ORDERED 2 SLICES OF BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA GUY WAS GONA PUT SAUCE FROM A BOTTLE ON THE COUNTER I ASKED WAS IT BBQ OR BUFFALO HE SAID BBQ I GET HOME DID A FEW THINGS ROUND THE HOUSE WHEN I WENT TO SIT AN EAT I OPEN THE BOX TO FIND MY PIZZA COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE SPENT $9 JUST TO THROW IT OUT NOT EVEN ONE BITE WAS TAKEN NEVER GOING HERE AGAIN
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Nikki G
I was starving and omw to Pitkin to grab a slice. Couldn't wait, and I always wanted to try this spot, so I stopped here. Horrible. The staff is very condescending. I paid $4.50 for a Margherita slice. Oh well, but at that price, what Italian restaurant in the world does not have Parmesan cheese. I was told that Parm is $9 a pound and too expensive to leave out for customers to put on slices. Insane! The staff was complaining about the community to each other and how ppl only come in for slices. So sad. Go to another area or franchise a pizza chain if you do not want to sell slices. Also, straight out the oven, and the slice was still room temp. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Marcelo Perez
Good food Good service been a costumer for long can't complain at all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta with Alfredo Sauce & Chicken, Fries, Chicken Parm, Baked Zitti & Chicken Parmesan
YouDontKnowMe OH
I placed an order through ubereats for extra pepperoni and extra cheese. I received my order and it only had regular pepperoni and cheese and this has happen twice. So I call the restaurant and let them know and the manager said all she can do is refund the money but she said that before when an item was missing and I didn’t receive the refund and I had to call her back the next day and place another order just to get the missing item. While I was on hold waiting for an answer about what will be done with the missing cheese I heard one of the workers which I then found out was the owner said seriously over extra cheese. That is not the point the point is I paid for an order and did not get what I paid for but yet this restaurant does not care at all as long as they got the money. I called back and told them Uber eats cannot refund me the money for the missing cheese and they was acting like they didn’t care and was saying they are really busy and was rushing me off the phone. I spoke with the owner and manager of this location at 850 Nostrand.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Domenick Casale
Great jerk chicken…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Salad, Fries
Robert Soderstrom
We’re new to the neighborhood and decided to try Tony’s pizza. Ordered a special made pizza and it was great. Quick service, too. We’ll try it again for sure!
THE MOST SLOPPY AND DISGUSTING MADE PIZZA IN BROOKLYN . STRAIGHT TRASH. CHEMICALLY MADE CHEESE & LOW QUALITY CRUST . MADE FOR TEENAGERS. GO DOWNTOWN BROOKLYN FOR HIGHER
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Issam Omar
Super awesome pizza and the owner and staff are great 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dominik Rutherford
Went for a regular cheese pizza pie and buffalo chicken pie. Had to wait 15 minutes, no problem. Very fun atmosphere while waiting. Got the pizza after the 15 mins. Both pies were delicious. Price is cheaper than when ordering over uber eats.
I really wonder how a New York pizza spot can be so bad. I asked for a buffalo pizza and got This is $1 slice pizza spot selling pies
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
jUjU
Don’t order delivery from them, just get it in person. When you order delivery they don’t care what they give you smh
Tyler Garrison
I've been ordering from Tony's for awhile and every time I receive the exact same quality and consistency that I've come to love. Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken is my go-to however I've also had the chance to try the cheese pizza and garlic bread. Chicken in the Penne Alla Vodka does not come breaded but they have honored my request for breaded the one time I requested it. Pizza is good, although I've only had it once so I don't feel qualified to say much more on that front. Their garlic bread is not what I normally expect. They go very heavy on the garlic and what I assume is paprika so it's definitely a unique experience as far as garlic bread goes. Truly up to the person eating it if it's for them or not.
OVERALL: A great, consistent, wallet-friendly option especially when ordering in for the night. Thanks for the great food!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crazy Cool
So basically when my friends and i were going to Toni's we stopped at pies r us for my friend to get her a personal pie then we went to Toni's after she got her food so then myself and my other friend can get food from there so when we went inside she placed her food down on the table they had and since there service was so long she decided to eat some of her food as she ate the Toni guy started to yell at her and insult her,me,and my friends and basically my whole school he quoted "that's why you guys have to attend summer school" we attend summer school because our school prepares us for the next school year not because we failed it literally says it in their school name when I asked him if I can get my order he quoted "GET OUT MY STORE" i understand she was in the wrong for eating the food but he went to far with the amount of insulting and rudness instead of politely telling us that that was disrespectful to his store and to kindly tell us to leave. This is not an example you should be setting for kids and I'm even being the bigger person for admitting my wrong so if I can get a in person apology that will be nice.(IM GOING TO KEEP YALL UPDATED).
Kid-friendliness: Rude and sets bad examples on how to handle a situation
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Harrington Williams
Tony, thanks for your continuous service by bringing good pizza to the neighborhood. Also, my son is loving the pie you hooked up for him to bring to FL!
