Gino's NY Pizza ( University Plaza )

3500 Main St, Buffalo
(716) 768-2462

Recent Reviews

Tanisha Lopez

Best in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Larry K.

First time trying. Came before going to movies across the parking lot. Figured I'd decide whether to get a whole pie or just slices depending on what slices they had available. Got two slices of Buffalo chicken in a creamy sauce on somewhat thicker dough and two slices of plain cheese on thin NYC style crust. Both were excellent. Got each as part of a special with a 20 oz drink included. Cost $10.30 and $8.80, respectively. Will be back.

Kaolla Hina

I am not one to just do this but I do not appreciate my food being tainted. After I waited to get lunch (started work 4³⁰a.m-3/4p.m), i went to get pizza in the same plaza i work. Once at work, i literally bit into a ring! I had a bbq and a stinger pizza combo. I went to show (after taking pictures feeling furious due to hurting my mouth), the guy had a HORRID attitude about just looking and told me (with my witness standing there) "It's not our ring, it happens sometimes". Excuse me? Foul! I will NEVER order there again! I'm so disgusted by his attitude. I was respectful enough to not let others hear my rant. It seemed as if they were use to complaints as bad as mine. This is MY experience, I do hope no one else had/ have this problem.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

Priamo Bekteshi

Best pizza in all of Buffalo. Friendly service as

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

K L

I’m originally from NYC, and this is my fav pizza here in Buffalo. Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

justin king

Excellent service and delivery was

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Wings

martin emiliani

We ordered subs ......they were excellent.....but next time I'd ask to toast the roll....but mine had lots of turkey.....outstandingWheelchair accessibility: Lots of parking and there spots within a curb to bring up a wheelchair.....however there are steps so you have to look which spot works

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

layla counter

i was just at this horrible so called pizza place. and the food was absolutely horrible. the wings were raw and pizza soggy like it was sitting for hours. the gino and joes on abbott is 100x better. would never recommend this food to

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

KAMI_WAV (Kid-Kami)

This pizza was awful, with so many other quality options in Buffalo New York, I’d encourage whoever is thinking of going here to go somewhere else nearby. The pepperoni pizza was flavorless, and the texture of the crust was cardboard. If I had a good thing to compare it to it would be school cafeteria pizza, for the price you can do better elsewhere

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

HoyMay P.

We all decided a pizza for dinner was a good plan. We were only a few minutes away from Gino's. They are located in a large mall. Gino's is a small place and not very conducive to dining in for 4 people. One or two people would be fine. We decided on a New York style large spinach and mushroom pizza. That's a thin crust pizza. Our pie was made fresh and they told us 15-20 minutes. There are three sizes to choose from; medium, large and extra large. The large is sufficient to feed 3 males and 1 female unless you are starving. They were on time making and boxing the pizza. Note that if you use a credit card, a 4% charge is tacked onto the bill. Staff were nice and make a good smelling pizza. Once home we unboxed the pizza. The pizza was very tasty, ingredients fresh with a thin crust. It all disappeared and was liked by all. Good choice for pizza. Large shared parking lot.

Yamaris (LxveFruitt)

This is the best Pizza place around. It's so delicious. The workers are nice and efficient. 10/10 would

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large 20 Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza

Joseph Pulvino

Pizza was ok. Higher prices than nearby pizzerias A three percent credit card fee will keep me from ever going

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Dave Gardingham

As a transplant from NYC, I am always on the lookout for “NY style” pizza in WNY. We went to a movie in the same shopping center and were excited to try Gino’s for dinner when we saw it. I’m glad we tried it but I’m in no rush to go back. It wasn’t the most pleasant place to dine-in at as the store and tables were very messy and the chairs were all so worn and ripped. At one point, a young male employee was talking to another employee and using some obscenities. We didn’t clutch our pearls about it but we both noted to one another that it was off putting. As for the food, it was decent. The sauce is definitely a bit of a compromise between “NY style” and the sweeter sauce preference of the region, which isn’t unfair. The garlic knots had ok flavor but I did appreciate they were very soft and not too tough. Overall, it was a decent place to eat but I would only get takeout going forward

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

m

Kinda pricey but I guess that’s because the slices are so big. I got pepperoni and cheese slices and it was very bland and flavorless.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Farhad

This is the best pizza store in Buffalo, NY. Pizza taste amazing!

Load More

Gino's NY Pizza ( University Plaza )

3500 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
(716) 768-2462