Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Love to see more socially conscious businesses in our community. Keep up the great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
john previty
Pizza is Extra Great! Always Fresh ingredients. Great service and pleasant professional staff. Always have a different selection of wines and cocktails.
Jack Jerris
Have had better
Guy Huber
Loved it great pizza and variety of toppings also had salad very good.
Phillip Littrell
Fantastic pizza! Enjoyed the Fried Chicken and mushroom with white sauce. The meatball pizza is just fantastic, order extra, double or triple meatballs, because they are great.
Matthew Chavanne
NY style (NOT buffalo style) pizza. Overall the food was very good. However, a small chef salad and a large pizza with a few toppings, with no drinks, split between two people cost $60. While I can get behind the concept of a tipless pricing scheme, the pricing is not proportional to the quality, taste, or experience of the food.
S Colvin
I was there for a private event. I was very surprised how nice it is! They have wine and tfull bar as well as food. The food was prepared by a person who works there and it was amazing and delicious. I would imagine the food you order there is probably delicious too! Nice atmosphere, very clean and inviting. Only negative is parking is tight on the street if it's a group of people going. Know your streets and direction of the street. Well worth it to try it out! I will be going back next time looking for a place near the location!
Elizabeth McCulloch
I can’t believe I just went to Extra Extra for the very first time. I’m in LOVE!! I’ve enjoyed it take out before but hands down let me tell you that nothing beats this pie right out of the oven! Amazing.
Greg
Average pizza, online order was set at 7:25 and pizza was on the colder side when picked up at that time.
Mark Hogan
Very high quality toppings and massive drinks menu. Cute small patio if you are here in the summer. Good vegan and gluten free options
Extra Extra Pizza is a great place to go for outstanding, steaming hot pizza ! I went there on a Friday night with 4 others so we had a 20 minute wait but it was well worth it. We ordered two different vegetarian pizzas - one with vegan pepperoni! They were delicious! We will definitely return to this immaculate little Westside restaurant!!!
Lauren Dean
This pizza is so good! The pizza shop was so cute. Very nice people! I am from out of town and wanted some good NY pizza. This hit the spot!!! It was so good!! Thank you! Definitely recommend!!
Garrett Breindel
Ok so, all I really have to say is that this is legitimately the worst tasting pizza I've ever had in my entire life. My one friend couldn't even finish his slice. How this place has such high ratings is beyond me.
David Rowe
They have a really good vibe to the place and it's one of the top pizzas in Buffalo taste-wise
Dale Denton
Closest thing to Sally's from New Haven. So good I come here every time I'm in town and happily buy the group pie
Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Love to see more socially conscious businesses in our community. Keep up the great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is Extra Great! Always Fresh ingredients. Great service and pleasant professional staff. Always have a different selection of wines and cocktails.
Have had better
Loved it great pizza and variety of toppings also had salad very good.
Fantastic pizza! Enjoyed the Fried Chicken and mushroom with white sauce. The meatball pizza is just fantastic, order extra, double or triple meatballs, because they are great.
NY style (NOT buffalo style) pizza. Overall the food was very good. However, a small chef salad and a large pizza with a few toppings, with no drinks, split between two people cost $60. While I can get behind the concept of a tipless pricing scheme, the pricing is not proportional to the quality, taste, or experience of the food.
I was there for a private event. I was very surprised how nice it is! They have wine and tfull bar as well as food. The food was prepared by a person who works there and it was amazing and delicious. I would imagine the food you order there is probably delicious too! Nice atmosphere, very clean and inviting. Only negative is parking is tight on the street if it's a group of people going. Know your streets and direction of the street. Well worth it to try it out! I will be going back next time looking for a place near the location!
I can’t believe I just went to Extra Extra for the very first time. I’m in LOVE!! I’ve enjoyed it take out before but hands down let me tell you that nothing beats this pie right out of the oven! Amazing.
Average pizza, online order was set at 7:25 and pizza was on the colder side when picked up at that time.
Very high quality toppings and massive drinks menu. Cute small patio if you are here in the summer. Good vegan and gluten free options
Restaurantji Recommends
Extra Extra Pizza is a great place to go for outstanding, steaming hot pizza ! I went there on a Friday night with 4 others so we had a 20 minute wait but it was well worth it. We ordered two different vegetarian pizzas - one with vegan pepperoni! They were delicious! We will definitely return to this immaculate little Westside restaurant!!!
This pizza is so good! The pizza shop was so cute. Very nice people! I am from out of town and wanted some good NY pizza. This hit the spot!!! It was so good!! Thank you! Definitely recommend!!
Ok so, all I really have to say is that this is legitimately the worst tasting pizza I've ever had in my entire life. My one friend couldn't even finish his slice. How this place has such high ratings is beyond me.
They have a really good vibe to the place and it's one of the top pizzas in Buffalo taste-wise
Closest thing to Sally's from New Haven. So good I come here every time I'm in town and happily buy the group pie
Loading...