ORDERED 2 SLICES OF BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA GUY WAS GONA PUT SAUCE FROM A BOTTLE ON THE COUNTER I ASKED WAS IT BBQ OR BUFFALO HE SAID BBQ I GET HOME DID A FEW THINGS ROUND THE HOUSE WHEN I WENT TO SIT AN EAT I OPEN THE BOX TO FIND MY PIZZA COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE SPENT $9 JUST TO THROW IT OUT NOT EVEN ONE BITE WAS TAKEN NEVER GOING HERE AGAIN
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
I was starving and omw to Pitkin to grab a slice. Couldn't wait, and I always wanted to try this spot, so I stopped here. Horrible. The staff is very condescending. I paid $4.50 for a Margherita slice. Oh well, but at that price, what Italian restaurant in the world does not have Parmesan cheese. I was told that Parm is $9 a pound and too expensive to leave out for customers to put on slices. Insane! The staff was complaining about the community to each other and how ppl only come in for slices. So sad. Go to another area or franchise a pizza chain if you do not want to sell slices. Also, straight out the oven, and the slice was still room temp. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Good food Good service been a costumer for long can't complain at all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta with Alfredo Sauce & Chicken, Fries, Chicken Parm, Baked Zitti & Chicken Parmesan
I placed an order through ubereats for extra pepperoni and extra cheese. I received my order and it only had regular pepperoni and cheese and this has happen twice. So I call the restaurant and let them know and the manager said all she can do is refund the money but she said that before when an item was missing and I didn’t receive the refund and I had to call her back the next day and place another order just to get the missing item. While I was on hold waiting for an answer about what will be done with the missing cheese I heard one of the workers which I then found out was the owner said seriously over extra cheese. That is not the point the point is I paid for an order and did not get what I paid for but yet this restaurant does not care at all as long as they got the money. I called back and told them Uber eats cannot refund me the money for the missing cheese and they was acting like they didn’t care and was saying they are really busy and was rushing me off the phone. I spoke with the owner and manager of this location at 850 Nostrand.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Great jerk chicken…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Salad, Fries
We’re new to the neighborhood and decided to try Tony’s pizza. Ordered a special made pizza and it was great. Quick service, too. We’ll try it again for sure!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Veggie Pizza
Great place
They treat you like family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sicilian Pizza, Chicken Parm, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
THE MOST SLOPPY AND DISGUSTING MADE PIZZA IN BROOKLYN . STRAIGHT TRASH. CHEMICALLY MADE CHEESE & LOW QUALITY CRUST . MADE FOR TEENAGERS. GO DOWNTOWN BROOKLYN FOR HIGHER
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Super awesome pizza and the owner and staff are great 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went for a regular cheese pizza pie and buffalo chicken pie. Had to wait 15 minutes, no problem. Very fun atmosphere while waiting. Got the pizza after the 15 mins. Both pies were delicious. Price is cheaper than when ordering over uber eats.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I really wonder how a New York pizza spot can be so bad. I asked for a buffalo pizza and got This is $1 slice pizza spot selling pies
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Don’t order delivery from them, just get it in person. When you order delivery they don’t care what they give you smh
I've been ordering from Tony's for awhile and every time I receive the exact same quality and consistency that I've come to love. Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken is my go-to however I've also had the chance to try the cheese pizza and garlic bread. Chicken in the Penne Alla Vodka does not come breaded but they have honored my request for breaded the one time I requested it. Pizza is good, although I've only had it once so I don't feel qualified to say much more on that front. Their garlic bread is not what I normally expect. They go very heavy on the garlic and what I assume is paprika so it's definitely a unique experience as far as garlic bread goes. Truly up to the person eating it if it's for them or not.
OVERALL: A great, consistent, wallet-friendly option especially when ordering in for the night. Thanks for the great food!
Food: 5
Service: 5
So basically when my friends and i were going to Toni's we stopped at pies r us for my friend to get her a personal pie then we went to Toni's after she got her food so then myself and my other friend can get food from there so when we went inside she placed her food down on the table they had and since there service was so long she decided to eat some of her food as she ate the Toni guy started to yell at her and insult her,me,and my friends and basically my whole school he quoted "that's why you guys have to attend summer school" we attend summer school because our school prepares us for the next school year not because we failed it literally says it in their school name when I asked him if I can get my order he quoted "GET OUT MY STORE" i understand she was in the wrong for eating the food but he went to far with the amount of insulting and rudness instead of politely telling us that that was disrespectful to his store and to kindly tell us to leave. This is not an example you should be setting for kids and I'm even being the bigger person for admitting my wrong so if I can get a in person apology that will be nice.(IM GOING TO KEEP YALL UPDATED).
Kid-friendliness: Rude and sets bad examples on how to handle a situation
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tony, thanks for your continuous service by bringing good pizza to the neighborhood. Also, my son is loving the pie you hooked up for him to bring to FL!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...