The Flaming Fish

535 Main St, Buffalo
(716) 322-5480

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Ketchup Hot Sauce Shrimp Sauce Starter Sauce And
The Haddock Fish Hoagie
Fish and Shrimp Dinner
Flaming Combo
Shrimp PO'Boy
The Fish Fry

Menu

Appetizers
Bombay Shrimp
A pile of our specially fried shrimp tossed in a medium spicy sauce, served over a bed of lettuce and topped with shredded carrots, red cabbage, and green onion.
Chicken Buenos Nachos
Tortilla chips, corn salsa (corn, black beans, tomato, red onion, cilantro), lettuce, shredded cheese, nacho cheese, salsa, sour cream, special sauce, and your choice of protein.
Poutine
French fries, our special homemade gravy, a blend of cheeses, and your choice of protein.
Quesadillas
Select either seasoned chicken breast, sirloin steak, fish, veggies or shrimp. Each selection includes your choice of protein, sauteed red and green bell peppers, onions, corn, and black beans, topped with a mix of shredded cheeses grilled to perfection on our flat top.
Honey Cajun Shrimp
A pile of our crispy shrimp tossed in our sweet and spicy Honey Cajun sauce and topped with red cabbage, shredded Carrots and green onion.
Buffalo Shrimp
Our specially seasoned fried shrimp tossed in our Buffalo Style Sauce. Served over a bed of lettuce and topped with shredded carrots, red cabbage and green onion.

Tacos
Regular Taco
12″ tortilla, lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese, salsa.
Hammerhead Taco
12″ tortilla, lettuce, tomato, cheese, radish, red onion, and medium spicy hammerhead sauce. Medium spicy.
Fiesta Taco
12″ tortilla, lettuce, corn salsa (corn, black beans, tomato, cilantro, lime juice), shredded cheese, and special sauce.
Bahama Mama Taco
Two 6″ tacos, lettuce, pice de gallo, topped with a light spicy special sauce. Light spicy.
Seabreeze Taco
Two 6″ tacos, lettuce, mango, pice de gallo, topped with a light spicy special sauce. Light spicy.
Jerk shrimp tacos
Grilled Jerk Shrimp, lettuce and pineapple salsa(pineapple, tomato, Red onion, cilantro) drizzled with our special sauce.

Entrees
Flaming Fish Fry
Our specially seasoned and fried with your choice of fish, french fries, dinner roll.
Flaming Shrimp Fry
10 shrimp specially seasoned and fried, french fries, dinner roll.
Flaming Combo
Specially seasoned and fried with your choice of fish, 5 specially seasoned fried shrimp, french fries, dinner roll.
Order of 5 Shrimp
5 Grilled or Fried Shrimp with Dinner Roll and Cocktail Sauce
Order of 10 Shrimp
Your choice of either 10 Grilled or 10 Fried Shrimp with Dinner Roll and Cocktail Sauce
Fish and Bread
Your Choice of Fish Grilled or Fried , a Dinner Roll and tartar and hot sauces.

Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich
Our specially seasoned and fried haddock, lettuce, american cheese, and tomato on an 8″ roll. Add tartar and hot sauce or sauce on side.
Fish Hoagie
Our specially seasoned and fried haddock, American cheese, sauteed onions, and sauteed red and green bell peppers with our special fish hoagie sauce on a toasted 8″ costanzo roll. Medium spicy.
Po'Boy
Your choice of our specially seasoned shrimp, haddock or catfish on top of lettuce, tomatoes, a light sprinkle of cheese, drizzled with our special medium spicy po'boy sauce and served on a toasted costanzo roll. Protein choices: Shrimp, Catfish, Haddock or 4 Jumbo Shrimp. Medium spicy.
Pesto Sandwich
Feta cheese, pesto mayo, and roasted red peppers on an 8″ roll. Choice of chicken or portabella mushroom.
Lobster Grilled Cheese
Chicken Sandwich
Our specially seasoned Fried Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese and or discussion Chicken Sandwich Sauce. Comes with French Fries.

Homemade Special Sauces
Fiesta Sauce
Hammerhead Sauce
Bahama Mama Sauce
Fish Hoagie Sauce
Po'Boy Sauce
Pesto Sauce
Bombay Sauce
Salsa

Desserts
Peach Cobbler Poundcake
Carrot Cake
Peach Cobbler
Chocolate Fudge Cake
Coconut Pineapple Cake

Sides
Coleslaw
Macaroni salad
Rotini noodles, onion, Red bell peppers.
Potato Salad
Potato, onion, red and green Bell peppers, and eggs
Hushpuppies
6 hushpuppies per order
Green Beans
Sauteed green beans drained with smoked turkey
Cabbage
Sauteed cabbage drained with smoked turkey.
Seasoned Rice
Pinto Beans(FRI/SAT ONLY)
Stewed pinto beans seasoned with smoked Turkey.
French Fries
Seafood pasta salad
Pasta, onions, Red and Green Bell peppers, celery, Grilled Shrimp and imitation crabmeat.
Candied Yams(FRIDAYS ONLY)
Cajun Rice(FRIDAYS ONLY)
Rice, onions, bell peppers, smoked sausage, and a blend of savory seasonings.
Macaroni and Cheese
Mashed Potatoes
Corn

Beverages
Lemon tea
Raspberry Tea
Diet Pepsi
Dr Pepper
Sprite
Orange Crush
Grape Crush

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+34 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+33 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place just doesn’t miss! The food is delicious! The portions are huge and the staff is very friendly! I highly recommend the shrimp po boy! It’s so good! And there usually 8 large shrimp on the sandwich, I had to eat half of them just to close the sandwich! All the sides are great but I’m a sucker for the red beans and rice! I’ve dined in and done take out no issues either way! I love this place and I plan on eating their food a lot in the future! Cheers Flaming Fish!...
October 2025
A truly pleasurable experience. We enjoyed the food and the service. There was no greeter at the door when we arrived, and that was a bit off putting because we stood there for 15 minutes before being acknowledged.
Our server, D, and another wait staff were friendly. D was attentive and timely. We wanted to start with the seafood cheddar dip, but they were out of it. We opted for the seafood fries. They were a 7/10. A bit soggy and didn't stay hot. They may have...
October 2025
Who knew?!!!

This unassuming little seafood joint was right out the back door of my hotel (Hyatt) and serves some amazing food!

Outstanding service!!!!

I had the fried green tomatoes as an appetizer (IN BUFFALO!!!) and they were outstanding. Next in line was the fried walleye with the house made macaroni salad (EXCELLENT taste and not bland) red beans and rice and collards. Being from the south, when it comes to collards...
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Graylynn - 537 Main St
Cocktail Bar, Tapas/Small Plates, American, Pet Friendly
overwinter coffee - downtown buffalo - 9 Genesee St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Misuta Chow's - 521 Main St
Bar, Arcades, Japanese, Pet Friendly

The Flaming Fish

535 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203
(716) 322-5480