Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop

I recently had the experience of having to locate a bakery on a last minute basis. The staff at Fairy Cakes Cupcakery not only immediately said they could help, but the three tier cake, and 4 dozen cupcakes were stunning. They fit our baby shower theme PERFECTLY) and we're raved about by the guests. Everything was superior quality, taste, and the service was wonderful. We will be ordering again for an event this coming fall!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had ordered cookies from them for my bachelorette and they were custom and turned out so cute (champagne tower)!! They were supposed to be individually wrapped but when we picked them up, they weren’t. We didn’t have time to go back so we brought them home and bagged them ourselves, but Fairycakes did refund us the pre-bagged charge. We also got a small cake to cut and it was SSOO GOOOD and we were eating it days later. A tad pricey for a 5 inch cake, but the cake was amazing so to me, it was worth it. All of their desserts really are incredible and they own up to any mistakes they make and do the right thing to fix them. We already said we want to get our wedding cake each year on our anniversary from them❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have used Fairycakes for our bridal shower and our wedding and we cannot recommend them enough! Not only are their cakes and desserts beyond delicious but their decoration and presentation is out of this world!! Their creations are truly a work of art! Their attention to detail and ability to execute the beauty and design of the desserts is unlike anything I've seen! The team at fairy cakes took the time to meet with us, consult with our wedding planner and other vendors, and were able to take our very complex and unique vision and bring it to life!! Our wedding dessert table was a rainbow colorblock and we were speechless and in awe when we saw the final product. We have received countless compliments on how beautiful our dessert tables were! The team at fairy cakes had wonderful communication, were very kind and patient, and were an absolute pleasure to work with! We cannot thank you all enough!! Xo-The Lekkis

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hands down the absolute best place to order custom cakes! Love it here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was searching for vegan & gluten free cakes in Buffalo and reviews online pointed me to Fairycakes. They exceeded my expectations! From the start as I was communicating what I wanted via email they were so open and available to make my birthday cake dream come true! My friends who shared the cake with me agreed with me that if you didn't know it was vegan and gluten free you would have never guessed it was! The cake was so light and the icing so rich! Will absolutely come to them for any cake or cupcake needs in the future! Thank you Fairycakes!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly & Mo extended their Talents and Professionalism to Make Our Daughter & Son in Law's Sweetheart Cake for their Wedding on 8/10!! It was BEAUTIFUL & Delicious!!! They worked with me (MOB) over Calls & Emails, with All questions answered promptly! They were highly recommended by our Venue and now We know Why!! Thank You for Making this Day Special for All of Us!!!

Ruth Anne Smith

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I called to order 20 cupcakes for a birthday. The lady I spoke on the phone was very nice stating that they could do a mix of cupcakes.(As I couldn’t make up my mind about what delicious flavors I wanted) So I agreed to that.
When I arrived, the staff was very nice, but unfortunately, the mixture I was hoping for was not available. Again, I was told something different on the phone

Further, the cupcakes were absolutely disgusting. The middle taste like they were possibly old, made the week before, and dry with no flavor.

Thankfully, my team loved them, but I will never ever purchase any baked goods from this place again!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

We booked Fairy cakes for our wedding and they were wonderful! We did an assortment of desserts on display and they came out so beautiful.During planning they asked for a theme and I said I didn't have one but sent some stationary we used as inspiration; they were able to replicate the stationary design onto the cookies- it was such a nice surprise and special touch. Additionally, the desserts were absolutely delicious! Our guests are still raving about how good they were. And our guests really loved them because they were gone so quickly! Mo also offered to put the allergy/vegan desserts in a box with the guests name on it. This was another nice touch and our guests that recieved these felt so special and were so excited to have a dessert they could eat!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just tried their new ice cream sandwiches and they were amazing! I got the brownie sandwich with chocolate ice cream. So delish! And super excited they are open on Fridays and Sundays now too. Didn't think anything could top the breakfast sandwich but

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This Bakery is only open for 4 hours a week on saturdays. When I went in they had a very limited selection of baked goods to choose from. Evidently most orders are made in advance and picked up. What they did have to choose from was perfectly baked beautifully decorated and tasted delicious

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Pop

We ordered our wedding cake from Fairy Cakes and I am so so glad we did. The service was fantastic, the cake was delicious, and it was decorated exactly how I asked them to. I am so glad I chose Fairy Cakes for our wedding cake, and I will be recommending them to everyone I know.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

After having seen and tasted the work they did we were convinced an order from here would be great. We placed an order as our friend is leaving to military camp and we are embarrassed to even show this to them. The cashier waited until the order was rang up before unveiling the sad low effort set of 24 cupcakes, two of which were melted and then needed to be “fixed”. We were hoping to support a local business for their attention to detail and quality, but it feels as if we were used as practice for a bake class.

Service: 1

I have never in my life had such dry and old tasteless cupcakes and cake in my entire life, however my cupcakes and cake were beautiful decorated. noway it was baked and made from scratch within the last 2 days !Reply to response: ?

Food: 2

I wanted to take a moment to express my sincerest gratitude for the stunning cake and desserts they created for my baby shower. Their talent and attention to detail truly made the event extra special, and the desserts were not only delicious but also beautifully crafted. They were the highlight of the celebration, and everyone couldn't stop raving about them. Just knowing my guests, I know they are not big on cakes, but they loved the peanut butter cream cake and so did we love the taste of our celebration cake for the very time! it was all gone in a blink of an eye.Fairy Cakes creations added such a delightful touch to the occasion, and I can't thank them enough for their wonderful work.I can't wait to order more things from them already for our next events!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was my duaghter's 10th birthday and she loves to bake, so I went online searching for a bakery/venue to do like cupcake decorating for a party.. I saw that Fairy Cakes, offers the "Nailed It!" Birthday party theme...I cried lol ..because we LOVE that show on Netflix! So I booked it...We were all so blown away at the attention to detail, the organization, the beautiful activities they did BEFORE the competition began..they decorated their own Aprons, it was too CUTE.. My Birthday girl wanted Little Mermaid 2023 theme..and Fairy Cakes WENT ALLL OUT FOR US?? I brought my own balloons and table decor..Take a look at how much fun we all had, the kids took home gorgeous 10inch round cakes, after the host/judges announced who'd actually NAILED IT! I highly recommend this party venue and the cup cakes are phenomenal!! My daughter said she'll never forget her 10th Birthday party, it was a dream come true ? Thank you so much Fairy Cakes! ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5