North Street Subway

35 North St, Buffalo
(716) 881-2454

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Lauer

Buffalo's best pizza and wings. Great pasta and subs as well

Mike Davidson

Great local subshop/pizzeria

Christina Stock

The food is delicious and the guy at the counter was hilarious. My mom and I had a great lunch from here.

T. Denny

This really is a hidden little gem in Allentown. I've lived in the area 2.5 years and just stopped in for the first time...very unassuming spot, with really superb quality and prices. I'm sad that I've missed out on 2.5 years of great food. Friendly staff, simple space, and great food!

JoDee Cruz

They never answer the phone.

James Cichocki

Great food, but they’re never open. If I call at 5pm on Saturday night, I would hope someone would answer. This is the third time recently that I’ve tried to order during regular hours and they’re closed.

Buffalo Bob

There were way too many flys in that place .Will not be back .They also serve really old slices

Rosetta Jenkins

The pizza I was served tasted like it had been sitting there for a while. Taste like gas station pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

LUIS RODRIGUEZ

The prices online do not reflect the prices of the food. When we ordered it came out to more than expected and when we called to inquire about it, we were told that "they do not control the menu online." When we asked how customers are supposed to know the real prices if they were looking to order they said that's why "they have menus." However, that doesn't help if someone is at work and wants to order a quick lunch. Online lunch specials say $8.99 but the real price is 11.99. Just some FYI.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Erik Heerdt

Was told by a friend to try this place, placed an order, and picked it up. I was less than impressed. I ordered a cheeseburger sub, with no onions, instead it was filled with onions, the cheese wasn't even melted like they placed them in the sub after they cooked the burgers and I ordered some fries and they tasted under cooked almost raw. Maybe it was a busy or off day for the place but I'm not sure I'm willing to come back and give it another shot.

catherine nicole

Clean and very welcoming. Support local pizza places like this is worth it. Gentleman in the front was so friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

el cucumber

quality food at a quality price with excellent service. subs and pizza are excellent, but I've got to come back to try their other offerings.

pizza: thin crust (passes the fold test), flavourful sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese! top tier NY style pizza

subs: we got the royal sub (sausage, capicola, and cheese), absolutely wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Jamie and David Engel

Great food, fantastic friendly staff. Was hard to find parking but so worth it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Finger Pizza, Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Finger

Mark Ejnik

You know I really thought the pizza was going to be better. I looked at that old sign out front and was like these guys must know how to make a great pizza. I rated it at three stars.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

patricia harper

Will not ever patronize their business again food is good but when they mess up your order they don't want to rectify the problem the guy was actually telling me I was wrong and the proof was on the receipt I can see it and he could too. Restaurants have to be mindful of their order food cost to much for mistakes

Loading...