Bailey Avenue Pizza
2916 Bailey Ave, Buffalo
(716) 837-4444
Customers' Favorites
Party Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese & Pepperoni Slice
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
BBQ Chicken Wings
Large
Steak
Appetizers
Mozzarella Stix
6 Pieces
Pizza Logs
5 Pieces
Fries
Everyday Specials
1/2 Pizza - Cheese + 1 Ingredient & 10 Wings
1/2 Pizza - Cheese + 1 Ingredient & 20 Wings
Large Cheese Pizza + 1 Ingredient & 20 Wings
Large Cheese Pizza + 1 Ingredient & 30 Wings
Large Cheese Pizza + 1 Ingredient & 50 Wings
Party Pizza + 1 Ingredient & 50 Wings
Pizza
Cheese (1/2)
Cheese (Whole)
Cheese & Pepperoni (1/2)
Cheese & Pepperoni (Whole)
Party Pizza
Cheese (Party)
Cheese & Pepperoni (Party)
Bailey Pizzeria Special
Bailey Pizzeria Special (Half)
Cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, sweet peppers, onions, green olives
Bailey Pizzeria Special (Whole)
Cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, sweet peppers, onions, green olives
Everything Pizza Special
Everything (Half)
Ground beef & meat balls available as pizza toppings
Everything (Whole)
Ground beef & meat balls available as pizza toppings
Pizza by the Slice!
Cheese & Pepperoni (Slice)
Submarines 8"
Assorted 8"
Bailey Pizzeria "Royal" 8"
Fried Italian sausage & capicola
Baked Beef 8"
Capicola 8"
Cheese 8"
Cheeseburger 8"
Chicken - N- Cheese Parmesan 8"
Chicken Finger 8"
Fried Italian Sausage 8"
Ham 8"
Hamburger 8"
Hard Salami 8"
Hitman's Delight 8"
Fried Italian sausage, hard salami, capicola, peppers & onions
Meat Ball 8"
Meat Ball Parmesan 8"
Pepperoni 8"
Pizza Sub 8"
Regular Steak Hoagie 8"
Fried onions & melted cheese
Roast Beef 8"
Sausage Hoagie 8"
Sausage Parmesan 8"
Steak & Cheese 8"
Lettuce & tomato
Steak & Sausage Hoagie 8"
Super Steak Hoagie 8"
Fried onions, mushrooms, hot & sweet peppers plus melted cheese
Top of the Bailey Pizzeria Double Decker 8"
With ham, hard salami & capicola
Tuna 8"
BLT 8"
Turkey & Bacon 8"
Turkey Breast 8"
Submarines 12"
Assorted 12"
Bailey Pizzeria "Royal" 12"
Fried Italian sausage & capicola
Baked Beef 12"
Capicola 12"
Cheese 12"
Cheeseburger 12"
Chicken - N- Cheese Parmesan 12"
Chicken Finger 12"
Fried Italian Sausage 12"
Ham 12"
Hamburger 12"
Hard Salami 12"
Hitman's Delight 12"
Fried Italian sausage, hard salami, capicola, peppers & onions
Meat Ball 12"
Meat Ball Parmesan 12"
Pepperoni 12"
Pizza Sub 12"
Regular Steak Hoagie 12"
Fried onions & melted cheese
Roast Beef 12"
Sausage Hoagie 12"
Sausage Parmesan 12"
Steak & Cheese 12"
Lettuce & tomato
Steak & Sausage Hoagie 12"
Super Steak Hoagie 12"
Fried onions, mushrooms, hot & sweet peppers plus melted cheese
Top of the Bailey Pizzeria Double Decker 12"
With ham, hard salami & capicola
Tuna 12"
BLT 12"
Turkey & Bacon 12"
Turkey Breast 12"
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings (10)
Chicken Wings (20)
Chicken Wings (30)
Chicken Wings (50)
Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings (10)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
Boneless Wings (20)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
Boneless Wings (30)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
Boneless Wings (50)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Finger (5)
Chicken Finger (10)
Chicken Finger (15)
Soft Drinks
Water Bottle
1 Liter Bottle
2 Liter Bottle
Pure Leaf
Cans
Side of Sauce
Side of Blue Cheese
Side of Honey Mustard
Side of Steak Sauce
Side of Marinara
Side of Hot Buffalo
Side of Medium Buffalo
Side of Mild Buffalo
Side of BBQ
Side of Honey BBQ
Side of Garlic Parm
Side of Lemon Pepper
Side of Kicken Burbon
Side of Sweet Chili
Tuesday Special
Tuesday Wings (10 Wings)
Tuesday Wings (20 Wings)
Tuesday Wings (30 Wings)
Tuesday Wings (50 Wings)
Photos
+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I grew up on this pizza and it hasn't changed at all! Love this place , it's great for just grabbing a quick slice. The guy at the counter is cool and patient especially on the weekends. You're doing God's work lol keep it up we see you!
June 2025
Ordered pizza and some boneless wings. Buffalo pizza Market is tough I'd say the pizza was just average, was cooked the way I like it. The boneless wings were a complete flop! Over cooked and where the sauce?
March 2024
The young lady at the counter is always a pleasure to see. I absolutely enjoy coming there to get my slices and seeing her as well. She always greets with a smile and is very polite and caring.
March 2024
You May Also Like
Caribbean Experience - 2897 Bailey Ave
![]()
Jamaican, Caribbean, Vegetarian
Louie's Texas Red Hots - 2811 Bailey Ave # A
![]()
Hot Dogs, American, Burgers, New American, Salad
Captain of the Sea - 3038 Bailey Ave
![]()
Fish & Chips, Seafood