Mustachio's Pizzeria

2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 874-8909

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Westfall

Excellent pizza and wings.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elvis Blueme

The food is consistently good!

Lisa Franco

On oct 21 2024 I ordered the daily special a large pizza and 20 chicken fingers on the pizza I orded cheese and mushrooms the pizza was sloppy every thing was falling of the pizza the pizza could have been made better

Food: 2

kiran reddy

I really liked the Veggie Deluxe pizza, and the onion rings were absolutely bomb! The people here are super nice and friendly — great experience overall!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Frances Paris

It’s was alright I thought it would be better but until now nothing beats Picassos pizza
Their chicken finger sub was not toast long enough and chicken fingers weren’t that crispy

Petee F

Ordered a pizza(well done) and mozzarella sticks. The pizza was incredible, as usual but the mozzarella sticks didn't have any cheese in them. Just breading. Maybe they thought I wanted those well done too? IDK. Not bashing because I dig this joint. Just constructive criticism.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peter G

Amazing pizza and boneless wings

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

luxuriousforce

Very solid dependable pizza. Chicken finger sub is the best though and their meatball sub is no slouch either.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

L9700NOkathya

Pizza is the best I've ever had! I've had pizzas of all sorts including in other states that I've resided in and never had one this good!

Sara Herringshaw

Their Pizza is so tasty, and love their wings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Jack

Billy's staff in there made me the Very best Antipasto salad I've ever had. The staff in there are always very kind and respectful. What a GREAT place to eat, especially when you're in a hurry. :)

Louiza Case-Drmacich

Top tier pizza with the best crust in Buffalo! Our pizzas always come with the perfect amount of toppings and they are always consistently delicious time after time. The ingredients are high quality and we would 10/10 recommend!

Annette Edwards

The food does not taste all that great, no seasoning at all, the food taste bland, I read the reviews and I was quite surprised till I got my food now I'm really surprised order two cheeseburgers a antipasto salad which was mostly lettuce I mean a whole lot of lettuce and a steak sandwich , all I tasted was the cheese on the steak sandwich, the two cheeseburgers the guys threw them in the garbage, my opinion order at your own risk

two people for the cheeseburgers they threw

them both in the garbage

7/12/25
please take the pastillios off the menu , terrible ,to greasey, just awful

Mimi Fox

A great neighborhood pizza place with delivery. I like their subs, the turkey club is my favorite here and their pizza also heats up great the next day the sauce is really good too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza, Antipasto Salad

Madeline Rivers

Oh my!! I got a wheat greek wrap and it was marvelous, delicious and didn't wait long at all. Tyvm!! Best i ever had! Everything tastes fresh!

Loading...