Bruegger's Bagels

2130 Delaware Ave, Buffalo
(716) 374-6792

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Salad on a Plain Bagel with Lettuce Tomatoes and American Cheese & a Pickle
Toasted Plain Bagel with Honey Walnut Cream Cheese
Egg Ham Egg and Cheese
Sack of Bagels & More
Bagel w Lox Shmear
Everything Bagel
Bagel with Egg
Salmon Bagel
The Hertel
Best Bagel

Menu

Oven Fresh
Single Bagel
Baker's Dozen
Bakers Dozen Sliced
Asiago
Cinnamon Stick
Cinnamon Stick W/ Butter
Cinnamon Twist
Sack of Bagels & More Sliced
Muffin
Muffin W/ Butter
1/2 Doz Muffins
Doz Muffins
Oatmeal
Pastry Heart
Challahs
Day Old Bagels
Bagel Crisps
15 Bagel Special
Sack And More
SAC AND MORE FLAVOR UP CHARGE
VEGGIE UPGRADE

Shmears
Bagel W/ Plain Cc
Bagel W/ Flavored Shmear
Bagel W/ Lox Shmear
Bagel W/ Butter
Bagel W/ Smart Balance
Bagel W/ Jelly
Bagel W/ PB & J
Plain Shmear Tub
Flavored Shmear Tub
Lox Shmear Tub
X Scoop Plain Cc
X Scoop Flav Cc
Butter Tub
Coffee Upgrade
Breakfast Special
Monday Madness
VEGGIE UPGRADE
EXTRA BUTTER

Eggel Bagels
No. 1 Egg & Cheese
No. 2 Egg, Ham & Cheese
No. 3 Egg, Bacon & Cheese
No. 4 Egg, Chicken Sausage & Cheese
THE JAY NORMOUS

Deli Favorites
Roasted Turkey Breast
Ham & Cheese
Ham
Corned Beef
Roast Beef
BLT
Turkey Melt
Slice Of Cheese
Xtra Meat
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
1/2 Bagel/ Sand & Soup
Chili Upgrade
8.99 MONTHLY Special
Lg Drink Upgrade
ADD FLAV CRM CHZ
ADD PL CRM CHZ
ADD PICKLE
VEGGIE UPGRADE

Jay's Classics
Tuna Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Salad
Cheese Melt
Tuna Melt
Cream Cheese & Nova
Xtra Nova
Veggie Delight
Hummus
Whitefish Salad
Pizza Bagel
Slice Of Cheese
1/2 Bagel Sand & Soup
Chili Upgrade
Lg Drink Upgrade
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
8.99 MONTHLY Special
Terrific Tuesday Special
ADD FLAV CRM CHZ
ADD PL CRM CHZ
VEGGIE UPGRADE
9.99 MONTHLY SPECIAL

Salads
Caesar Salad
Chicken Caesar Salad
Classic Salad Plate
Greek Salad
Green Salad
Scoop Of Tuna
Scoop Of Chicken Salad
Scoop of Egg Salad

Taste Tempting Specialties
Albuquerque Turkey
Athens Chicken
Athens Turkey
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Chicken Club Wrap
Hummus Wrap Spectacular
Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular
The Buffalo Club
The Delaware
The Downtowner
The Hertel
The Hopkins
The Reuben
Make it a Combo
Lg Drink Upgrade
8.49 Special
The Snyder
VEGGIE UPGRADE
ASIAGO

Soups & Sides
Soup Reg
Soup Lg
Chili Reg
Chili Lg
Chili w/Butter Bagel
1/2 Bagel & Soup
Chips
Coleslaw Side
Potato Salad

Desserts
Cookie
Black & White Cookie
Brownie
Chocolate Covered Macaroon
Crumb Cake
Pound Cake

Make it a Combo
Chips & Drink
Side Salad & Drink
Soup & Drink
Lg Drink Upgrade
Chili & Drink
Lg Chili Upgrade
Lg. Soup Upgrade

Beverages
Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Cappuccino
Hot Tea / Herbal Teas
Milk
Fountain Drink
Iced Coffee
Tropicana Juices & Lipton Teas
Dr. Browns Gatorade SOBE
Aquifina Water
Cofffee Box
LG ICE COFFEE
ADD SYRUP TO COFFEE

Smoked Salmon & Bulk
4oz Smoked Salmon
8oz Smoked Salmon
Turkey /lb
Corned Beef /lb
Ham /lb
Roast Beef /lb
Tuna Salad /lb
Chicken Salad /lb
Egg Salad /lb
Whitefish Salad /lb
Hummus /lb
Coleslaw /lb
Potato Salad /lb
Plain Cream Cheese /lb
Flavored Cream Cheese /lb
Lox Cream Cheese /lb
Smoked Salmon /lb

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+66 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+65 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Bagels are consistently fresh and perfectly toasted! The bagel flavors appealing and diverse as are the cream cheese flavors.
The staff is friendly, efficient, and helpful.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is clean, comfortable, and welcoming.
The prices are perceived as reasonable for the quality and experience.
Parking is free and easily accessibility.
July 2025
Out-of-towner, Jewish, big fan of NYC bagels (of course), second time eating at this location.

Breuggers has some excellent bagels! The hash brown bagel is really delicious!

If you get a smoked salmon bagel, make sure to ask for cream cheese on both sides, they kinda skimped on my portion today. Lots of salmon, half the cream cheese I would've wanted, lesson learned

Prices are awesome compared to my home town, food...
May 2025
Updating my review to reflect the takeover of Bruegger's Bagels from Bagel Jay's:

Whenever a local chain that is owned and operated by local people is sold off to a national chain, it's never a good sign. I very much appreciated all of the years that Bagel Jay's was open, as they seemed like a pillar of the community, and seemed to really care about its customers and its food quality. Not so anymore, it would seem.

What's...
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Federal Meats - Buffalo - Marshall’s Plaza, 3210, 2140 Delaware Ave
Butcher, Meat Shops, Seafood Markets
Pizza Hut - 2150 Delaware Ave
Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings, Fast Food
New China Restaurant - 2166 Delaware Ave
Chinese

Bruegger's Bagels

2130 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
(716) 374-6792