Remember ordering from them during the super bowl during an exclusive opening. Just way too overpriced for the quality of the food. Better off ordering elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
arahsas
We were on short camping trip that got rained out the first night so we decided to venture into Middleburgh to look for a place to eat and hangout. We had a small dog with us so there we thought we’d have to get take out and eat in our cars. We took a chance and asked if we could have a rag to dry off the table and chairs and sit outside but two staff members dried off and moved some of their outdoor table and chairs around for us so we could all hang out and get food (it wasn’t raining there then but it had earlier). They went above and beyond when they could’ve just said no. They were incredible nice and attentive and not once made us feel like an inconvenience. My friends got a small pizza and a salad and I got the hot wings (photoed) and it was all very good. It was a pretty busy place between the restaurant side and pizza side. I saw stacks of pizza walk past us the whole time we were there. I recommend and I will go back next time I’m in the area.
Liam
Mayo on my sub. Pizza and wings solid tho.
M9357IYstephena
Had my first visit the other day and it won't be the last. I got the wings, and they were damn near perfect. They had that quintessential flavor I'm always looking for and can't always find here in Upstate NY. They didn't skimp on the quality of the food: good, full sized wings, the blue cheese was thick, creamy, the veggies on the side were fresh... The service was excellent -- friendly, outgoing, the comradery among the staff makes it a place I will not hesitate to go to again. I felt more than comfortable there; their decor made me laugh out loud and their signage brought me back to my childhood like I was in 70's Brooklyn. The prices on that sign -- these wings that are as good as I have ever had -- were the right price -- cheaper than what I can get in my local town by more than a couple of bucks. They did everything right. I can't wait to go back!
Zeshan Lin
Pizza was not worth it lol
Heidi B
A long time favorite, it’s THE place my father wanted to have our family dinner (even though we now live a hour away). I’ve loved the food (their pizza crust is seasoned to perfection) and trusted the service for over 30 years with no regrets.
SMarkus888
I have had pizza all over the world and I would put this in my top three. We always make a point to get a pie when we are in Middleburgh. The service people are very nice. Anything we have gotten in the restaurant was very good. I would recommend this to anyone.
James Lee
Pizza was not worth it lol
John H
Small restaurant with limited seating but very good food. We sat at the outside tables, which can accommodate about 8-10 people. There was no inside seating. They seem to mainly do pizza, but have a full menu. Between us we tried hamburgers, scallops, and haddock. All the food was very good. Service was very good.
steveno803
We were visiting Middleburgh and decided to grab a quick pizza. Being from NJ, we are picky about our pizza, especially if you have had pizza from one of the Jersey boardwalk pizzerias. We would definitely rank this up there with those. It was a great pie and we enjoyed every bite.
Food quality is decent. The wait time for the food is extremely inconsistent. One day you could wait 10 minutes, the next day you could wait 45-60 minutes. Workers visibly seen not making orders at times and just sitting around talking to each other. There are far better options out there, especially for the bloated price.
Remember ordering from them during the super bowl during an exclusive opening. Just way too overpriced for the quality of the food. Better off ordering elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
We were on short camping trip that got rained out the first night so we decided to venture into Middleburgh to look for a place to eat and hangout. We had a small dog with us so there we thought we’d have to get take out and eat in our cars. We took a chance and asked if we could have a rag to dry off the table and chairs and sit outside but two staff members dried off and moved some of their outdoor table and chairs around for us so we could all hang out and get food (it wasn’t raining there then but it had earlier). They went above and beyond when they could’ve just said no. They were incredible nice and attentive and not once made us feel like an inconvenience. My friends got a small pizza and a salad and I got the hot wings (photoed) and it was all very good. It was a pretty busy place between the restaurant side and pizza side. I saw stacks of pizza walk past us the whole time we were there. I recommend and I will go back next time I’m in the area.
Mayo on my sub. Pizza and wings solid tho.
Had my first visit the other day and it won't be the last. I got the wings, and they were damn near perfect. They had that quintessential flavor I'm always looking for and can't always find here in Upstate NY. They didn't skimp on the quality of the food: good, full sized wings, the blue cheese was thick, creamy, the veggies on the side were fresh... The service was excellent -- friendly, outgoing, the comradery among the staff makes it a place I will not hesitate to go to again. I felt more than comfortable there; their decor made me laugh out loud and their signage brought me back to my childhood like I was in 70's Brooklyn. The prices on that sign -- these wings that are as good as I have ever had -- were the right price -- cheaper than what I can get in my local town by more than a couple of bucks. They did everything right. I can't wait to go back!
Pizza was not worth it lol
A long time favorite, it’s THE place my father wanted to have our family dinner (even though we now live a hour away). I’ve loved the food (their pizza crust is seasoned to perfection) and trusted the service for over 30 years with no regrets.
I have had pizza all over the world and I would put this in my top three. We always make a point to get a pie when we are in Middleburgh. The service people are very nice. Anything we have gotten in the restaurant was very good. I would recommend this to anyone.
Pizza was not worth it lol
Small restaurant with limited seating but very good food. We sat at the outside tables, which can accommodate about 8-10 people. There was no inside seating. They seem to mainly do pizza, but have a full menu. Between us we tried hamburgers, scallops, and haddock. All the food was very good. Service was very good.
We were visiting Middleburgh and decided to grab a quick pizza. Being from NJ, we are picky about our pizza, especially if you have had pizza from one of the Jersey boardwalk pizzerias. We would definitely rank this up there with those. It was a great pie and we enjoyed every bite.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was not worth it lol
Food is amazing
Food quality is decent. The wait time for the food is extremely inconsistent. One day you could wait 10 minutes, the next day you could wait 45-60 minutes. Workers visibly seen not making orders at times and just sitting around talking to each other. There are far better options out there, especially for the bloated price.
Very good food, but always super slow
Amazing Subs