Sunny John Pizzeria

5408 Avenue N, Brooklyn
(718) 241-6115

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jadeah Norris

I only come here because it’s close to my job otherwise I would go somewhere else. Idk maybe I’m spoiled but the pizza portion upsets me. I’ve had bigger slices for cheaper than what they serve here. I’m usually full off a slice not here 😂 still hungry asf . Their pizza is tasty but paying more for regular ass pizza don’t sit right with me

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Djuan Smalls

Great grandma pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Noureddine Bettache

We were hungry so we decided to stop to eat my family chose Sunny pizza because it was the closest we asked for a Large pizza, a bottle of sprite and a small bottle of juice for my child my children could not eat this pizza because of poor quality plus the guys at the counter are not welcoming the surprise is the bill which was more than $47.

Nicole Semple

Nice experience. Food tasty. Clean restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Baked Ziti

Charlie Dicanio

$18 for a slice of pizza with slices that are only about half, about the size of a slice of digourno. Only ordered here cause originals is just as bad. Do not order here

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

biagio di salvatore

Good pizza

Hameed Khan

I am experiencing heartburn after just eating one slice. The pizza is made with cheap ingredients. The italian guy at the counter was not welcoming. The place seemed not well taken care of save yourself the headache and go elsewhere

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brooklyn Beaver

You need to clean up these front counter Amigos , they are filthy and I have yet to see them wash hands , tell them also to stop touching the pizza after it comes out of oven with their hands over and over there is no need to touch it often and stop touching the plates with their palms all day , disgusting, today I got a hair in pizza. Just for this dirtyness I’m done coming here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Ian Wallis

The sort of pizza you expect to find on every block. Guys working the counter were quick and really polite. Place was real clean. Fresh mozz and tomato pizza was great, just the right amount of basil with it, crust thin and hit a good balance of crispy and chewy.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

H. Bradford Morris III

Terrible service. I left and drove 10 mins. away in order to not wait on their rudeness.

La Charmille

Has bathrooms, has TV, Fresh affordable pizza, clean,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A Radjpaul

My new go to spot for a quick slice excellent

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrea Hinds

I order from them every Monday for my son pizza day at school. Every week I ask them to cut two slices into small pieces for him and they always make sure it's the appropriate temperature and I get a plate and foil paper with his box to carry in. They time my arrival perfectly so I'm never late to get out of the restaurant. It's the little things that make you know they care. Sunny John staff are so respectful and courteous. If you ever have to wait, make conversation.... they will share some awesome neighborhood history stories.

Kid-friendliness: My son always feels like family when we stop in... and we're from the Caribbean but the guys treat him like he's at home when he likes to take off his shoes while seated at the table. They make him feel at peace with that pet peeve he has.

Recommended dishes: Zeppoles, Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza Slice, Beef Patty

Adrian Mac

Ordered 2 pies & soda (on point with plates & cups). The pizza was crispy just the way I like it, next time i will dine in. 100% recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

James Casatelli

This place has gone downhill. A regular pizza is super thin and not filling at all, and the sauce is way too acidic. And the prices have sky rocketed. Ordered ravioli (you get 6), chicken wings (you get 8) and a fried calzone with pepperoni. $40 for three things. The calzone didn't have any pepperoni in it, and it was inedible, way too tough and way too greasy. That will be my last time ordering from here. Shame, the place was pretty good for a long time, but can't justify $40 for a couple of ravioli and chicken wings and an inedible calzone.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Loading...