Mustachio's Pizzeria

2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 874-8909

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Jack

Billy's staff in there made me the Very best Antipasto salad I've ever had. The staff in there are always very kind and respectful. What a GREAT place to eat, especially when you're in a hurry. :)

Louiza Case-Drmacich

Top tier pizza with the best crust in Buffalo! Our pizzas always come with the perfect amount of toppings and they are always consistently delicious time after time. The ingredients are high quality and we would 10/10 recommend!

Annette Edwards

The food does not taste all that great, no seasoning at all, the food taste bland, I read the reviews and I was quite surprised till I got my food now I'm really surprised order two cheeseburgers a antipasto salad which was mostly lettuce I mean a whole lot of lettuce and a steak sandwich , all I tasted was the cheese on the steak sandwich, the two cheeseburgers the guys threw them in the garbage, my opinion order at your own risk

two people for the cheeseburgers they threw

them both in the garbage

7/12/25
please take the pastillios off the menu , terrible ,to greasey, just awful

Mimi Fox

A great neighborhood pizza place with delivery. I like their subs, the turkey club is my favorite here and their pizza also heats up great the next day the sauce is really good too.

Madeline Rivers

Oh my!! I got a wheat greek wrap and it was marvelous, delicious and didn't wait long at all. Tyvm!! Best i ever had! Everything tastes fresh!

Stephanie McGee

Really soft and buttery crust. All the ingredients are mixed well!
Definitely a Buffalo Home pizza!
I started eating the pizza hot but of course other things distracted me
By time I got back to my slice it was cold but it never missed a BEAT in the FLAVOR !!
One of the BEST pizza I’ve had in a long time!!

Bee Bee

absolutely horrible horrible pizza place in my opinion ordered chicken fingers and a pizza pizza so soggy the pizza is just flopping over cheese just won't even stay on the pizza chicken fingers honestly so small the chickens must have obviously been handicapped in some way because they were not chicken fingers like all the restaurants I highly recommend not ordering from this place

Traveler60177411693

While they do have a counter to eat in, they are more known for takeout. Their pizza is the best of all pizza places in the area! We drive 20 minutes to get our pizza! If you want a Royal Sub, they make the best. (Embarrassing to say, we also drive 20 minutes to pick one up!) Fish Fries? Awesome!!

Nicola

It is pretty good, but I can tell I've seen a drop in quality over the last year and a half though it's still pretty good. I will say I stick with their more simple pizzas and their sausage is gross to me and probably their worst topping. The wings are also pretty good, but it is Buffalo so I understand the bar needs to be high there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Chicken Wings

Brian Eleey

Good pie. Would order again when I that area working

Food: 4

Service: 4

Joey Marrelli

Pizza was fine. They definitely messed it up though. Toppings made it on 1/2 that weren’t supposed to be there which is an honest mistake. I work in the restaurant business This stuff happens. At the end of the day. All I was looking for was a remade pizza. They told me no, but offered me $5 and exchange for the mess up.. not even a refund.. just five bucks, I sadly took the $5 dollars… I’ll order from Franco’s next time at least they show a little more Sincerity.

Food: 4

Service: 1

Jim Myers

Great pizza and great prices, no reason to look anywhere else in the area for pizza and garlic bread!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pizza

Gordon Moorhead

Great pizza. One of the best wings in

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Chicken Wings

Caren Paterniti

Great Pizza!! Friendly staff, from phone and to delivery people!! Great
Job. Thank you for the high standard of service!! ??

Peter Baptiste

Ordered food for me and my son . Called hour later to ask if they forgot about us they said they didn't have my order so then manager said he will make it over and send it out in 10 mins jus to find hair in are food .. very disgusting and disappointing.. after arguing with manger they sent food out only to find a hair in my taco salad waste of 40 dollars.waitied hour and a half just to throw it out very disgusting place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...