Ordered pick up and crust was weird and wet and cold. Let them know and no response. Won’t return.
Food: 1
Service: 3
John Santaferraro
WOW, WOW, WOW! I know that Michelin has their three stars, well I give Wheated my three wows for the triple wow experience I had there last night. Every person serving us was exceedingly talented at what they did and extremely personal in the way they treated us. Every moment, even in the waiting, was a beautiful experience; and the food and cocktails went far beyond our expectations, every ingredient, every morsal curated for the best possible taste, texture, and consistency. I say WOW, WOW, WOW!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cliodhna Burke
Incredible pizza with vegan options!! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh Spare
I just moved over to the Flatbush area from the city and I was looking for a solid local pizza spot you can dine it at. This is the one! Been twice and both times the pizza was phenomenal (top 10 in all of NYC good). The atmosphere and ambiance is great and it is good for families or just a date night. I highly recommend this spot and I will become a regular soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maggie Milke
Great drinks fantabulous service and such good pizza. Arugula salad was unbelievably delicious. Its defo poppin but worth the wait. Ask server for theyre homeade pizza sesame topping
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Miranda
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed!
But... they allowed me, my son, and my daughter to enjoy dinner at the bar. You guys were awesome and entertaining while my kids poked at the salad and stole the cherry from my Manhattan lol.
Arugula salad was nice and the Pizza, even better! Added onion and mushrooms to the Bay Ridge that I ordered and tried with the spicy crunch added.
Gave great recommendations and we're really attentive. Thank you for this great meal!
I'll be back when I can!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Dabydeen
Wheated probably takes the crown for some of the best specialty pizzas in Brooklyn. We absolutely loved our dinner here. The space has a fast, lively energy that makes it feel like you’re in on a neighborhood favorite, and the food completely lives up to the buzz.
One of the coolest touches is that every pizza is named after a Brooklyn neighborhood, which makes the menu fun to explore. I ordered the Flatbush and it honestly surprised me in the best way. I had never tried eggplant on pizza before, but it worked incredibly well. It added a rich, savory depth without feeling heavy, and the crust had that perfect balance of chewy and crisp.
The cocktails were also a pleasant surprise. It’s not always expected at a pizza spot, but they were thoughtfully made and paired perfectly with the meal.
Everything about Wheated just clicked, from the energy of the room to the quality of the food. This is the kind of place you leave already planning what you’ll order next time. I cannot wait to come back. 🍕🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
lee Vogel
Definitely one of the TOP Pie spots in Brooklyn!
Love the aesthetics! The bathroom door blending into the wall is cool! I don’t remember that last time I was here to dine-in but that was a while ago. I’ve done both take-out & dine-in here.
There were a couple tables available but they do fill up fast! I found a seat by the bar right away! I ordered a drink while I waited I don’t remember the name but it was good.
The Pizza came after like 15min or so it wasn’t a long wait. I was really happy with its presentation, flavor & texture etc…
The cheese was perfectly melted, the crust was crispy & sauce was great! They definitely didn’t disappoint & piled high the toppings for the supreme part of the pie. I would definitely get the supreme again though next time I wanna try a white pie maybe the New Haven rosemary potato pie sounds good as a next try. I would also highly recommend the Flatbush for all the Eggplant lovers out there!
The service was good, the staff was attentive to my needs & were friendly.
What a wonderful place! Delicious food and a cozy atmosphere. I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kraig DeMatteis
Picked-up dinner but I want to come back to eat-in. Their bar counter overlooks their wide selection of bourbons and whiskeys in a cozy wood-covered interior. I did not order dinner myself but apparently you need to reserve spots for pick-up so the food is hot. Not 100% sure, but be prepared.
Pizza was excellent - I think we had plain (Bensonhurst) and Sunset Park. Caesar salad very good, too - anchovies in the sauce but no one minded. Nice combo for a get-together. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrea Posada Colavizza
Amazing pizza! Despite we had to wait over 1 hour, the service was good and the pizza was so delicious, that i would definitely come back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fabienne
The artichoke pizza (Prospect Park South) is to die for 🤤
Kenneth Munz
What happened????? I keep trying to come back post covid and find myself disappointed every time. Pizza tonight was hard, very chewy, like a flatbread. Guessing the dough was overproofed, but this seems to be the norm now. We switched from ordering the small pie to the larger pie and it is now the same. This was one of my favorite pizzas in NY and now it is a shadow of its former self. I’m pulling for the restaurant but feel like there needs to be some internal soul searching. Sorry to sound like a Karen but someone needs to say it.
