Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Steve's Key Lime Pie has a lot of hype around it and a line to match, but the line moved fast.

I am giving it a three because while the pie and Limeaide I had were good, when it comes to Key Lime Pie I just prefer something more tart.

I want a key lime pie where the tartness hits you in the face just a little bit.

Glad I finally went, won't be rushing back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Maris & Gerry are wonderful worker's and I bet they deal with a lot haha 😄 they handle customers like a pro and they do so with fast service and a smile during these hard times I'm just a little upset that after ALL this time now the owners decide to raise the prices on everything and I thought it was a rip off getting charged extra just for whip cream because it does go together with key lime just be prepared to shell out more $$$five bucks for small and $10 for Large .. yikes that's a lot they should open a few cans throughout the day to offerto those unfortunate that maybe can't afford a whole can whip cream or have no use for whole can if just ordering 1 small treat WHERES THE SENSE and coffee are you nuts next time I'll bring my own haha. Their kind of charging more than bodegas Stores for a 1 SIZE SMALL coffee ughhhh so though treats are soooo delicious I unfortunately come from a far where I'm paying dam tolls & bridges for a treat 😋 times are getting rough friends but definitely worth the time drive & money for a flavorful experience in your mouth & comfort to the max when enjoying hot coffee ☕️ & whipped key lime pie 🥧 baby ENJOY friends 😉 please try bringing prices down owners!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rating: 7.5/10
Date Last Visited: 9/6/2025

We ordered the Raspberry Chocolate Swingle ($9.50) and La Victoria Swingle ($9.50). The swingles are individual servings of key lime pie dipped and coated in chocolate. The raspberry swingle was delicious - there was a good balance between the raspberry jam and key lime pie plus chocolate. It tasted exactly like what you would expect a chocolate dipped key lime pie to taste like. The La Victoria had a spicy kick to it, and I personally was not a fan. It’s takeout only but the surrounding area has nice views. Overall, if you’re a fan of key lime pie and chocolate, this place is worth a visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Raspberry Swingle

Sick key lime pies, very old school, un corporate feel.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Deep in Red Hook, right by the water! Grabbed a couple of tarts for after dinner dessert. Great taste, nice and sour, the pie crust gave it some texture and was perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Key lime pie was delicious. Get the 10” because the 8” isn’t big enough.

I’ve been coming here for years and they have easily the best key lime pie in NYC. Their pies come in a variety of sizes with from personal minis to large. They also have some unique offerings including chocolate dipped frozen mini pies on a stick and ones either raspberry filling, all of which are delicious.

The location is also lovely with a variety of outdoor picnic seating as well as direct park and pier access so you can enjoy your pie with a waterfront view. Highly recommend everyone tries this spot at least once, you won’t regret it.

location is also unique great spot. You are basically taking it to go and either eating on the picnic tables or taking it home.

The pie is excellent, and available in personal size or larger pies.

Their crust is a blend of professionally perfect and hometown rustic. The texture of the key lime custard I would put up against a Michelin star restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Has gelatin

Hidden gem

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tasted great, rude cashier

Tried the “famous” key lime “pie” on a stick with chocolate and raspberry. Honestly, it was just OK. Three bites and it was gone, and the actual key lime flavor barely showed. But there was a weird aftertaste that lingered way too long. Long line out the door, but probably more about Instagram hype than substance. Not worth the wait, and I wouldn’t go back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

If you are a fan of KeyLime pie then you need to come here , their chocolate dipped keylime pies are delicious and the view only adds to the total experience , highly recommend !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a gem!!!!!! The key lime is awesome!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

cute spot to have a key pie lime ice crem, and walk to the pier.

it was too sweet for our liking. its kind of hard to finish one by yourself but its not shareable either.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

The original pie is the best, ice cream options are fun on a hot day but the unique flavors get lost. So, yeah, keep with the original.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5