Cookies & Cream

2114 Seneca St, Buffalo
(716) 322-0040

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Austin Ihle

Good ice cream when they have it. But it's expensive and they are ALWAYS out of 3/4 of the menu. I feel bad for the workers having to answer to that.

Debi Johnson

Fun place. Great outdoor area

the lober (lober)

Ice cream is always really good, but they've had some bad staffing issues as of late. I've gone at 4pm for 5 days in a row now and they've always been locked up with a paper sign that says sorry closed at 6 (pm) on the door. Hope business picks up enough to fix this because the food is amazing!
Edit, looks like it's regular hours for the summer now! Place is still great

Tony Avino

From the time we walked in, the girl behind the counter made us feel welcome. Made some great suggestions and as always the desserts are out of this world!!

Faith Hester

I love it! I come here almost everyday 😋

Jessica Hopkins

PLEASE just update with your ACCURATE hours. Disappointed kids again today.

Edgar Rife

Amazing service. Big portions. Tasty desserts!

Joshua Robinson

The staff here is always great, but some things are good on the menu and other things could be better. The cookies are all delicious, but the soft serve leaves something to be desired. It might have just been something wrong with the machine but the texture was too icy and not nearly as creamy as some other places. I think the hard ice cream is fine, but if you are looking for soft serve specifically this might not be the place. Also it seems like the milk shake machine may have been out of order for a while based on other reviews. Still a good place to have in the neighborhood!

Kate Riley

This cookie and ice cream shoppe is so lovely. A step back in time in decor with the warm smell of fresh baked goods. All of the cookies are worth trying, and they usually have two (two!) Gluten Free cookie options. Much love to Cookies & Cream in the Southtowns area!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free Options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J P

Really nice ice cream spot! They've got a neat out door are, patio as well as a nice interior space. The ice cream was creamy and delicious.

Kid-friendliness: Very much so

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Summer fiegel

went in to get ice cream, got two 77s and 2 cookies, the “blizzards” were literally ice cream soup…. i never complain about anything but this was ridiculous lmfao on the way out i saw a sign that said “sorry no milkshakes” so i realized the machine isn’t working but no one said that while i ordered or cashed out that the blizzards wouldn’t be able to be made either ???? i should’ve been told sorry the machine is broken but we can do this instead, not just throw it together how they did and giving it to me like this….??? i would’ve gotten something else, idk if they were just flustered or what but definitely not happy for spending $22 on ice cream and cookies.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Asha Glorioso

Ordered a ‘77 with pb cups and chocolate pretzel caramel. Figured it was all mushed in with vanilla, my fault on not checking. The chocolate part on the pretzel option means ice cream. The girls made it and then saw I do not like chocolate ice cream and then offered to fix it with vanilla - at closing time. It was delicioussss and the service made it that much more enjoyable!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JAIME Rodriguez

Great little ice cream store . A lot for your buck .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charisma Garcia

I took my kids there and they loved the ice cream and I had a cookie from here and it was so amazing reminds me of my mom's cooking ❤️ I will definitely be back and very reasonable prices just a great place and clean

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Big as the Babies Head, Macadamia Nut Cookie

Kanupriya Pandey

Loved the raspberry ice cream. Definitely one of my favorites now. Nice atmosphere and the two employees were really sweet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...