Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
929 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 381-8699
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Blizzard with Chocolate and Artisan Coca Cola
Snack Aisle Cookie Sundae
Chocolate Ice Cream
Scoop of Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sandwich
Cookies & Cream
Hot Fudge
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This is a review for Cookies & Cream On the Water, which is located at the Outer Harbor. We were very happy customers! Mary Catherine took care of our order and expertly created picture-perfect, delicious desserts. The cookie dough creation was crowned best in show, but everyone enjoyed their treat and the lovely waterfront setting. Highly recommended and a special shoutout to Mary Catherine who was very kind and helpful!
Very cute and quaint. ☺️
Good first date spot, or if you just need a spot to get away and decompress for a moment. The sugar cookie is delicious, but the smores cookie is top tier! It's a chocolate based cookie versus your standard tan.
The strawberry cheesecake icecream 9/10
Cookies and cream icecream 1000/10 (please try)
Cookie dough icecream 8/10
You're allowed to split one scoop of icecream into two types of flavors...
Good first date spot, or if you just need a spot to get away and decompress for a moment. The sugar cookie is delicious, but the smores cookie is top tier! It's a chocolate based cookie versus your standard tan.
The strawberry cheesecake icecream 9/10
Cookies and cream icecream 1000/10 (please try)
Cookie dough icecream 8/10
You're allowed to split one scoop of icecream into two types of flavors...
You May Also Like
Starbucks - 933 Elmwood Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Elmwood Taco & Subs - 937 Elmwood Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican, American, New American, Vegan
McGarrets - 946 Elmwood Ave
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar
Was a bit hard. Its ice cream or maybe Buffalo does ice cream different than the west coast. I let it warm up the cookies and cream 10 for 10. Butter pecan 15 outta 10. My wife got strawberry on a white chocolate macadamia cookie [think that] strawberry wasn't outta the park. 8.5 outta 10 It was good. The cookie. 7.5 of 10 it was sweet and im a candy addict.. so that says something.
Would...