SUGARFISH Williamsburg

157 Wythe Ave, Brooklyn
(929) 489-0301

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Kleinerman

As regulars, our latest visit felt a bit off. With lots of new staff, the service was confusing and food pacing inconsistent. The quality is always great, but we missed the usual seamless experience we've come to love.

N M

Food is always amazing ! Jack is super rude and unfriendly. Hope I came on an off day and he doesn’t usually treat client the way he interacted w us.

Caity Bk

First time at this location. Skill and presentation fell short compared to their other establishments. Rice fell apart and didn’t hold well. I fear with the increase of locations, standards are being compromised.

Angie Lee

A casual sushi place🩷 nice setting, just comfortable and easy! sushi melts in your mouth☺️

Violette Trotter

My boyfriend and I always do date night at this Sugarfish location, and they have always been so kind and accommodating to us. Allison the manager is fantastic, and always goes above and beyond. The food is excellent for the price and has definitely become a staple for us. Thank you for all you do, we appreciate you so much!

Veronica

Always, ALWAYS consistently DELICIOUS! the freshest fish I've ever had! This is my go-to restaurant because it never disappoints! Not sure why they don't have a 5 star review but they deff get one from me! The staff is always so friendly and welcoming! Everyone I bring here loves it!

A G

Love SUGARFISH! Can’t say anything bad about this place. Wait times can be long during busy times and you won’t be seated unless your whole group is present.
Can’t go wrong with anything you decide to order. If it’s your first time take their waiter’s recommendation you won’t regret it.

Jeremy Hayz

This place isn't for MEN, it's for tiny little boys and high school kids. The portions are way too small to feed a normal eating man. They bring the food in Bird Size portions almost insulting like to see how stupid someone can be dine here. Almost like a social experiment. Service is whack, very scripted and no emotions. Typical Sushi joint decoration so nothing so special here. If you're into not being able to feast and eat like a king this place IS NOT FOR YOU. I asked for Siracha, was responded we don't give out extra sauces the food comes as per chefs rules , I asked for something Spicy and was only given Wasabi. SMFH I felt like a dog, getting little treats.

Randy Lam

Came around 8pm monday night, given a 30min wait time, seated in 20ish (definitely depends on how slow/amount people want to eat)

Good variety of fishes as well as fish eggs, lobster, eel. Unfortunately they ran out of the eel and a few pieces of the bluefin that I wanted. Waiter was helpful in recommending replacement fishes

Ordered about 12 different pieces ranging from 9 - 24$, quality was good, sizes/portions could be larger. With the dish size plates couldve been brought out with 5 or so different sashimi/hand rolls on the plates

The pieces of bluefin I got were light but a good amount of fattyness to them (4 or so variations of bluefin, light to fatty) would honestly order more of bluefin if I was looking to reorder something
Pink lobster can be skipped, is more of a filler piece
Anago, no salty taste, eel had a nice texture
Salmon eggs, wrapped with seaweed around, sounds weird but the eggs didnt pop nor were they as refreshing/savory as I usually think roe is. Still tasted good

Overall a good experience but leaves you wanting more food at the end, wait staff was friendly and attentive (quick to update on wait time as well as letting us know when they were out of a fish)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Marcus Baggio

Bad experience

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Lila kwong

Always good, never a disappointment ❣️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Graciela Bordona

Everything is excellent!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dean Snyder

No gluten free anything. Awful response to asking for tamari.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Mechy Tal

sugarfish has changed my perspective on raw fish forever. every time i come here, the staff is incredible & the food never disappoints. the quality is fabulous, always fresh & satisfying, worth the wait if there is one. when you find yourself here, especially if you’re a first timer with raw fish, i highly recommend coming for dinner & ordering the trust me. you will leave satisfied & wondering when your next visit will be. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Toro Hand Roll, Yellowtail Sushi, Salmon Nigiri with Sesame Seeds

EJ Rosen

?so perfect, the fish so fresh, impossibly fresh, melt in mouth. and the traditional warm rice, divine. I closed my eyes like six times after taking first bites of this or that sushi. I had the chef's Trust Me and was glad. The course structure is fun and extends the meal.

Only plaint is it's really hard to hear -- all the surfaces are wood, tile, and leather so all the sound is bouncing, none absorbed, such that it's a very lean-forward-to-hear-each-other sort of affair for four friends on a Friday night.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...