Bailey Avenue Pizza

2916 Bailey Ave, Buffalo
(716) 837-4444

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stacey Cruz

I could eat here every day and never get tired of it.

James W

Small place, literally a take out joint.
The pizza is top notch and the customer service was excellent . It was my first time. Ill definitely be back.

CeJay McMillan

I grew up on this pizza and it hasn't changed at all! Love this place , it's great for just grabbing a quick slice. The guy at the counter is cool and patient especially on the weekends. You're doing God's work lol keep it up we see you!

catherine burgos

FALSE ADVERTISING on prices and times of operation--- website info incorrect--

Cyndra Nash

I called to order a half of box of pizza and the girl decided she want me to a whole pizza
Then we get the pizza
It was so nasty
Like where was the sauce
Why is crust so damn hard
I been eating here for years
Dear new owners you are going to lose loyal customers if keep cutting corners.
Make sure employees are not over charging customers
How I order a half of box of pizza but you charge and place a full box of pizza
40.00 was wasted on garbage
I could of went a corner store and got better pizza a hot and ready

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joe Bloniarz

New fave place to stop and grab a slice. Great buffalo pizza. Definitely a gem on bailey

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Bell

Friendly staff good food

Breanna Harris

I called to make an order because the doors was locked. When it should have been open because it was opening time. But the man that answered the phone was DISGUSTING I made a joke about the doors being locked because I’m sitting outside and he got REAL NASTY and hung up on me. I have been going here since I was a kid and for him to be so nasty to a loyal customer threw me for a loop. This makes me NEVER WANT TO SUPPORT THEM AGAIN. I am very disappointed and disgusted at his customer service. Maybe he need to not answer any phone calls. I wanted to get nasty but I let the lady know what happen and she opologize but nevertheless I took my money elsewhere. Please do better.

Service: 1

Martin Ceciliano

I couldn't believe the size of a slice of pizza. I'm glad I didn't order 2. Would never have finished it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice, Cheese & Pepperoni Slice

Tweety Bird

Ordered TWO cheese and pepperoni slices thru uber eats and only got one slice like i didnt pay for that on top of that making my uber driver wait for 10 mins to only get one pizza smh order name Star S

Honest Reviews

The Caucasian man behind the counter is the rudest person I’ve ever encountered in customer service. Everything he says is condescending and disrespectful. Today, I walked in and asked for a well-done slice because they never cook the pizza correctly. He snapped, “Well, it’s gonna be 15 minutes!” I repeated, “15 minutes?” to clarify, and he rudely yelled back, “Yes, because the health department says I can’t remove the pizza from the box and reheat it, so you have to wait for a fresh pie.”

I didn’t ask for an explanation, but his tone and attitude were unnecessary. I will not be returning. Every time I go there, he’s speaking to someone rudely. He either hates his job or has a problem with Black people. Either way, he should not be dealing with customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Emilio Santos

Awesome welcome . And the food is delicious. Is my first time coming here and I am hooked . Thank you .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, BBQ Chicken Wings

Mount Up 716

The pizza was absolutely the thicccest pizza I've ever had and it was delicious ? definitely recommend

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Party Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza

Kimberly Hunter

Food is always hot,ready and huge portions for your money.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Slice, Pizza

mike Will

Best slices in the town $5 a slice but it's big as the pizza box blue cheese top tier too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice

Loading...