paid 9.24 for two slices and garlic knots and I noticed a sign that says lunch special Mon-Fri 11-3 I bought my food at 2pm and the lady says since I already ordered 2 slices and 3 garlic knots I don’t get a drink, avoid this place not worth it for the disrespect you’ll receive
Went Sergio pizza for first time sunday 5/4 the margarita pizza pie was delicious today Tuesday 5/6 order by phone to pick up there another margarita pizza and ii had a completely different flavor, it was really bad pizza. I called to ask if the pizza who made the pizza was a different guy from Sunday and the lady that work there need a customer service training. Never again
I live nearby so it’s easy for me to pop into Sergio’s. Unfortunately the person who’s usually there these days is rude and doesn’t do their job. I get it, I’ve worked some jobs like this and it can be taxing. I’m a polite customer and I tip really well and am always friendly. They’ve overcharged me and seem to always burn my pizza, or in some weird retaliation, not heat it at all.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
As a local I've ordered from here for years from getting the 2 pizza deal for dinner to stopping in after school with the kids for lunch so to have a difficult time just getting a half cheese half pepperoni pizza is just bad service lol. It was already overpriced and tasteless, but not being able to accommodate customers on basic pizza orders in a world where some people don't eat pork is disrespectful.
Someone at this address stole my credit card info. Trashy, sketchy people own and/or are employed at this restaurant.
Crappy pizza, crappy people.
I love grabbing a few slices from here. I go with the kids after school. The pizza is really good. It's actually flavorful pizza 🍕. Top notch quality.
Pizza is extremely small for $3.50 each but they have a special that’s 2 slices and a drink for 7.88 after taxes it that helps
I was in the mood for pizza, my spot I regularly go to was about to close soon so they ran out. I'm not a fan of Sergio Pizza. Their not consistent at all. Sometimes it's OK. I went there the other day, the crust was thin and hard and the pizza had no taste. Plus I don't know why their charging 3.88 for a slice of pizza that should be
99 cent. I won't be back.
Loading...