great Bagel with good Tofu Spread. My husband had a Pizza Bagel wich was nice, i had an everything bagel with vegetable tofu spread wich was delicious and very filling. staff was really friendly
Bimini Wright
This place is great. They’re always friendly, prompt, and the bagels are SO
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagels
Patrice Rascasse
I've been to this place during our visit in Oct 2024. Smith Street Bagels offers a huge variety of sandwiches and bagels. Customers have a large choice of spreads, almost too many to try. All of the ones we chose were very delicious.
The place offers seating inside and outside. Therefore, it was super chill to place our order and enjoy the bagels on the bench in front of the store.
Our special thanks goes to Monique, working the register. She treated us with such hospitality, patience and kindness. She made us feel really welcome during our stay, just like the entire staff, that is friendly and dedicated to provide the best service and food they can.
Thank you very much for making during our trip to NYC so much better. Would love to come back anytime. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brett Dunie Neustadt
Very, very solid everything bagel with a great crispy outside to fluffy inside ratio. Good everything mix. Cheddar jalepeno cream cheese was quite tasty and very jale forward as it should be!
Lana G
Went to order their Sandwich platter they have listed on their menu for $65. Staff didn't know know how many sandwiches are in the plater. After a lot of back and forth, was told that there are 10 sandwiches. Proceed to order 3 platters. All of a sudden, they had to check with the manager. Again, after waiting for a good while was told that the manager doesn't want to give 10 sandwiches but they will check with her again. The manager never came out to resolve the issue. They claim that the menu is for online ordering, which, btw is also a scam, because in the process of ordering, they DOUBLE the advertised price. Very unprofessional and deceiving practices.
Service: 1
Katie Peinovich
Avoid. The coffee was bad and I waited 25 min for a bagel with cream cheese. When I unwrapped my bagel there was green stuff smeared across both halves, which I assume means they didn’t clean the knife in between orders, so I tossed it. So many other places to get good bagels in Brooklyn.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Emma
Thankful for the vegan options but wish they didn’t mess them up with real meat.
Eleven 888
ve to say that I have been a customer of this store for more than 10 years and I feel happy with the new changes... I no longer have to put up with the rude and rude attitude of the cashier... the new management of the store is simply exceptional, the store looks cleaner, more organized and the attitude of the workers (despite how super busy they are) is wonderful.. thanks to the owner for the new changes ..!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rainbow Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese, Bagels
Janelle Ibaven
The staff is great and work hard to provide you with the best service.
Dietary restrictions: They are very careful and detailed to get any food aversions taken care of.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagels
Matt
Whoever makes their sandwiches seems to have never made a sandwich before. I ordered an egg and cheese bagel with avocado and tomatoes. They forgot the eggs and just put raw cheese and tomatoes on a bagel and smeared a spoonful of guacamole on it and called it a day. I tried to call and have them fix it but no one answered the phone.
Super average bagel. My bacon was bland and sort of half-cooked. Bagels were slightly stale. If you're looking for a respectable New York bagel, you won't find it here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
John B
I want this place to be great because a). I like their bagels and b). they're a local spot. But having ordered from here several times, the order is always messed up. I'm certain it's the cook staff, as I can see the employees taking down my order exactly as specified. In the end the condiments/cheese/bagel/meat/toppings are always missing or incorrect.
I really just think there needs to be some quick QA before handing off the order. Otherwise I can only recommend ordering the bagels as is.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Régis Pereira
It was a surprise. Best bagel ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rosemarie Vaudo Aridas
Delivered perfectly correct order at exactly time requested!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ronald Lee
This place was THE place for Bagels. Unfortunately it’s come down in quality and service over time.
They can’t seem to get two things right:
1. Consistency of their bagels (they have fluctuated over the years). I think it started after they bought out Court St.? I don’t know why, but they used to have the best bagels, and I miss it.
2. Getting an order correct. It’s been a while since we’ve received exactly what we ordered (onsite or delivery). There’s a huge disconnect between the servers and cashiers. Process is just broken.
