Sicily's Best

190 Cypress Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 456-1833

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matty Tuzynski

Great underrated pizza. Crust isn't too thick or floury, and slightly crunchy yet soft inside (a lot of newer places burn the crust way too much for the aesthetic look). Tomato sauce slight sweet and not over seasoned. Cheese is flavorful and perfectly proportioned. One of the best slices you can get in the neighborhood; a quintessential classic slice (leagues above your 99¢ places, but not unnecessarily beautified like a lot newer, gentrified places would make).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

fernando ortiz

The worst fettuccine alfredo I've ever eaten in my life. Look at that, it looks like it's all butter. , nastyy

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Ica Gonzalez

Always attentive with Customers , pizza fresh I love there Pasta and white pizza .

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Magnetic 357

Not to freindly!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Alvaro Imbrett

If I can say one thing this place was very underwhelming and disappointing. The white slice was more bread than cheese. It seems like they were saving money by making light slice. The worst part were the bland wonder bread like garlic knots.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Mustache

Not a professional place at all, in terms of counter service.
My family often orders here a lot and I'm not talking a small order but $80 to $100 in food, from pizza to pasta plates.
The issue occured when I sent in my wife In person for the first time to order us specialty slices.
My wife ordered 1 margarita slice, 1 plain slice, 1 ceasar chicken slice & 1 buffalo chicken slice.
The issue was the slices were so small to be labeled a specialty slice and it wasn't fresh at all, I can understand if I came during closing but it was early noon.
Now the main issue is generally when I order a buffalo slice they usually give me a drizzle of ranch right on top.
This guy had the audacity to charge my wife a $1.50 for a side of ranch. Why would I need 6 ounces of ranch for one buffalo slice ?
Not only that my wife stated the guy had a bad attitude And I'm going to make a big assumption that this guy is hindering your business regarding food quality and customer service because the food quality hasn't been up to par from when we first ordered and now it cost you.
Oh and btw yes I'm 270.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

jia-lian Lin

I got a few slices here. The regular cheese slice is good but nothing special. I can’t say much good about their Sicilian slice though. Probably the worst Sicilian slice I’ve had. It literally just tasted like thick bread with sauce and cheese on it. Usually the combo of it together is more than the sum of its parts but not this time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Bruno Valenzuela

They drop your food and still give it to you after. Trash

Shaina

The flavor was good but my chicken roll dough was raw and I specifically said well done.

Diana Malinsky

Came here on a whim after a playgym with 3 hungry kids. Owner was very nice, pizza came out fast and delicious roughly 10 min. Owner was kind enough to add in zeppoles for the kids. Would recommend to come here again. Thank you

Bruce Rodriguez

Ordered delivery from this place on a whim and is hands down, the best pizzeria I've had in the Bushwick area. Everything they cook is great quality from the pizza and sandwiches to their pasta dishes. I ordered for my family and the pizza was excellent with a great cheese to sauce ratio and had tons of flavor, I give it a 8.9. Their pasta is delicious with perfect aldente, portions, and flavor. I've tried the fettuccine alfredo and lasagna with meatballs. Not to mention, they provided top notch customer service remembering every single detail of my large order, always clear with time, and fair prices.

Fine Painting NY

Great pizzeria 🇮🇹

Charlie Tiberio

Apparently I never had a REAL Sicilian square until I came here... I got a vodka Sicilian slice and it totally blew my mind. Other places serve thick, dry bread with some cheese on top and call it a sicilian slice. This place is the real deal, the inner crust structure melts in your mouth and I would recommend this place to anyone

Vegetarian options: Wide variety of vegetarian slices

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Kaitlyn

Best PIZZA in the world.
The owner is super nice and cares about his customers They were getting ready to close and he offer us a table outside while they clean inside.
The workers were the best and made sure we had everything to be comfortable outside.
Again THANK YOU SO MUCH.

Zarek Simonson

Cheese like plastic crust like cardboard

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...