Absolutely delicious food. Great drinks. Amazing team as well.
I’ve been coming here for 10+ years and it never disappoints! Great food, phenomenal staff! All I can say is well worth the trip !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Meatballs, Chocolate Cake
Ordered pick up and crust was weird and wet and cold. Let them know and no response. Won’t return.
Food: 1
Service: 3
WOW, WOW, WOW! I know that Michelin has their three stars, well I give Wheated my three wows for the triple wow experience I had there last night. Every person serving us was exceedingly talented at what they did and extremely personal in the way they treated us. Every moment, even in the waiting, was a beautiful experience; and the food and cocktails went far beyond our expectations, every ingredient, every morsal curated for the best possible taste, texture, and consistency. I say WOW, WOW, WOW!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible pizza with vegan options!! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just moved over to the Flatbush area from the city and I was looking for a solid local pizza spot you can dine it at. This is the one! Been twice and both times the pizza was phenomenal (top 10 in all of NYC good). The atmosphere and ambiance is great and it is good for families or just a date night. I highly recommend this spot and I will become a regular soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great drinks fantabulous service and such good pizza. Arugula salad was unbelievably delicious. Its defo poppin but worth the wait. Ask server for theyre homeade pizza sesame topping
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed!
But... they allowed me, my son, and my daughter to enjoy dinner at the bar. You guys were awesome and entertaining while my kids poked at the salad and stole the cherry from my Manhattan lol.
Arugula salad was nice and the Pizza, even better! Added onion and mushrooms to the Bay Ridge that I ordered and tried with the spicy crunch added.
Gave great recommendations and we're really attentive. Thank you for this great meal!
I'll be back when I can!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wheated probably takes the crown for some of the best specialty pizzas in Brooklyn. We absolutely loved our dinner here. The space has a fast, lively energy that makes it feel like you’re in on a neighborhood favorite, and the food completely lives up to the buzz.
One of the coolest touches is that every pizza is named after a Brooklyn neighborhood, which makes the menu fun to explore. I ordered the Flatbush and it honestly surprised me in the best way. I had never tried eggplant on pizza before, but it worked incredibly well. It added a rich, savory depth without feeling heavy, and the crust had that perfect balance of chewy and crisp.
The cocktails were also a pleasant surprise. It’s not always expected at a pizza spot, but they were thoughtfully made and paired perfectly with the meal.
Everything about Wheated just clicked, from the energy of the room to the quality of the food. This is the kind of place you leave already planning what you’ll order next time. I cannot wait to come back. 🍕🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely one of the TOP Pie spots in Brooklyn!
Love the aesthetics! The bathroom door blending into the wall is cool! I don’t remember that last time I was here to dine-in but that was a while ago. I’ve done both take-out & dine-in here.
There were a couple tables available but they do fill up fast! I found a seat by the bar right away!
I ordered a drink while I waited I don’t remember the name but it was good.
The Pizza came after like 15min or so it wasn’t a long wait. I was really happy with its presentation, flavor & texture etc…
The cheese was perfectly melted, the crust was crispy & sauce was great! They definitely didn’t disappoint & piled high the toppings for the supreme part of the pie. I would definitely get the supreme again though next time I wanna try a white pie maybe the New Haven rosemary potato pie sounds good as a next try. I would also highly recommend the Flatbush for all the Eggplant lovers out there!
The service was good, the staff was attentive to my needs & were friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
What a wonderful place! Delicious food and a cozy atmosphere. I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Picked-up dinner but I want to come back to eat-in. Their bar counter overlooks their wide selection of bourbons and whiskeys in a cozy wood-covered interior. I did not order dinner myself but apparently you need to reserve spots for pick-up so the food is hot. Not 100% sure, but be prepared.
Pizza was excellent - I think we had plain (Bensonhurst) and Sunset Park. Caesar salad very good, too - anchovies in the sauce but no one minded. Nice combo for a get-together. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza! Despite we had to wait over 1 hour, the service was good and the pizza was so delicious, that i would definitely come back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The artichoke pizza (Prospect Park South) is to die for 🤤
What happened????? I keep trying to come back post covid and find myself disappointed every time. Pizza tonight was hard, very chewy, like a flatbread. Guessing the dough was overproofed, but this seems to be the norm now. We switched from ordering the small pie to the larger pie and it is now the same. This was one of my favorite pizzas in NY and now it is a shadow of its former self. I’m pulling for the restaurant but feel like there needs to be some internal soul searching. Sorry to sound like a Karen but someone needs to say it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Meatballs
Loading...