Their Classic NY Pizza is DYNAMITE!!! Honestly my wife is starting to get on me about having it too often! The people are so nice and friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and they have a small, but very nice wine list. I ‘accidentally’ get there early for pick up so I can enjoy a glass of red while waiting! Wish I could give six stars!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic NY Pizza
Areum Kim
Poor delivery quality but more than that, I was just really disappointed with the GF crust - I thought it would be a fresh homemade crust but it’s clearly just one of those pre-packaged ones that taste like cardboard
Food: 2
Belkys Diaz
Ok so yes 3 stars for food!! Burnt pizza which you can easily see in pics. A very easy fix by trimming off the burnt crust. Taste was good and holds up like it should. Veggie pizza was mixed with margarita but the veggie side was too sogged up and did not hold up to the amount of veggies that were on the pizza.
This was a group of 7 and my daughter said it may have been an off night.. it’s Friday it should be your best night. I saw other pizzas that had same look of burnt pizza and where the crust was left behind bc it was way to burnt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ana Myles
Tried this place the first time a couple weeks ago and loved it! We had the perfect dinner- a salad, pizza, and a pasta! Plus the recommended wines were well priced and delicious. Already have ordered take-out a couple times since. This is our new favorite neighborhood pizza spot for sure!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mr William Pizza
Claudia
Consistently Amazing crispy thin crust pizza in a charming low key pizza restaurant across from Greenwood!! Salads are so fresh , large and delicious too!! Also they serve 3 different Other Half beers!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seasonal Salad
Hika Delle Donne
I ordered delivery and it was phenomenal! Gluten free crust was also very good
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza options
Food: 5
Ana Carr
The meatballs were too acidic. It left a bad taste but otherwise everything else was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza Peperoni
Dawn H Chin
Female manager or owner scowled at us versus a “hello” or “welcome” as is polite customary practice to greet new customers. I had to ask if this was “Astarita” before she scowled an answer. Boris, our server, seated us outdoors due to the shower booked inside. Despite the reviews, Mr. William pizza was bland. Charging $4.00 to sub mushrooms in place of (much more expensive) pepperoni meat without transparency was a bit miserly. Okay seasonal salad. Atmosphere is bare bones. Loud hipsters dining on very basic tabletops nearby. As native New Yorkers from the neighborhood, we tipped generously and won’t return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
marco
Very good pizza and fresh ingredients (and I am Italian ...) but an extremely disorganized staff, sometimes rude wth customers. Note: super small and unconfortable tables - and shaking chairs - outside!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Leah Schneider
This place is a hidden gem. I'm not sure why it wasn't more packed. The pizza was delicious. It was a perfectly crispy crust and didn't get soggy with all the toppings that we ordered. The cheese was absolutely top quality as well. This is one of the best pizza places I've been to and I make it a point to try a lot. I'd love to go back and just get the plain pizza. I'm sure it's perfect.
What just happened?! I came in here because for some reason Luigi's was closed on a late Saturday afternoon. Yes, this isn't a slice shop. Honestly, I randomly saw this place out the window of a bus as I was passing by...
Crispy thin crust, robust flavorful sauce, thick fresh cheese, fantastic veggie toppings. Reminded me of a New Haven style pizza in terms of size and finish.
We also had the Cesar salad to start, and it was perfect. Fresh baby kale, high quality craisins, crunchy walnut bits, and tasty goat cheese nuggets.
Don't sleep on this exceptional location! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Baby Yoda
Great service, good food and great atmosphere brought me to this great sunset park eatery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina
Highly recommend! Excellent food, great atmosphere and super friendly staff
Their Classic NY Pizza is DYNAMITE!!! Honestly my wife is starting to get on me about having it too often! The people are so nice and friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and they have a small, but very nice wine list. I ‘accidentally’ get there early for pick up so I can enjoy a glass of red while waiting! Wish I could give six stars!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic NY Pizza
Poor delivery quality but more than that, I was just really disappointed with the GF crust - I thought it would be a fresh homemade crust but it’s clearly just one of those pre-packaged ones that taste like cardboard
Food: 2
Ok so yes 3 stars for food!! Burnt pizza which you can easily see in pics. A very easy fix by trimming off the burnt crust. Taste was good and holds up like it should. Veggie pizza was mixed with margarita but the veggie side was too sogged up and did not hold up to the amount of veggies that were on the pizza.
This was a group of 7 and my daughter said it may have been an off night.. it’s Friday it should be your best night. I saw other pizzas that had same look of burnt pizza and where the crust was left behind bc it was way to burnt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Tried this place the first time a couple weeks ago and loved it! We had the perfect dinner- a salad, pizza, and a pasta! Plus the recommended wines were well priced and delicious. Already have ordered take-out a couple times since. This is our new favorite neighborhood pizza spot for sure!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mr William Pizza
Consistently Amazing crispy thin crust pizza in a charming low key pizza restaurant across from Greenwood!! Salads are so fresh , large and delicious too!! Also they serve 3 different Other Half beers!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seasonal Salad
I ordered delivery and it was phenomenal! Gluten free crust was also very good
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza options
Food: 5
The meatballs were too acidic. It left a bad taste but otherwise everything else was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza Peperoni
Female manager or owner scowled at us versus a “hello” or “welcome” as is polite customary practice to greet new customers. I had to ask if this was “Astarita” before she scowled an answer. Boris, our server, seated us outdoors due to the shower booked inside. Despite the reviews, Mr. William pizza was bland. Charging $4.00 to sub mushrooms in place of (much more expensive) pepperoni meat without transparency was a bit miserly. Okay seasonal salad. Atmosphere is bare bones. Loud hipsters dining on very basic tabletops nearby. As native New Yorkers from the neighborhood, we tipped generously and won’t return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very good pizza and fresh ingredients (and I am Italian ...) but an extremely disorganized staff, sometimes rude wth customers. Note: super small and unconfortable tables - and shaking chairs - outside!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
This place is a hidden gem. I'm not sure why it wasn't more packed. The pizza was delicious. It was a perfectly crispy crust and didn't get soggy with all the toppings that we ordered. The cheese was absolutely top quality as well. This is one of the best pizza places I've been to and I make it a point to try a lot. I'd love to go back and just get the plain pizza. I'm sure it's perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow! Great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not that tasty
What just happened?! I came in here because for some reason Luigi's was closed on a late Saturday afternoon. Yes, this isn't a slice shop. Honestly, I randomly saw this place out the window of a bus as I was passing by...
Crispy thin crust, robust flavorful sauce, thick fresh cheese, fantastic veggie toppings. Reminded me of a New Haven style pizza in terms of size and finish.
We also had the Cesar salad to start, and it was perfect. Fresh baby kale, high quality craisins, crunchy walnut bits, and tasty goat cheese nuggets.
Don't sleep on this exceptional location! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, good food and great atmosphere brought me to this great sunset park eatery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend! Excellent food, great atmosphere and super friendly staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Meatballs
Loading...