An old style atmosphere ice cream and cookie store with helpful friendly staff. SO far the food has been outstanding. I have not found a dish of ice cream that I regret. I strongly recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vinnie L
We were in here on a Saturday night 2/3/24 and it was packed! The two employees were awesome! They worked incredibly hard to fill orders for over a dozen people and DoorDash. The ice cream we ordered was fantastic, the employees were very friendly and the place was very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brad Marshall
First time trying Cookies and Cream on Seneca st. It was very busy at about 7pm. The ice cream was very good I would recommend. The service was a little slow because of how busy they were but it was worth the wait! We may try ordering ahead next time to avoid that next
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Debbie
Had an issue with a purchase and after speaking with one of the workers, they more than made up for it. Our new cake was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tamara Green
Cookie sundaes! We came in about an hour before closing, and they were out of our first two choices of cookies. We ended up getting the Macadamia Nut Cookie Sundae. It was really good! It was the perfect amount to split with someone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jes H
Cookie butter milkshake is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mariah B
Always good here! Friendly employees and wonderful selection of freshly baked cookies! And of course, Ice cream!!!
Ryan Nicastro
I would give them 5 but they have very limited non dairy accommodations.
Debb S.
Upon recommendation from a few South Buffalo natives, I was really impressed at this year-round ice cream shop. The selection of ice cream novelties and cookies is enormous. When I walked in, Donna was baking waffle cones on the spot and was very helpful in helping me decide on my order. She truly loved working here and I thought she was the owner. The shop is very clean and comfortable with a very cute outside patio for additional seating and of course, the perfect aroma of freshly baked cookies. I love that they're open all year around, and even tho I reside in the suburbs, I will definitely be back. I'm glad I discovered this hidden gem in South Buffalo!
Edward Grey
No summer day is complete without ice cream. This place won't disappoint. Not only an assortment of specials but they also do them to order. Very friendly and attractive staff.
Smells like cookies and vanilla as soon as you walk in! Sundaes are huge. Outdoor area is shaded and quaint. Perfect little hidden gem
Chris Glick
A bit pricey but good choices such as cookie sundaes, cookie sandwiches, and ice cream birthday cakes.
Raymond Herman
Great treat, friendly staff, retro dine in. Neat relaxing outside seating area! Best peanut butter sauce!!Update I do t know what's going on but the last few times I went there the ice cream started to taste different, this it was completely awful the ice cream had almost a texture to it ufaul!
Eric Warren
Really nice cookie and ice cream shop. The ice cream sandwiches are gigantic
Colleen Nelson
My custard was gritty...very unpalatable. It was my first time having the custard and my last.
An old style atmosphere ice cream and cookie store with helpful friendly staff. SO far the food has been outstanding. I have not found a dish of ice cream that I regret. I strongly recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were in here on a Saturday night 2/3/24 and it was packed! The two employees were awesome! They worked incredibly hard to fill orders for over a dozen people and DoorDash. The ice cream we ordered was fantastic, the employees were very friendly and the place was very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying Cookies and Cream on Seneca st. It was very busy at about 7pm. The ice cream was very good I would recommend. The service was a little slow because of how busy they were but it was worth the wait! We may try ordering ahead next time to avoid that next
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Had an issue with a purchase and after speaking with one of the workers, they more than made up for it. Our new cake was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cookie sundaes! We came in about an hour before closing, and they were out of our first two choices of cookies. We ended up getting the Macadamia Nut Cookie Sundae. It was really good! It was the perfect amount to split with someone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cookie butter milkshake is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good here! Friendly employees and wonderful selection of freshly baked cookies! And of course, Ice cream!!!
I would give them 5 but they have very limited non dairy accommodations.
Upon recommendation from a few South Buffalo natives, I was really impressed at this year-round ice cream shop. The selection of ice cream novelties and cookies is enormous. When I walked in, Donna was baking waffle cones on the spot and was very helpful in helping me decide on my order. She truly loved working here and I thought she was the owner. The shop is very clean and comfortable with a very cute outside patio for additional seating and of course, the perfect aroma of freshly baked cookies. I love that they're open all year around, and even tho I reside in the suburbs, I will definitely be back. I'm glad I discovered this hidden gem in South Buffalo!
No summer day is complete without ice cream. This place won't disappoint. Not only an assortment of specials but they also do them to order. Very friendly and attractive staff.
Restaurantji Recommends
Smells like cookies and vanilla as soon as you walk in! Sundaes are huge. Outdoor area is shaded and quaint. Perfect little hidden gem
A bit pricey but good choices such as cookie sundaes, cookie sandwiches, and ice cream birthday cakes.
Great treat, friendly staff, retro dine in. Neat relaxing outside seating area! Best peanut butter sauce!!Update I do t know what's going on but the last few times I went there the ice cream started to taste different, this it was completely awful the ice cream had almost a texture to it ufaul!
Really nice cookie and ice cream shop. The ice cream sandwiches are gigantic
My custard was gritty...very unpalatable. It was my first time having the custard and my last.