Came for the Bakery had a very minimal was very dissapointed by the selection and was charged 8 dollars for a bottle of water. Don't bother coming here for the sweets. Go to la sweets next door instead.
Karen Gagliano
I had an Easter Pie (grain pie) delivered by Goldbelly, it was wonderful. After 3 tries because of UPS delivery problems. Such a sin to throw out all that good food. But it is the best pie. The flavor is like when i was young in NYC, in the 50's and 60's . ** But please take note, the ad in Goldbelly is incorrect. It says 2 pounds. It is 5 pounds. This should be corrected so that people realize how much they actually get for the price.
Diana Aguilar
Oh my God! Give me anything raspberry filled from this bakery!!! The tricolor raspberry filled croissant đ±. The Panettone.....all kinds! The St. Joseph's cream-filled Pastries! All to die for! And the standard pastries and breads are wonderful as well! You cannot go wrong with anything from this bakery! Highly recommend!
I ordered the Torta Mimosa mini and large cakes on 3/8/25. My family and I were pleasantly impressed because they were simply delicious! Superb and very scrumptious cakes Bilena!
Augusto Laspina
Settepani Bakery truly embodies the spirit of a family-run business in every way. Bilena and her family are incredibly welcoming, and itâs clear they pour their hearts into what they do. The quality of their baked goods is exceptionalâeach item is made with care and passion. As a proud Sicilian, I couldnât recommend Settepani Bakery enough. If youâre looking for authentic, top-tier pastries, this is the place to visit. Keep up the fantastic work!
Unfortunately the rainbow cookie panettone did not live up to the hype. Did not taste like panettone. Honestly didnât taste like rainbow cookie either. It was so lack luster and flavorless. It was beautiful to look at though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Enrico Scotto rosAto
Not on italiano bakery This is on American bakery đ§ Beware not Italian bakery
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jackie Gordon Singing Chef
Get the panettone! Someone gave me a slice last Christmas and it's been on my list to visit this bakery ever since and I finally made it!
The pistachio chocolate chip with pistachio cream is the bomb!!!
What's great is you can buy full size panettone and baby panettone. We also got the amaretto and chocolate chip which was very nice as well.
I also got the stollen which has chunks of almond paste in it. I got a drier Christmas cake that I don't remember the name of as well.
Cut them up and serve them at a party and everyone loved them!
They also have a zillion other kinds of pastries and cookies and goodies, plus coffee and hot chocolates.
Iâve never been a pie personâuntil I had Settepaniâs pumpkin pie. After comparing several pies from local bakeries, this one blew the competition out of the water. The crust? Perfectly flaky, not too thick, just the right amount of buttery goodness. The filling? A smooth, creamy dream that isnât overwhelmed by spices or sugar. Itâs like they bottled fall in a slice.
Before this, pumpkin pie was just "meh" to me. Now? I'm hooked. Settepaniâs fresh batches have officially converted me into a pumpkin pie lover. If you havenât tried it yet, youâre seriously missing out.1000000/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Croissant, Carrot Cake, Cannoli, Rainbow Cookies
Sun Day
Lattes were in point. The Apple and apricot tarts were cold, rock hard and lacked any discernible flavour. Gross.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Suzanne K
I ordered a rainbow panettone for my husband for Christmas. He is from Brooklyn, we currently live in pennsylvania. This was a huge disappointment. Nothing like what was advertised. Very dry,open inside and cookies on the top were horrible dry& I think they ran out,we only had a few pieces. $80 waste. My husband said "is this a joke?!"...sorry. Christmas fail.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jessica Zarian
After seeing their panettone on TikTok, I had to get my own! I purchased three large for Christmas Eve, but also added in this mini one for my husband and I to try right away! The owner suggested the âflavors of Italyâ, which was her personal favorite, and I have to say it was the most delicious thing I have ever tried! It had a creamy center, chocolate chips, and was incredibly moist! My husband immediately asked me if we really needed to have three at Christmas Eve or if we could just get away with one and eat the others now- Love the father/daughter duo- They are adorable! Highly recommend- Also the packaging is just to die for so these make fantastic gifts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
elizabeth vargas
Kid-friendliness: # 1 fan I will recommend 100 % this bakery to every one I know
Came for the Bakery had a very minimal was very dissapointed by the selection and was charged 8 dollars for a bottle of water. Don't bother coming here for the sweets. Go to la sweets next door instead.
