For my Dad’s 80th birthday we ordered something special and Caramici’s bakery did not disappoint. Beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly Diviak
For my Dad’s 80th birthday we ordered something special and Caramici’s bakery did not disappoint. Beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. It was perfect!
Darlene B.
This place was a genuis find for my search for Italian bakeries. If I wouldn't have looked on YELP, would have never known about this bakery. The location isn't where you would think to find a bakery. Located in a former elementary or middle school is where you'll find it. Cute set up, my boyfriend was thrilled that the bakery made cuccidati, lemon cookies and we both loved the orange pecan biscotti, there flavorful, and great for dipping in coffee. Defintly check it out if your in search of authentic Italian cookies, and cascata cakes.
Greg G.
Didn't realize that they were here until I went to vote. I remember how good everything was prepared and tasted. I am glad I happened to have found it again. I bought about a dozen different cookies and pastries. They were as good as they always were. I will definitely return to purchase these well made treats.
Maryann Gullo
Maryann G.As a first time customer, we ordered the Cassata Cake for my Birthday. It was beautifully decorated as well as delicious. And the price was so reasonable! We'll definitely will be returning to try her other baked goods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Crist
Where do I begin? My husband and I reached out to Caramici’s Bakery for our wedding cake! We have known Diane Serra for years. We live in MA and really hoped we would be able to work something out where she would be the one to create our dream wedding cake! Once we got engaged and picked a date, we reached out to start to figure out if this would even be possible. Diane’s immediate response was “of course we can, let’s start planning!” My husband and I were so excited about this and couldn’t wait to bring our ideas to life! Diane was so amazing! We did multiple zoom calls (due to distance) and she even drew up several different cake styles for us and walked us through what each would look like! She was extremely responsive and never complained about all the different changes or additions I had (and I had ALOT). As an anxious bride who wanted everything to be perfect, Diane was extremely patient and made me feel comfortable that our cake was in the best hands!!Fast forward to our wedding which was this past Sunday 9/3, the cake was GORGEOUS! Diane brought the separate cake layers to the venue and decorated/put the cake together AT THE VENUE! That is some serious first class service!! Diane did not crack under the pressure of having a short window to decorate the cake and have it look as elegant as we wanted! And aside from the way the cake looked, O-M-G was it beyond DELICIOUS! I think at the wedding my husband and I had a piece of each layer!! Our waist lines are still upset with us! 4 days later, we are still getting text messages from friends and family saying that it was the best tasting wedding cake they ever had!!!Mike & I can’t thank Diane & Caramici’s Bakery enough for everything they did for us to bring our dream wedding cake to life!!
Marylouise Kompson
I ordered a chocolate cassata cake with very short notice on a very busy weekend. They were able to do it!! Thank you it was for my mothers 90th birthday - the cake was AMAZING I will never go anywhere else and I am looking forward to trying all the cakes on the menu ! Thank you thank you thank you !!!
Armando A.
I would love to leave a review . I was truly looking forward to trying the Cassatta Chocolata ,so I called the bakery and left my name, phone number and an explanation what I wanted. No one ever returned my phone call.
Michael D
this is the best f*coin cannoli I've ever had.... can't wait to order a cassata and eat the entire thing in one sitting..
The fact that none of the sweets they offer comes from a factory justifies their price. For that same reason, you get a unique taste of their sweets than you would from even places like Paula's Donuts. The Almond Bear Claws have a great ratio of the pastry to almond filling; the pastry itself is soft and flaky; and the right amount of icing to give it sweetness without being too overpowering. They impressed me very much in my accidental visit to their site and I am looking forward to visit it again in the near future to try their other desserts.
Annie P
We ordered a cassata cake and Italian pastries for a baptism. Everything was delicious! It's not easy to find Italian pastries in Buffalo anymore, so we are so happy we found someone who makes them - especially sfogliatelle. Definitely recommend Diane and her staff for delicious desserts!
Christina Chiavetta Stapf
We ordered a cassata cake for my mother’s birthday party. EVERYONE loved it! A house full of Italians and everyone thought it was the best cassata! Will definitely be back!
Katherine Majewski
Ordered the Spumoni cake for a special birthday. It fit the occasion - very special, beautiful and delicious!
