Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop

289 Parkside Ave, Buffalo
(716) 688-0361

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Molly Mitchell

I worked with Fairy Cakes for my wedding and it’s one of the best decisions we made!! Nicolle’s attention to detail is like none other! I was blown away by our dessert table and the guests loved every variety we offered. I HIGHLY recommend Fairy Cakes for your next event, or if you just want to pop in for a treat one day. Thank you for everything Nicolle!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie So

My husband and I went with Fairy Cakes for our wedding based on a recommendation from our photographer and we had a really great experience with them!

They were open to our request for a mixture of a small cake for cutting, mini cupcakes, and mini pies, and were able to accommodate our request to have some gluten-free cupcakes for our guests with celiac disease. They also had a really wide selection of unique flavors for both the cupcakes and pies, which we were really excited about!

They were quick and professional throughout all of our communications and answered all of our questions. The desserts were delicious and we basically had nothing left by the end of the night. The cake was both stunning and whimsical. We were just really pleased with everything that Fairy Cakes had to offer and provided. We will definitely be turning to them in the future for any other cake/dessert needs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

NadiaNTrent

Fairy Cakes Bakeshop made the most delicious and beautiful desserts and wedding cake for our big day! Everything looked absolutely stunning and tasted even better. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about the treats! The team was so lovely to work with and brought our vision to life perfectly. We’re so thankful for their incredible talent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kio sal

Happy customer. Will be back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara Schaffer

Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful and looked exactly like the inspiration picture I showed them! They got every detail I asked for. It also tasted really amazing, and everyone loved it! The cream cheese filling was very yummy. I also appreciated that the process to order and pay for the cake was very easy and stress free. Thanks Fairy Cakes for making my dream wedding cake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Clair Youngsnan

I was in the other day in hopes of having a good experience. But it was anything but that. The staff was loud and inappropriate and the girl who helped us was lacking support in her wardrobe. My son even asked me if I saw the girls nipples after we left! I am beyond upset. I wouldn't waste your time here unless you like indecent exposure and rude staff.

liz thomas

We ordered our wedding cake from Fairy Cakes. Not only was it beautiful, it was delicious! We had some guests with dietary concerns and they told us the gluten-free cupcakes we got them from Fairy Cakes were the best they’ve ever had.

Perfect communication. Super accommodating. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emma

Incredible, gorgeous custom cake. Absolutely delicious. The chocolate cake was rich and moist, and the icing was wonderful. The staff is also incredibly kind and sweet to work with. Thank you!!!

Alyssa Pino

I hired Fairy Cakes to do a desert table as well as a small cutting cake for my wedding and it was exceptional! There was so much variety in the deserts, from cookies to mini bundt cakes to chocolate covered Oreos - there really was something for everyone, and everything tasted amazing and was decorated beautifully!! I highly recommend.

ann kile

I ordered custom cookies and cupcakes for my nieces baby shower. They exceeded my expectations- the custom work was beautiful to go with her baby in bloom theme! Everyone raved about the flavor of the vanilla cupcake it was so moist and each cupcake was a piped into a flower! Just beautiful! Will recommend to everyone. Communicate was excellent and they packaged individually at my request!

jennifer filby

Super cute bakery! Ordered a birthday cake and it was delicious. Everything in the bakery looked amazing but the cake was outstanding. Easy to communicate with the shop and we let them have free reign of the cake and it was beautiful. Would definitely order again.

Nicole Forsyth

I recently had the experience of having to locate a bakery on a last minute basis. The staff at Fairy Cakes Cupcakery not only immediately said they could help, but the three tier cake, and 4 dozen cupcakes were stunning. They fit our baby shower theme PERFECTLY) and we're raved about by the guests. Everything was superior quality, taste, and the service was wonderful. We will be ordering again for an event this coming fall!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angela Sylvester-Sekuterski

We had ordered cookies from them for my bachelorette and they were custom and turned out so cute (champagne tower)!! They were supposed to be individually wrapped but when we picked them up, they weren’t. We didn’t have time to go back so we brought them home and bagged them ourselves, but Fairycakes did refund us the pre-bagged charge. We also got a small cake to cut and it was SSOO GOOOD and we were eating it days later. A tad pricey for a 5 inch cake, but the cake was amazing so to me, it was worth it. All of their desserts really are incredible and they own up to any mistakes they make and do the right thing to fix them. We already said we want to get our wedding cake each year on our anniversary from them❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madison Alleva

We have used Fairycakes for our bridal shower and our wedding and we cannot recommend them enough! Not only are their cakes and desserts beyond delicious but their decoration and presentation is out of this world!! Their creations are truly a work of art! Their attention to detail and ability to execute the beauty and design of the desserts is unlike anything I've seen! The team at fairy cakes took the time to meet with us, consult with our wedding planner and other vendors, and were able to take our very complex and unique vision and bring it to life!! Our wedding dessert table was a rainbow colorblock and we were speechless and in awe when we saw the final product. We have received countless compliments on how beautiful our dessert tables were! The team at fairy cakes had wonderful communication, were very kind and patient, and were an absolute pleasure to work with! We cannot thank you all enough!! Xo-The Lekkis

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isabella Kross

Hands down the absolute best place to order custom cakes! Love it here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop

289 Parkside Ave, Buffalo, NY 14214
(716) 688-0361