Crosby's- Caledonia

3018 Main St, Caledonia
(585) 538-2300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lisa Ohle

Thank you to the store manager Hanna for the delicious breakfast pizza! Great customer service and had my pizza ready asap!

L H

Thank you to the store manager Hanna for the delicious breakfast pizza! Great customer service and had my pizza ready asap!

Tina Spence

I love the pizza and the staff at this location.

Ben Verbeck

The lady who works in the morning bagged up fresh breakfast sandwiches and let me tell you, the yolks were perfect. I read the negative reviews and that has not been my experience whatsoever. It seems as though users Jake fromstatefarm, Cody Preston and Theresa Cirigliano who have only reviewed one business, ever, chose to hold grudges and drop one measly star and not even mention how spectacularly clean the bathrooms are, which is a lot to ask for because you know the grossest dumps ever get dropped in those bowls. I mean, it’s a gas station, workers from all around this area come here just to poop, and their diets are wretched. They eat gas station food so, you get it.

jake fromstatefarm

So not sure why the night time manager no longer works here. Her food was the best and her timing was impeccable. I tried ordering a pizza and the guy with glasses tried telling me that it was a 2 hour wait, she would’ve had four of my pizzas up in 25 minutes! Coolers are never stocked, ice is always empty, pizza is always expired and rock hard, same with the cookies, I want the night lady back!

Josh Bigg

Insane this place is still open!! "No food because he's new and she's leaving soon" only two or three slices of hours old cheese pizza.Also not the first time this happened (or similar). Just amazed that Crosbys hasn't shut this place down or done something.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Trish A

Bought two pizzas and the dough was raw. Very disappointing. Not the first time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Cody Preston

I ordered a sub and was told 45 minutes, I showed up 10 minutes later than I was told and it wasn’t even started yet. If I could leave 0 stars I would

Ashley S

Worst job I’ve ever had. 10/10 would not recommend

Theresa Cirigliano

Got charged for 2 transactions, only 1 of them being mine, cashier was very unhelpful and

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

I Rod

I've been to this Crosby's at least 3 times and everytime Ive attempted to purchase food from here it looks really old And over cooked. The cookies are over baked and the pizza and calzones are old and dry this Crosby's needs an employee change.

Israel Rodriguez

I've been to this Crosby's at least 3 times and everytime Ive attempted to purchase food from here it looks really old And over cooked. The cookies are over baked and the pizza and calzones are old and dry this Crosby's needs an employee change.

Robert Grant

Customer service is awful gas pump locked wouldn’t release card took literally 10!minutes for pump to fill car. Watched 2 customers leave from the same problem!!!!!

Donna Shelton

I was just in Crosby's and I so wanted a slice of pizza. I was standing in line and I watch an employee moving food around in the pizza warmer. She was not wear gloves and touching the food with her hands!!!!!!!!!! I told her I wanted a slice of pizza till I watched her touching the food with her hands. She told me to my face I was wrong I can not believe it. I told her she can not say she did not do it when O watched her. That place is very crappy. I so wish we got 7-11 store.

Michael Curtis

Buffalo chicken pizza is very good

Loading...