I had an Easter Pie (grain pie) delivered by Goldbelly, it was wonderful. After 3 tries because of UPS delivery problems. Such a sin to throw out all that good food. But it is the best pie. The flavor is like when i was young in NYC, in the 50's and 60's .
** But please take note, the ad in Goldbelly is incorrect. It says 2 pounds. It is 5 pounds. This should be corrected so that people realize how much they actually get for the price.
Oh my God! Give me anything raspberry filled from this bakery!!! The tricolor raspberry filled croissant đ±. The Panettone.....all kinds! The St. Joseph's cream-filled
Pastries! All to die for! And the standard pastries and breads are wonderful as well! You cannot go wrong with anything from this bakery! Highly recommend!
This cafĂ© is very expensive. We ordered two small pistachio tarts and two large coffees; however, their âlargeâ is smaller than Starbucksâ Tall cup. The tarts taste like margarine and we couldn't even ate them. We paid 32 bucks. Don't waste your money.
I ordered the Torta Mimosa mini and large cakes on 3/8/25. My family and I were pleasantly impressed because they were simply delicious! Superb and very scrumptious cakes Bilena!
Settepani Bakery truly embodies the spirit of a family-run business in every way. Bilena and her family are incredibly welcoming, and itâs clear they pour their hearts into what they do. The quality of their baked goods is exceptionalâeach item is made with care and passion. As a proud Sicilian, I couldnât recommend Settepani Bakery enough. If youâre looking for authentic, top-tier pastries, this is the place to visit. Keep up the fantastic work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Biscotti, Rainbow Cookie Croissant, Cannoli, Rainbow Cookies, Pistachio Panettone
delicious panettone!
Unfortunately the rainbow cookie panettone did not live up to the hype. Did not taste like panettone. Honestly didnât taste like rainbow cookie either. It was so lack luster and flavorless. It was beautiful to look at though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Not on italiano bakery
This is on American bakery đ§
Beware not Italian bakery
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Get the panettone! Someone gave me a slice last Christmas and it's been on my list to visit this bakery ever since and I finally made it!
The pistachio chocolate chip with pistachio cream is the bomb!!!
What's great is you can buy full size panettone and baby panettone. We also got the amaretto and chocolate chip which was very nice as well.
I also got the stollen which has chunks of almond paste in it. I got a drier Christmas cake that I don't remember the name of as well.
Cut them up and serve them at a party and everyone loved them!
They also have a zillion other kinds of pastries and cookies and goodies, plus coffee and hot chocolates.
Definitely check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Panettone
Restaurantji Recommends
Settepani Bakery Pumpkin Pie: A Game Changer
Iâve never been a pie personâuntil I had Settepaniâs pumpkin pie. After comparing several pies from local bakeries, this one blew the competition out of the water. The crust? Perfectly flaky, not too thick, just the right amount of buttery goodness. The filling? A smooth, creamy dream that isnât overwhelmed by spices or sugar. Itâs like they bottled fall in a slice.
Before this, pumpkin pie was just "meh" to me. Now? I'm hooked. Settepaniâs fresh batches have officially converted me into a pumpkin pie lover. If you havenât tried it yet, youâre seriously missing out.1000000/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Croissant, Carrot Cake, Cannoli, Rainbow Cookies
Lattes were in point. The Apple and apricot tarts were cold, rock hard and lacked any discernible flavour. Gross.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
I ordered a rainbow panettone for my husband for Christmas. He is from Brooklyn, we currently live in pennsylvania. This was a huge disappointment. Nothing like what was advertised. Very dry,open inside and cookies on the top were horrible dry& I think they ran out,we only had a few pieces. $80 waste. My husband said "is this a joke?!"...sorry. Christmas fail.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
After seeing their panettone on TikTok, I had to get my own! I purchased three large for Christmas Eve, but also added in this mini one for my husband and I to try right away! The owner suggested the âflavors of Italyâ, which was her personal favorite, and I have to say it was the most delicious thing I have ever tried! It had a creamy center, chocolate chips, and was incredibly moist! My husband immediately asked me if we really needed to have three at Christmas Eve or if we could just get away with one and eat the others now-
Love the father/daughter duo- They are adorable!
Highly recommend- Also the packaging is just to die for so these make fantastic gifts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Kid-friendliness: # 1 fan I will recommend 100 % this bakery to every one I know
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli
Loading...