A+ across the board. Unbelievable service. Sitting at the chef’s table was a little smoky but a blast. Was nearly impossible to get a reservation and I hate to say it but it’s worth the hype! Hope we’re able to land another reservation again soon because I’m going to be thinking about this meal for a long time.
Alex Chin
The sourdough topped with whipped ricotta was delicious, and the broccolini was even better. Both dishes had a perfectly balanced flavor; it was just right! We also ordered the half chicken, which took a little while to prepare, but it was worth the wait.
David D.
One of my favorite places to eat in Brooklyn. Excellent food, service and atmosphere. We have tasted both trout dishes, the ricotta on sourdough, the lamb flatbread and the half chicken plate. Highly recommend this restaurant. One of the rare menus where you don't have to be worried about what you order because everything is delicious!
Julia Liss
We were really surprised by how much we didn't like Theodora. The 3 hour wait wasn't even the issue. We normally love all the great spots in nyc and have rly never left a popular spot this disappointed. I really owe my opinion to the food only though the wait and slow service didn't help. We actively disliked the little gem salad and the cod. The drink was fine and the ceviche was decent. Really overall underwhelmed based on how heavily recommended this was. Also it took 20+ min to have a drink order event taken and another 20 min to have it made (we were seated at the bar after a 3 hour wait)
Kir S
Delicious, beautiful, and great service, too. A buzzy, warm, and sexy place
douglas mollin
Can I give it 6 stars?
One of my favorite meals in a long time … service was spectacular, plating straight from The Bear and flavors bursting through every bite.
Meals are meant to share and two of us shared 5 plates plus two desserts …. We over did it, you can get by with 4 and 1 lol.
The chicken really is as good as everyone says it is … if you never order roast chicken out like me, try this one.
Bravo Theadora
Emily
One of the best meals of my life. The inside is gorgeously designed- cozy, clean, bright, lots of plants. We sat in the back room. Drinks were top tier, service was fast & we ate much of the menu. I cannot pick a favorite, but the ricotta sourdough and yellowtail dish were up there!
Santiago Ramirez Degollado
Fantastic razor clams, cod and swordfish. Very cosy decor and excellent service. Monkfish liver hummus is delicious.
Conor Murphy
Had a great time . Food is 10/10 service phenomenal. Shout outs to Dave , Kate and Adam and rest of staff .
My absolute favorite restaurant in nyc!!!!!!!!!!!!! Excellent food excellent ambiance excellent staff incredible atmosphere each and every time. Drinks are amazing It's simply the best!!!'
overpriced perfection, everything is fun exciting lovely, the line art on the wall and bathroom door hurts my eyes and soul but we all have to embrace bad taste when everything must be so devinely good, maybe it improves the food…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrance B
We were able to get a table right away as a walk in. The cocktails were amazing, the Zero Proof drink however was very bland and overly garnished. Portions are tiny, like on the brink of Canapé not small plates. Food was yummy but gone in one to two bites…. Enjoyed the atmosphere and service but over priced and eat before/ after you visit or order everything on the menu to have full meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Stephen Racano
Had some great dishes, but didn't earn the 5th star for me. Go for the seafood. Those are the best dishes. The lamb was very average and the kebonah looks better than it was. Service was great. Also, save room for the chocolate cake dessert. Simple but phenomenal.
A+ across the board. Unbelievable service. Sitting at the chef’s table was a little smoky but a blast. Was nearly impossible to get a reservation and I hate to say it but it’s worth the hype! Hope we’re able to land another reservation again soon because I’m going to be thinking about this meal for a long time.
The sourdough topped with whipped ricotta was delicious, and the broccolini was even better. Both dishes had a perfectly balanced flavor; it was just right! We also ordered the half chicken, which took a little while to prepare, but it was worth the wait.
One of my favorite places to eat in Brooklyn. Excellent food, service and atmosphere. We have tasted both trout dishes, the ricotta on sourdough, the lamb flatbread and the half chicken plate. Highly recommend this restaurant. One of the rare menus where you don't have to be worried about what you order because everything is delicious!
We were really surprised by how much we didn't like Theodora. The 3 hour wait wasn't even the issue. We normally love all the great spots in nyc and have rly never left a popular spot this disappointed. I really owe my opinion to the food only though the wait and slow service didn't help. We actively disliked the little gem salad and the cod. The drink was fine and the ceviche was decent. Really overall underwhelmed based on how heavily recommended this was. Also it took 20+ min to have a drink order event taken and another 20 min to have it made (we were seated at the bar after a 3 hour wait)
Delicious, beautiful, and great service, too. A buzzy, warm, and sexy place
Can I give it 6 stars?
One of my favorite meals in a long time … service was spectacular, plating straight from The Bear and flavors bursting through every bite.
Meals are meant to share and two of us shared 5 plates plus two desserts …. We over did it, you can get by with 4 and 1 lol.
The chicken really is as good as everyone says it is … if you never order roast chicken out like me, try this one.
Bravo Theadora
One of the best meals of my life. The inside is gorgeously designed- cozy, clean, bright, lots of plants. We sat in the back room. Drinks were top tier, service was fast & we ate much of the menu. I cannot pick a favorite, but the ricotta sourdough and yellowtail dish were up there!
Fantastic razor clams, cod and swordfish. Very cosy decor and excellent service. Monkfish liver hummus is delicious.
Had a great time . Food is 10/10 service phenomenal. Shout outs to Dave , Kate and Adam and rest of staff .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Five stars all around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My absolute favorite restaurant in nyc!!!!!!!!!!!!! Excellent food excellent ambiance excellent staff incredible atmosphere each and every time. Drinks are amazing It's simply the best!!!'
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Flan, Cheesecake, Monkfish Liver, Half Chicken, Sourdough Whipped Ricotta, Whipped Ricotta Toast, Napa Cabbage Skewer, Baklava Sundae, Chocolate Cake, Red Snapper Ceviche, Broccolini, Swordfish Skewers, Swordfish Belly Skewer, Black Cod Collar, Striped Bass, Mackerel
overpriced perfection, everything is fun exciting lovely, the line art on the wall and bathroom door hurts my eyes and soul but we all have to embrace bad taste when everything must be so devinely good, maybe it improves the food…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were able to get a table right away as a walk in. The cocktails were amazing, the Zero Proof drink however was very bland and overly garnished. Portions are tiny, like on the brink of Canapé not small plates. Food was yummy but gone in one to two bites…. Enjoyed the atmosphere and service but over priced and eat before/ after you visit or order everything on the menu to have full meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Had some great dishes, but didn't earn the 5th star for me. Go for the seafood. Those are the best dishes. The lamb was very average and the kebonah looks better than it was. Service was great. Also, save room for the chocolate cake dessert. Simple but phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake, Swordfish Belly Skewer
Dry aged fish are just orders here, appetizers or large format!
Service really good!
Order martini 🍸 u will thank me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Chicken, Za’Atar Kubaneh, Sourdough Whipped Ricotta, Whipped Ricotta Toast, Carpaccio, Baklava Sundae, Chocolate Cake, Swordfish Skewers
Loading...