Lastly, if you’re looking for quiet/relaxing place, better to take out. Place especially when busy is chaotic and anxiety inducing.
great Bagel with good Tofu Spread. My husband had a Pizza Bagel wich was nice, i had an everything bagel with vegetable tofu spread wich was delicious and very filling. staff was really friendly
This place is great. They’re always friendly, prompt, and the bagels are SO
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagels
I've been to this place during our visit in Oct 2024. Smith Street Bagels offers a huge variety of sandwiches and bagels. Customers have a large choice of spreads, almost too many to try. All of the ones we chose were very delicious.
The place offers seating inside and outside. Therefore, it was super chill to place our order and enjoy the bagels on the bench in front of the store.
Our special thanks goes to Monique, working the register. She treated us with such hospitality, patience and kindness. She made us feel really welcome during our stay, just like the entire staff, that is friendly and dedicated to provide the best service and food they can.
Thank you very much for making during our trip to NYC so much better. Would love to come back anytime. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very, very solid everything bagel with a great crispy outside to fluffy inside ratio. Good everything mix. Cheddar jalepeno cream cheese was quite tasty and very jale forward as it should be!
Went to order their Sandwich platter they have listed on their menu for $65. Staff didn't know know how many sandwiches are in the plater. After a lot of back and forth, was told that there are 10 sandwiches. Proceed to order 3 platters. All of a sudden, they had to check with the manager. Again, after waiting for a good while was told that the manager doesn't want to give 10 sandwiches but they will check with her again. The manager never came out to resolve the issue. They claim that the menu is for online ordering, which, btw is also a scam, because in the process of ordering, they DOUBLE the advertised price.
Very unprofessional and deceiving practices.
Service: 1
Avoid. The coffee was bad and I waited 25 min for a bagel with cream cheese. When I unwrapped my bagel there was green stuff smeared across both halves, which I assume means they didn’t clean the knife in between orders, so I tossed it. So many other places to get good bagels in Brooklyn.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Thankful for the vegan options but wish they didn’t mess them up with real meat.
ve to say that I have been a customer of this store for more than 10 years and I feel happy with the new changes... I no longer have to put up with the rude and rude attitude of the cashier... the new management of the store is simply exceptional, the store looks cleaner, more organized and the attitude of the workers (despite how super busy they are) is wonderful.. thanks to the owner for the new changes ..!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rainbow Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese, Bagels
The staff is great and work hard to provide you with the best service.
Dietary restrictions: They are very careful and detailed to get any food aversions taken care of.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagels
Whoever makes their sandwiches seems to have never made a sandwich before. I ordered an egg and cheese bagel with avocado and tomatoes. They forgot the eggs and just put raw cheese and tomatoes on a bagel and smeared a spoonful of guacamole on it and called it a day. I tried to call and have them fix it but no one answered the phone.
Restaurantji Recommends
Super average bagel. My bacon was bland and sort of half-cooked. Bagels were slightly stale. If you're looking for a respectable New York bagel, you won't find it here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
I want this place to be great because a). I like their bagels and b). they're a local spot. But having ordered from here several times, the order is always messed up. I'm certain it's the cook staff, as I can see the employees taking down my order exactly as specified. In the end the condiments/cheese/bagel/meat/toppings are always missing or incorrect.
I really just think there needs to be some quick QA before handing off the order. Otherwise I can only recommend ordering the bagels as is.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
It was a surprise. Best bagel ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delivered perfectly correct order at exactly time requested!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was THE place for Bagels. Unfortunately it’s come down in quality and service over time.
They can’t seem to get two things right:
1. Consistency of their bagels (they have fluctuated over the years). I think it started after they bought out Court St.? I don’t know why, but they used to have the best bagels, and I miss it.
2. Getting an order correct. It’s been a while since we’ve received exactly what we ordered (onsite or delivery). There’s a huge disconnect between the servers and cashiers. Process is just broken.
Lastly, if you’re looking for quiet/relaxing place, better to take out. Place especially when busy is chaotic and anxiety inducing.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Bagels
Loading...