Okay if you need a quick slice, ingredients aren’t the best quality, but prices are reasonable. I haven’t gone back since spring when I cracked a tooth on a slice of Sicilian pizza.
Logan Phares
My friend is a trans woman and upon entering The Sicilian this evening she was told by the person behind the register that she “can’t come in here looking like that” and forced to leave. She was dressed normally—this was a clear attack on her gender identity. If you are a trans person you are not safe here, and if you care about trans people you will not patron this business.
Theresa Johnson
I visited this pizzeria today, 9/27 the man serving the food had dirty fingernails, and I mean every finger. I worked with food and I was not allowed to serve without gloves even if I had super clean hands. I had a square slice with pepperoni and a medium diet soda, cost was $9.50, to me over priced and being severed with dirty fingernail hands to boot was very disappointing.
Ryan Hui
We ordered a pizza here. The delivery driver, Rocco, called us and told us the pizza was "stolen" and to call the pizzeria again the next day to sort it out. Upon calling, they were not aware of any situation that had happened. They gave us credit for pizza, which was appreciated, but this has really soured a place that I really enjoyed.
Charlie Daehler
I come here about once a month for my pizza-slice-fix. No frills $5 slice that gets the job done. They usually have a good variety during peak times. Good people work here
Bushido Ken
Stopped in at this spot randomly. Was en route to a job in Brooklyn, and had to use the john. Partner and I walked in this place and found it to be clean comfortable and inviting. The spread looked amazing and they had a restroom. My partner had the lemon chicken pizza and I had the marinara swirl slice. Amazing! Great food, great environment and trendy music ? ? ?Unfortunately I live out of state but would love to come back.
Alexandra Benavente
We just ordered food from The Sicilian to take to the park and we are blown away. Their spaghetti with meat sauce and lasagna are incredible. Everyone who tried it said the flavor of this pasta was the best they’ve had in a long time. We’ll be back!
Robert o'byrne
Great spot for a great slice! Beautiful sitting area in back to hang out
Call Me Supaa
I wish i can put 0 stars , never again ? this place is disgusting . I feel bad for the workers
Alex Handler
Great customer service and delicious food. The one time they made an error it was dealt with promptly. I love this place, their meat tortellini is amazing.
It's not a bad place but I didn't like the pizza I took. It was too beefy for me so I didn't enjoy it. I should have take the regular one.
David Moldvai
Just moved to nyc and have been coming to this pizza shop regularly. Great pizza, fast service, big fan of the people who keep the shop running!
Alyssa B
Great pizza, friendly staff and clean seating area! They have open front windows so you’re able to enjoy the environment while eating a Slice of pizza
Ruby Miller
Pizza here is great. Love that they have a backyard space. My kids love the food and service here as well.
Laura McCarthy
Best pizza ever! Extremely tasty, creative, and beautifully presented as well. We loved having lunch in the back patio area during our trip to New York.
Okay if you need a quick slice, ingredients aren’t the best quality, but prices are reasonable. I haven’t gone back since spring when I cracked a tooth on a slice of Sicilian pizza.
My friend is a trans woman and upon entering The Sicilian this evening she was told by the person behind the register that she “can’t come in here looking like that” and forced to leave. She was dressed normally—this was a clear attack on her gender identity. If you are a trans person you are not safe here, and if you care about trans people you will not patron this business.
I visited this pizzeria today, 9/27 the man serving the food had dirty fingernails, and I mean every finger. I worked with food and I was not allowed to serve without gloves even if I had super clean hands. I had a square slice with pepperoni and a medium diet soda, cost was $9.50, to me over priced and being severed with dirty fingernail hands to boot was very disappointing.
We ordered a pizza here. The delivery driver, Rocco, called us and told us the pizza was "stolen" and to call the pizzeria again the next day to sort it out. Upon calling, they were not aware of any situation that had happened. They gave us credit for pizza, which was appreciated, but this has really soured a place that I really enjoyed.
I come here about once a month for my pizza-slice-fix. No frills $5 slice that gets the job done. They usually have a good variety during peak times. Good people work here
Stopped in at this spot randomly. Was en route to a job in Brooklyn, and had to use the john. Partner and I walked in this place and found it to be clean comfortable and inviting. The spread looked amazing and they had a restroom. My partner had the lemon chicken pizza and I had the marinara swirl slice. Amazing! Great food, great environment and trendy music ? ? ?Unfortunately I live out of state but would love to come back.
We just ordered food from The Sicilian to take to the park and we are blown away. Their spaghetti with meat sauce and lasagna are incredible. Everyone who tried it said the flavor of this pasta was the best they’ve had in a long time. We’ll be back!
Great spot for a great slice! Beautiful sitting area in back to hang out
I wish i can put 0 stars , never again ? this place is disgusting . I feel bad for the workers
Great customer service and delicious food. The one time they made an error it was dealt with promptly. I love this place, their meat tortellini is amazing.
Restaurantji Recommends
It's not a bad place but I didn't like the pizza I took. It was too beefy for me so I didn't enjoy it. I should have take the regular one.
Just moved to nyc and have been coming to this pizza shop regularly. Great pizza, fast service, big fan of the people who keep the shop running!
Great pizza, friendly staff and clean seating area! They have open front windows so you’re able to enjoy the environment while eating a Slice of pizza
Pizza here is great. Love that they have a backyard space. My kids love the food and service here as well.
Best pizza ever! Extremely tasty, creative, and beautifully presented as well. We loved having lunch in the back patio area during our trip to New York.
Loading...