Pasquale's Italian Restaurant West Seneca

Grabbed dinner.. got the Chicken Alfredo, baked Penne.. and Tiramisu.. good food and good service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Warm Atmosphere and Excellent Service at Pasquale’s – Looking Forward to Next Time!

We started with the bread and oil they provide—absolutely outstanding! Fresh, flavorful, and a great way to kick off the meal.

I ordered the Chicken Marsala, which came with Brussels sprouts and pasta. It may have been a busy night (Pasta Tuesday!), or perhaps just a different flavor profile than I’m used to, but the marsala sauce was a bit strong for my taste, the chicken was slightly dry, and the Brussels sprouts could’ve used more seasoning. I also wasn’t a fan of the red sauce on the pasta.

That said, none of this will deter me from coming back. The atmosphere is warm and comforting, the restaurant is very clean—including the bathroom, which was noticeably well-kept—and the staff was absolutely above and beyond.

I’m looking forward to returning and trying something new—there’s a lot to love about this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

We love the chicken bacon ranch and the Italian rainbow pizza. Highly recommend!

It pains me to write a negative review for this restaurant because I do love the food and the service is great. However, I don’t understand how an ITALIAN restaurant can change $10 for (literally— I had the waitress check) a plate of Kraft Mac and cheese with no sides. Nowhere on the menu does it state that it is Kraft. I could buy a full box of it for $1.50 at the grocery store. I understand that it is a kids menu, but you would think that an Italian restaurant would at least serve their own pasta. I expressed my concern to the waitress who was able to give me a free side of steamed broccoli but she spoke to the GM and told me, “it is what it is”. Everything else we ordered was great but I expected more from a nice sit down restaurant like Pasquale’s than food that came out of a box and then be charged many times more than it was worth.

Love this local favorite! Home cooked, amazing, delicious food, reasonably priced and lovely service! McKenzie was awesome ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lasagna Chicken Parmigiana, Fish Fry, Baked Penne, White, Stuffed Shells, Lasagna, Fettuccine Alfredo, Eggplant Strato, Calamari, Seafood, Scallops, Wings, Chicken Parmesan, Combo Platter, Tiramisu, Caesar Salad

The pickle pizza yummmmy !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

The restaurant was fairly busy and we had to wait to be seated.
Once we were called, we were seated in a booth and both the booth seat and table were extremely wet which I did not realize until I sat down and my pants got soaked.

Once seated It took a few minutes for the waitress to come over and take our drink and food order.

Eventually our soups/salads were brought out. The soups were lukewarm.

I ordered the Broccoli Cheese Soup and as soon as the bowl was placed on the table in front of me I noticed it had a different scent. I took one bite and it tasted off, so I took a second bite and realized it had a very sweet taste to it. Everyone at the table tried it and my nephew said it reminded him of a vanilla pudding flavor, needless to say no one ate it.

The waitress took forever to return to come check on us and once she finally did I told her about the soup.
She spoke with the kitchen and came back to tell us the cook thought it was the soup base because I was not the first person to mention it tasted off.
NOT ONLY DID THE COOKS KNOW THE SOUP WASN'T RIGHT, THEY CONTINUED TO SERVE IT LIKE THAT!

Next our meals came out.
I ordered baked penne with rosa sauce, it was also lukewarm which I don’t understand since it was baked in the oven and the plate was hot.
There was so much sauce I couldn't find the pasta on the plate nevermind taste it. I ate less than a 1/4 of the pasta and again the waitress failed to check on us in a timely manner so I didn't even bother bringing up the issues this time.

I have eaten in the restaurant in the past and was very satisfied but that was close to a year ago. I am not sure if this was a fluke or if the food quality and service have gone downhill.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Lighting made reading the menu difficult, other than that very nice place, fantastic waitress and excellent food!!

We were greeted by a very pleasant hostess and seated in Wil’s section. He came over took our drink orders and left. Came back set them on the table, no napkins said are you ready. We placed our order and he left, we got our salads and had to ask for rolls, finally we get them, no bread plates and only 2 butters, we had to ask for more. Our dinners came out while still eating the salads and we again asked for more butter. Never asked about cheese, just put dinner down and took the salad plates. Shortly after he came and put Togo containers on the table and said I’m sure you are going to need these and left the bill. I said boy, you never even asked about a second drink, our response was, oh did you all want one. Not once did he ask about coffee or dessert or even how was everything? I did ask him if he was in a hurry and we were his last table and he said no, why? We dine at Pasquales’s quite often, it is the only place I order pizza from and have never encountered such poor service. I usually enjoy the dining experience and have a pleasant meal and evening, not last night, it was very discouraging!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Amazing Italian food. I had the shrimp and scallops medley with a bambino mini pizza on the side Caesar salad, All, top-notch, huge,menu, amazing service, good prices. Good people and atmosphere. I can’t wait to come back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood, Scallops

I know they have great Italian food bit I highly recommend the steak bomber sub one of the best in buffalo and I've tried alot of steak hoagie every where in buffalo

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fatty veal. Very unappetizing.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Excellent food and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Eggplant Strato

Too noisy and very chaotic atmosphere. Mussels too salty. Very fast service because they needed the table.

Ordered online. This is what a Buffalo pizza should look like. Cheese past the crust. Sloppy looking. Toppings not symmetrical. Plenty to almost too much cheese. Sauce and sauce. This sauce wasn’t sweet but was great. Cup n char was perfect. Loved the crust too. I really really enjoyed this pizza. Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5