Pickup time was right on. It was still hot an very very good. I visited from ohio an wanted to try a place I've never heard of and im glad I picked Tony's. I hope to come back.
heather gurman
awesome folks, fast great food and reasonably priced 😋👍🏼 our boss has been ordering 🍕 & 🍗 every Tuesday for over 10yrs. serious food dedication indeed! thanku all of you !!
Ian Green
Sub was absolutely garbage.....4 meatballs on it hardly any sauce 90% of the cheese was burned to the foil took them 20 minutes to make the p.o.s sub this place is absolutely garbage and the workers have terrible attitudes
William Marso
Old, cold slices. One may have been rancid.. Didn't eat it!
Mariangela Mercurio
I got the Greek wrap it was quite delicious and honestly bigger than I anticipated, chicken was cooked to perfection, it was very fast service as well
David Pettigrew
Overall started out as a good place but just started going downhill with quality of the food, went in for 2 slices today got back to work and was just a grease and soggy mess cheese fell right off the pizza along with the stream of liquid dripping off the bottom of the box safe to say last time goin here
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Robert LaPorte
Best chicken wings in WNY. Way better than Anchor or Duff's. Their pizza is also excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patty W
My husband and I have ordered from Tony's for OVER 50 years when it started on Cleveland Dr. Always consistent and happy with food and service. However, tonight my husband ordered a pizza sub (which for over 50 years was a toasted sub roll with sauce, cheese and pepperoni). My husband had a coupon and the correct/exact cash on hand. The girl behind the counter said, "That will be 13.50 + tax. $13.50??? For a pizza sub?? That, in itself, is ridiculous! When my husband pointed out to the girl behind the counter (using a menu there AND the menu online) that the price listed was $12.50, she responded the extra dollar was for the pepperoni. WHAT??! Since when is a pizza sub only sauce and cheese? My husband complained that you can't charge more than what's listed on the menu. She said that what her boss told her to charge. Huh?? Even though it's only a dollar, it's the principle. Who owns Tony's on Harlem now? If it's the sons or grandsons of the "original" Tony, they certainly don't have his business acumen. If I order a chicken parm sub, will I be charged extra for the cheese? A Tony's pizza sub has ALWAYS been toasted sub roll, sauce, cheese AND pepperoni. Charging extra for pepperoni is nickel and diming your customers. I suggest the current owner re-read all the 1-star reviews here and start having a serious talk with his staff about consistency, accuracy, and not charging more than what their menu states. I don't know if they're desperate for workers but they're not hiring quality employees. We WERE 50-year customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Scatpack716
My personal favorite pizza place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me Checky You Likey
Delicious pizza , great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Logs, Steak Sub, Onion Rings, Taco Salad, Fish Fry, Cheeseburger, Fried, Italian Style Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, French Fries, Sheet Cheese Pizza
Parking: Available parking in front and on the side of the building. Also, street parking on the side street. No parking on Harlem Rd.
Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs at the entrance of Tony's, which makes it easy for people using a wheelchair.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Sub, Taco Salad, Pizza
Patricia Clark
Got my 1st pizza here. I have lived in area for over 20 years and gave them a try. For me pizza is about the sauce. The pizza I got had no sauce it was spread so thin that it was tasteless. Can't say I would go back. Was really disappointed.
Layha
The wings are nasty and undercooked. There is no seasoning on the wings, even with the medium heat and the honey garlic, the wings were not cooked long enough, making them worse. Update: After 2 days of receiving the run around, I finally spoke with Kyle, the manager, and he told me that because I posted a review and he would not correct the issue. Wow...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike Stutz
We have been getting pizza from Tony’s for our weekend pizza night for quite a while. Pizza is always done just right and on time. We have tried several other places in the area but always go back here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
ANGEL VINICIO MEDINA AGUILAR
I recommend it without a doubt, the best place to buy pizzas
Pickup time was right on. It was still hot an very very good. I visited from ohio an wanted to try a place I've never heard of and im glad I picked Tony's. I hope to come back.
awesome folks, fast great food and reasonably priced 😋👍🏼 our boss has been ordering 🍕 & 🍗 every Tuesday for over 10yrs.
serious food dedication indeed! thanku all of you !!
Sub was absolutely garbage.....4 meatballs on it hardly any sauce 90% of the cheese was burned to the foil took them 20 minutes to make the p.o.s sub this place is absolutely garbage and the workers have terrible attitudes
Old, cold slices.
One may have been rancid..
Didn't eat it!
I got the Greek wrap it was quite delicious and honestly bigger than I anticipated, chicken was cooked to perfection, it was very fast service as well
Overall started out as a good place but just started going downhill with quality of the food, went in for 2 slices today got back to work and was just a grease and soggy mess cheese fell right off the pizza along with the stream of liquid dripping off the bottom of the box safe to say last time goin here
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best chicken wings in WNY. Way better than Anchor or Duff's.
Their pizza is also excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I have ordered from Tony's for OVER 50 years when it started on Cleveland Dr. Always consistent and happy with food and service. However, tonight my husband ordered a pizza sub (which for over 50 years was a toasted sub roll with sauce, cheese and pepperoni). My husband had a coupon and the correct/exact cash on hand. The girl behind the counter said, "That will be 13.50 + tax. $13.50??? For a pizza sub?? That, in itself, is ridiculous! When my husband pointed out to the girl behind the counter (using a menu there AND the menu online) that the price listed was $12.50, she responded the extra dollar was for the pepperoni. WHAT??! Since when is a pizza sub only sauce and cheese? My husband complained that you can't charge more than what's listed on the menu. She said that what her boss told her to charge. Huh?? Even though it's only a dollar, it's the principle. Who owns Tony's on Harlem now? If it's the sons or grandsons of the "original" Tony, they certainly don't have his business acumen. If I order a chicken parm sub, will I be charged extra for the cheese? A Tony's pizza sub has ALWAYS been toasted sub roll, sauce, cheese AND pepperoni. Charging extra for pepperoni is nickel and diming your customers. I suggest the current owner re-read all the 1-star reviews here and start having a serious talk with his staff about consistency, accuracy, and not charging more than what their menu states. I don't know if they're desperate for workers but they're not hiring quality employees. We WERE 50-year customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
My personal favorite pizza place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza , great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Logs, Steak Sub, Onion Rings, Taco Salad, Fish Fry, Cheeseburger, Fried, Italian Style Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, French Fries, Sheet Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
As always, great wings and pizza!
Parking: Available parking in front and on the side of the building. Also, street parking on the side street. No parking on Harlem Rd.
Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs at the entrance of Tony's, which makes it easy for people using a wheelchair.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Sub, Taco Salad, Pizza
Got my 1st pizza here. I have lived in area for over 20 years and gave them a try. For me pizza is about the sauce. The pizza I got had no sauce it was spread so thin that it was tasteless. Can't say I would go back. Was really disappointed.
The wings are nasty and undercooked. There is no seasoning on the wings, even with the medium heat and the honey garlic, the wings were not cooked long enough, making them worse. Update: After 2 days of receiving the run around, I finally spoke with Kyle, the manager, and he told me that because I posted a review and he would not correct the issue. Wow...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We have been getting pizza from Tony’s for our weekend pizza night for quite a while. Pizza is always done just right and on time. We have tried several other places in the area but always go back here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I recommend it without a doubt, the best place to buy pizzas
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...