Forty Thieves

727 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 464-3822

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kevin Hernandez

Amazing wings (Carolina sauce) and service. We also had an amazing stacked burger with tots.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stack Burger, Tater Tots

Chris Edwards

This was unfortunate... We used to come here all the time, and sadly, I think this will be a pass from here on. The service was really terrible, coupled with the fact that there were 3 tables in the whole place with 2 servers and a bartender. It was also around 7 pm on a Tuesday, so there was no reason for this. We had to ask for our bill at the bar because it took so long. The food was cold, yet tasty.
It's such a pity as there are so many options around the area.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Eric Brudecki

The place is very slow on their orders, and I went in there, when not to many people were there, so when my Lady only wanted a drink, and I ordered a burger, it should not take 30 min, just to give us cups of water, so we were on a schedule, so me and my Lady left pissed

Victor A. Castillo

Will is absolutely killin it in the kitchen. Crispiest wings I ever had and the beefiest Reuben I ever had. Also decent N/A beer options which is always a plus.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Pillittieri

Wow! Food portions are huge! Food is amazing!! Loaded nachos could easily be a meal for 2! Yummy burgers and huge!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Nachos, Ruben Sandwich

Lauren Helfer

We get to go a lot & it never disappoints!

Food: 5

Alex Martin

Cool buffalo spot. Food was good, but I’d go for drinks instead at night. Service got really slow once the bar picked up. Beautiful bar though, I just wouldn’t go back with kids like we did.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Nicole Damon

Always my favorite smash burger! Great service, had Cecila, she was super sweet and efficient!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle Matesic

Friends came in from the capital district area to experience what this great city of Buffalo has to showcase for chicken wings. Went to six places back to back to back etc… in one day. The atmosphere is great. The staff was amazing. I also and a glutton for great French onion soup. I found it. So to pace ourselves we ordered 10 medium wings. The wings were cooked perfectly. We ordered them extra crispy which I never do but nonetheless were great. Juicy crispy tender. The sauce was fantastic. The appropriate amount of heat for medium. They were on the tangy sweeter side than tangy acidic side. I loved them. If you’re a fan of Blue cheese they make it in house and it was awesome. I love rooties and this was way better. I highly recommend going here for wings, French onion soup and probably anything else they offer. Great vibes. Thank you soooo much

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

vi ab

Good food and drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stack Burger, Fish Fry, Tater Tots, Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

RAH2na

Now this place is the best! Love it there!!

Siena Reynolds

Food is really good, price is proportionate to portion sizes. ($17 sandwich but practically 2 meals in size). Always have a nice time here.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free buns available

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Banana Peppers, Turkey Brie Sandwich

Margaret & Todd Walter

The food was inconsistent. The salad was huge and delicious as were the chicken fingers. The pizza logs were tiny and the shrimp tacos and tater tots were cold.
IDK if the waitress was new, but she would disappear for long periods of time. I asked for a fork and got one ten minutes later after I had already borrowed my sons fork. The atmosphere was nothing special. Kind of rundown. Overpriced. I will not return.

Kid-friendliness: Not kid friendly

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

David

We had a great time. They have a beautiful outdoor seating area. The inside area is a little loud. The burgers are amazing and the waitresses are so nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Pruitt

Great food. The pretzel cheese was sooo good. A little spicy. The pictures do not do it justice, the pretzel is insanely huge.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Giant Soft Pretzel & Queso

Loading...