Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn
(718) 858-5333

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

La Victoria Key Lime Pie with Chipotle Puree on a Stick
Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Raspberry White Chocolate Key Lime Pie
Dark Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie
The Raspberry Swingle
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
4 Single-Serve Tart
The Classic Swingle
Famous Tart Frozen

Menu

Featured items
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
Our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-formed Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves eight. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
A smaller version of our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-made Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves four. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted 4-inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Blonde
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Box of Ten 4-Inch Tarts
Five over five, eat some now and freeze some later. Perfect portion control for a gathering with easy plating. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten Free Classic Swingle
Same chocolate-dipped Swingle delight but placed in an in-house 100% Gluten-free crust. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Authentic Key Lime Pies
4-Inch Key Lime Tart
A perfect single-serve portion for one. Exactly the same as our larger pies just scaled down. Typically serves one. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
Our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-formed Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves eight. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
A smaller version of our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-made Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves four. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Box of Ten 4-Inch Tarts
Five over five, eat some now and freeze some later. Perfect portion control for a gathering with easy plating. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Our Renowned Swingles
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted 4-inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Blonde
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The LaVictoria
Same as the Classic but topped with a layer of La Morena chipotle purree before hand-dipping in chocolate. Feel the heat. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Gluten Free
Gluten-Free 8-Inch Key Lime Pie*
Our famous key lime custard placed in a delicious in-house hand-formed buttery gluten-free crust. Typically serves 4. *Available frozen ONLY. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten Free Classic Swingle
Same chocolate-dipped Swingle delight but placed in an in-house 100% Gluten-free crust. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten-Free 10-Inch Key Lime Pie*
Our famous key lime custard placed in a delicious in-house hand-formed buttery gluten-free crust. Typically serves 8. *Available frozen ONLY. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Farmland Whipped Cream
7-Oz. Farmland Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream, so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 8-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.
14-Oz. Farmland Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream, so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 10-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+47 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Steve's Key Lime Pie has a lot of hype around it and a line to match, but the line moved fast.

I am giving it a three because while the pie and Limeaide I had were good, when it comes to Key Lime Pie I just prefer something more tart.

I want a key lime pie where the tartness hits you in the face just a little bit.

Glad I finally went, won't be rushing back.
September 2025
Maris & Gerry are wonderful worker's and I bet they deal with a lot haha 😄 they handle customers like a pro and they do so with fast service and a smile during these hard times I'm just a little upset that after ALL this time now the owners decide to raise the prices on everything and I thought it was a rip off getting charged extra just for whip cream because it does go together with key lime just be prepared to shell out more $$$five bucks for small and $10...
September 2025
Rating: 7.5/10
Date Last Visited: 9/6/2025

We ordered the Raspberry Chocolate Swingle ($9.50) and La Victoria Swingle ($9.50). The swingles are individual servings of key lime pie dipped and coated in chocolate. The raspberry swingle was delicious - there was a good balance between the raspberry jam and key lime pie plus chocolate. It tasted exactly like what you would expect a chocolate dipped key lime pie to taste like. The La Victoria had a spicy...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Strong Rope Brewery Red Hook - 185 Van Dyke St
Brewery, Pet Friendly, Brewpubs
Hoek Pizza - 117 Ferris St
Pizza, Bar, Salad, Vegan
The Red Hook Winery - SOUTH SIDE OF PIER, 175 Van Dyke St Pier 41 Suite 325A
Wineries, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 858-5333