Extra Extra Pizza
549 W Utica St, Buffalo
(716) 248-2994
Customers' Favorites
Medium Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Finger Pizza Slice
Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
Jalapeno Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese and Onion Pizza
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Large Cheese Pizza
Large Cheese Pie
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I love this place. It's one of my favorites in Buffalo and I've tried them all. The pizza (thin crust) is delicious (they have vegan cheese and meat), it's a cute atmosphere, and it's a worker cooperative!! They have an excellent drink list (one of the workers owners is a sommelier), cocktails, and great mocktails too (they even use NA liquor). Tips are included too!
Updated from previous review on 2025-09-18
NY style (NOT buffalo style) pizza. Overall the food was very good. However, a small chef salad and a large pizza with a few toppings, with no drinks, split between two people cost $60. While I can get behind the concept of a tipless pricing scheme, the pricing is not proportional to the quality, taste, or experience of the food.
I was there for a private event. I was very surprised how nice it is! They have wine and tfull bar as well as food. The food was prepared by a person who works there and it was amazing and delicious. I would imagine the food you order there is probably delicious too! Nice atmosphere, very clean and inviting. Only negative is parking is tight on the street if it's a group of people going. Know your streets and direction of the street. Well worth it to try it out! I will be...
You May Also Like
Las Puertas Buffalo - 385 Rhode Island St
![]()
Latin American, Vegan, Vegetarian, Mexican
Remedy House - 429 Rhode Island St
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly