The Sweet Tooth & Catering

376 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn
(718) 574-2580

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Shrimp PO Boy Cabbage Potato Salad with Garlic Bread
Jerl Chicken Potato Salad Mac and Cheese
Signature Sweet Potato Cheesecake
Sweet Potato Pound Cake Loaf
Pulled Jerk Chicken Sandwich
Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake
Homemade Banana Pudding
Red Velvet Cake Slice
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake

Menu

Featured items
SWEET POTATO CHEESECAKE SLICE
SHAKOOR'S SHRIMP PO BOY
Fried Shrimp with Homemade Cole Slaw Served on Pan Toasted Hoagie and Homemade Spicy Mayo
FLOUNDER PO BOY SMALL
Served on Toasted Brioche Bun and Built with Homemade Cole Slaw and Special Sauce
SIRLOIN MEATBALLS W/SAUTÉED ONIONS
2 Meatballs w/ Sautéed Onions served on Toasted Brioche Bun & Special Sauce
LEMON LAYER CAKE SLICE
6" MINI APPLE PIE
5" STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
HALF & HALF (SHRIMP/CATFISH/ FLOUNDER) ONLY 2 SELECTIONS!
Select 2 Different Seafood Items Only , Served with 2 Sides
STRAWBERRY SWIRL CHEESECAKE SLICE
JUMBO FRIED SHRIMP W/ 2 SIDES
Jumbo Shrimp Fried to Perfection, served with 2 sides and Toasted Italian Bread.

SIGNATURE SANDWICHES
SHAKOOR'S SHRIMP PO BOY
Fried Shrimp with Homemade Cole Slaw Served on Pan Toasted Hoagie and Homemade Spicy Mayo
SIGNATURE CHOPPED BBQ CHICKEN SANDWICH
Balanced Chicken Breast and Thigh Meat Slowly Baked with Onions , Red and Green Bell Peppers and BBQ Sauce . Served on Toasted Brioche Bun.
FLOUNDER PO BOY SMALL
Served on Toasted Brioche Bun and Built with Homemade Cole Slaw and Special Sauce
(HALF & HALF) SHRIMP & FLOUNDER PO BOY
Jumbo Shrimp & Flounder Portions Assembled with Homemade Cole Slaw on Toasted Hoagie and Spicy Special Sauce
SIRLOIN MEATBALLS W/SAUTÉED ONIONS
2 Meatballs w/ Sautéed Onions served on Toasted Brioche Bun & Special Sauce
PULLED JERK CHICKEN
Breast and Thigh Meat , Onions, Red Peppers served on Toasted Brioche Bun and Light Cole Slaw to balance Heat. Yummers!
(HALF & HALF) SHRIMP & CATFISH PO BOY
Jumbo Shrimp & Catfish Portions Assembled with Homemade Coleslaw and Spicy Special Sauce
CATFISH PO BOY
FLOUNDER PO BOY LARGE
Served on Toasted Italian Bread Built with Homemade Cole Slaw and Special Homemade Sauce

DINNER SPECIALS
HALF & HALF (SHRIMP/CATFISH/ FLOUNDER) ONLY 2 SELECTIONS!
Select 2 Different Seafood Items Only , Served with 2 Sides
JUMBO FRIED SHRIMP W/ 2 SIDES
Jumbo Shrimp Fried to Perfection, served with 2 sides and Toasted Italian Bread.
SIGNATURE CHOPPED BBQ CHICKEN W/2 SIDES
PULLED JERK CHICKEN W/2 SIDES
JUMBO SIRLOIN MEATBALLS w/ 2 Sides

DESSERT SLICES (Slices are refrigerated)
LEMON LAYER CAKE SLICE
SWEET POTATO CHEESECAKE SLICE
6" MINI APPLE PIE
STRAWBERRY SWIRL CHEESECAKE SLICE
5" STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
5" CARAMEL PECAN CHEESECAKE
SOUTHERN STYLE PEACH COBBLER
CHOCOLATE MARBLE LAYER SLICE
LEMON BUTTER POUND CAKE SLICE
TRIPLE PLAY CHEESECAKES/ LIMITED TIME!
ANY THREE (3) CHEESECAKE SLICES. MUST BE DIFFERENT FLAVORS!
STRAWBERRY LAYER CAKE
RED VELVET CHEESECAKE SLICE
DOUBLE CHOCOLATE GANACHE LAYER SLICE

SIDES
BUTTERY HOMINY GRITS
MAC & CHEESE
WHOLE GREEN BEANS
HOMEMADE COLE SLAW
SEASONED RICE
COLLARD GREENS (No Meat)

7'' LAYER CAKES
RED VELVET CAKE SERVES 10-12
DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CAKE SERVES 10-12
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Frosting
VERY LEMON LAYER SERVES 10-12
RED VELVET W/ NUTS SERVES 10-12

Beverages
BOTTLED WATER
BREWED ICED TEA

NEW BREAKFAST - SERVED ALL DAY
FRIED SHRIMP & HOMINY GRITS
(6) Jumbo Shrimp (fried) served with buttery Hominy Grits and a wedge of Italian bread.
TWO FISH COMBO & GRITS
Select any two of the following items: SHRIMP, FLOUNDER,CATFISH served with GRITS.
FLOUNDER & HOMINY GRITS
(3) pcs. of Fried Flounder served with buttery Hominy Grits and a wedge of toasted Italian bread.
BUTTERY CHEDDAR CHEESE GRITS
BUTTERY HOMINY GRITS

HOT SOUPS
HOMEMADE CORN CHOWDER
Sweet Corn, Scallions, Potatoes, Heavy Cream, Butter, Red & Green Bell Peppers And Love.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
+20 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+19 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Had the most AMAZING Poboy & conversation with the owner/cook of sweet tooth. The business has been on Garvey for 17 years and I think it’s because he stayed true to himself, pork free soulfood, chopped chicken barbecue sandwiches, Poboy and homemade iced teas and let’s not forget about the desserts which I didn’t get to get any because I’m on a sweet break but next time I pop in I’m definitely getting a sweet potato cheesecake. Now for my sandwich, I had four juicy...
August 2025
Stopped by after getting my hair done and I was not disappointed. Everything was good from the service to the food. That dough-apple pie!!!! Delicious!!! Will definitely go back on my next trip to Bklyn!
July 2025
We ordered the fried chicken and sweet potato pie for an event at home. The service was great. Elonzo was prompt and tried to accommodate any preferences I had.
Our guests loved the food. Glad to have this reliable catering service in our neighborhood.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Barb’s - 380A Marcus Garvey Blvd
Bar, Cocktail Bar, Beer Bar
Zig Zag - 382 Marcus Garvey Blvd
Tiki Bar, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian
Prestige Gourmet Deli Corp. - 362 Marcus Garvey Blvd
Deli, Grocery, Fast Food

The Sweet Tooth & Catering

376 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11221
(718) 574-2580