Robert Bruno
Support your local bakeries. This is an excellent little bakery located in the former Phillip Sheridan Elementary School. All baked goods that are offered are of good quality. Give them a try!
Love this place taste is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For my Dad’s 80th birthday we ordered something special and Caramici’s bakery did not disappoint. Beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For my Dad’s 80th birthday we ordered something special and Caramici’s bakery did not disappoint. Beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. It was perfect!
This place was a genuis find for my search for Italian bakeries. If I wouldn't have looked on YELP, would have never known about this bakery. The location isn't where you would think to find a bakery. Located in a former elementary or middle school is where you'll find it. Cute set up, my boyfriend was thrilled that the bakery made cuccidati, lemon cookies and we both loved the orange pecan biscotti, there flavorful, and great for dipping in coffee. Defintly check it out if your in search of authentic Italian cookies, and cascata cakes.
Didn't realize that they were here until I went to vote. I remember how good everything was prepared and tasted. I am glad I happened to have found it again. I bought about a dozen different cookies and pastries. They were as good as they always were. I will definitely return to purchase these well made treats.
Maryann G.As a first time customer, we ordered the Cassata Cake for my Birthday. It was beautifully decorated as well as delicious. And the price was so reasonable! We'll definitely will be returning to try her other baked goods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Where do I begin? My husband and I reached out to Caramici’s Bakery for our wedding cake! We have known Diane Serra for years. We live in MA and really hoped we would be able to work something out where she would be the one to create our dream wedding cake! Once we got engaged and picked a date, we reached out to start to figure out if this would even be possible. Diane’s immediate response was “of course we can, let’s start planning!” My husband and I were so excited about this and couldn’t wait to bring our ideas to life! Diane was so amazing! We did multiple zoom calls (due to distance) and she even drew up several different cake styles for us and walked us through what each would look like! She was extremely responsive and never complained about all the different changes or additions I had (and I had ALOT). As an anxious bride who wanted everything to be perfect, Diane was extremely patient and made me feel comfortable that our cake was in the best hands!!Fast forward to our wedding which was this past Sunday 9/3, the cake was GORGEOUS! Diane brought the separate cake layers to the venue and decorated/put the cake together AT THE VENUE! That is some serious first class service!! Diane did not crack under the pressure of having a short window to decorate the cake and have it look as elegant as we wanted! And aside from the way the cake looked, O-M-G was it beyond DELICIOUS! I think at the wedding my husband and I had a piece of each layer!! Our waist lines are still upset with us! 4 days later, we are still getting text messages from friends and family saying that it was the best tasting wedding cake they ever had!!!Mike & I can’t thank Diane & Caramici’s Bakery enough for everything they did for us to bring our dream wedding cake to life!!
I ordered a chocolate cassata cake with very short notice on a very busy weekend. They were able to do it!! Thank you it was for my mothers 90th birthday - the cake was AMAZING I will never go anywhere else and I am looking forward to trying all the cakes on the menu ! Thank you thank you thank you !!!
I would love to leave a review . I was truly looking forward to trying the Cassatta Chocolata ,so I called the bakery and left my name, phone number and an explanation what I wanted. No one ever returned my phone call.
this is the best f*coin cannoli I've ever had.... can't wait to order a cassata and eat the entire thing in one sitting..
Restaurantji Recommends
The fact that none of the sweets they offer comes from a factory justifies their price. For that same reason, you get a unique taste of their sweets than you would from even places like Paula's Donuts. The Almond Bear Claws have a great ratio of the pastry to almond filling; the pastry itself is soft and flaky; and the right amount of icing to give it sweetness without being too overpowering. They impressed me very much in my accidental visit to their site and I am looking forward to visit it again in the near future to try their other desserts.
We ordered a cassata cake and Italian pastries for a baptism. Everything was delicious! It's not easy to find Italian pastries in Buffalo anymore, so we are so happy we found someone who makes them - especially sfogliatelle. Definitely recommend Diane and her staff for delicious desserts!
We ordered a cassata cake for my mother’s birthday party. EVERYONE loved it! A house full of Italians and everyone thought it was the best cassata! Will definitely be back!
Ordered the Spumoni cake for a special birthday. It fit the occasion - very special, beautiful and delicious!
Support your local bakeries. This is an excellent little bakery located in the former Phillip Sheridan Elementary School. All baked goods that are offered are of good quality. Give them a try!