Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn
(718) 858-5333

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

La Victoria Key Lime Pie with Chipotle Puree on a Stick
Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Raspberry White Chocolate Key Lime Pie
Dark Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie
The Raspberry Swingle
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
4 Single-Serve Tart
The Classic Swingle
Famous Tart Frozen

Menu

Featured items
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
Our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-formed Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves eight. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
A smaller version of our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-made Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves four. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted 4-inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Blonde
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Box of Ten 4-Inch Tarts
Five over five, eat some now and freeze some later. Perfect portion control for a gathering with easy plating. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten Free Classic Swingle
Same chocolate-dipped Swingle delight but placed in an in-house 100% Gluten-free crust. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Authentic Key Lime Pies
4-Inch Key Lime Tart
A perfect single-serve portion for one. Exactly the same as our larger pies just scaled down. Typically serves one. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
Our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-formed Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves eight. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
8-Inch Key Lime Pie
A smaller version of our classic, authentic key lime pie. Our "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-made Graham-crumb and butter crust. Typically serves four. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Box of Ten 4-Inch Tarts
Five over five, eat some now and freeze some later. Perfect portion control for a gathering with easy plating. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Our Renowned Swingles
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted 4-inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The Raspberry Blonde
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
The LaVictoria
Same as the Classic but topped with a layer of La Morena chipotle purree before hand-dipping in chocolate. Feel the heat. *Contains WHEAT, EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Gluten Free
Gluten-Free 8-Inch Key Lime Pie*
Our famous key lime custard placed in a delicious in-house hand-formed buttery gluten-free crust. Typically serves 4. *Available frozen ONLY. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten Free Classic Swingle
Same chocolate-dipped Swingle delight but placed in an in-house 100% Gluten-free crust. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.
Gluten-Free 10-Inch Key Lime Pie*
Our famous key lime custard placed in a delicious in-house hand-formed buttery gluten-free crust. Typically serves 8. *Available frozen ONLY. *Contains EGGS, MILK. *We operate in a 100% nut-free facility.

Farmland Whipped Cream
7-Oz. Farmland Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream, so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 8-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.
14-Oz. Farmland Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream, so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 10-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Dissappointed after going well out of my way to try it based on a number of very positive reviews. The pie is good but not great and certainly not worth going out of your way for and expensive for what it is. Better options available elsewhere in the city.
December 2025
Steve's Key Lime Pie has a lot of hype around it and a line to match, but the line moved fast.

I am giving it a three because while the pie and Limeaide I had were good, when it comes to Key Lime Pie I just prefer something more tart.

I want a key lime pie where the tartness hits you in the face just a little bit.

Glad I finally went, won't be rushing back.
September 2025
Maris & Gerry are wonderful worker's and I bet they deal with a lot haha 😄 they handle customers like a pro and they do so with fast service and a smile during these hard times I'm just a little upset that after ALL this time now the owners decide to raise the prices on everything and I thought it was a rip off getting charged extra just for whip cream because it does go together with key lime just be prepared to shell out more $$$five bucks for small and $10...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Strong Rope Brewery Red Hook - 185 Van Dyke St
Brewery, Pet Friendly, Brewpubs
Hoek Pizza - 117 Ferris St
Pizza, Bar, Salad, Vegan
The Red Hook Winery - SOUTH SIDE OF PIER, 175 Van Dyke St Pier 41 Suite 325A
Wineries, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 858-5333