Local Pizza

4499 NY-17B, Callicoon
(845) 887-3500

Recent Reviews

Summer Putman

We stopped here after hiking the Tusten Mountain Trail. It’s a small but cozy little place with delicious food (we got pizza and the shrimp tacos)! No alcohol but a good selection of fun drinks in the cooler. They had a couple picnic tables outside to sit at if it was a nice day. The staff were awesome; very accommodating and kind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp Tacos

A Botello Jr

A very diverse menu. My favorite is the bulgogi tacos. Sooo good ?! Going back to Miami, will miss

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily van den Blink

You might think this is your average local pizza shop, but it’s so much more. The guy running the register and taking orders was fast, friendly, and very helpful when asked for recommendations. We were thrilled that there were so many fresh and delicious vegan options. We especially liked the BBQ vegan wings, Thai peanut salad, and the lo mein noodle bowl (it is heavy on the sauce, so if that’s not your thing you might want to go with a different option).We went on New Year’s Day when it was particularly busy. In spite of that, the food was presented promptly and beautifully plated.Vegetarian options: Fresh and delicious vegan options

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Antriksh Mutha

Pizza sauce can be better! Pizza crust was good but sauce could have been better. Tiramisu was basically a coffee cake. Could have been better. Little expensive for the quality.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Damian F.

Great place and amazing service and cool pizzas that nobody makes ! Very friendly and local business!

Lisa G.

This place is great! Although it's take-out really it's still cute inside and cozy enough to eat in. Wide selection of tasty food and nice staff. My only complaint is not enough gluten free options. Although their gluten free pizza is better than most.

Comer C.

They have a relatively few seats for dine-in. So we usually get take out. They are friendly and the food is good, especially the tacos.

Lois Gallagher

Good pizza. A bit light on the toppings but otherwise tasty. Ordering on line is super easy and the vegan cheese was surpringly good.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Paul M.

Usually delicious food but it varies depending on who is cooking ie, fish tacos sometimes fabulous and other times not with whole other taste, Prices are high. Tacos are much better than the pizza which I think is "so-so"

Joan Reynolds

It's a small sitting area, food was very good service friendly! I've been there quite a few times. Give it a try, lots of take out orders.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Diana McNerney

Our first time visiting this evening. The staff were really friendly and the food was awesome! We purchased the Bad Idea pizza and Vampire Tacos. Delicious ?. Definitely going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy F.

Pizza was Great we got the General tso'chicken pizza and Owens Own (? A Hawaiian style) . Both were delicious. Staff were friendly and happy. A year ago we had some sand with here that were also VERY VERY good. seating is small but it is mostly a takeout kind of place. definitely recommend!

Sharen Ivory

I ate there for the first time this week and I had wings thy where great cooked perfect and the people are very friendly and polite will be my go to spot the food is outstanding I really enjoyed it thank you ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Missy Ann

Is this a hooters or local pizza? Girl that took my order was wearing boyshort underwear. Ladies do not let your man visit this place and girlcot it with me. I will never give this place another cent. Pizza was mediocre at best but maybe it would have been better if I wasn't so disgusted by the skanky help and kitchen full of Spanish guys. Maybe the tacos are what people go here for... but I won't be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Soto

Prices online do not reflect the prices in store, check ahead if you call in to order.The pizza is just below average and doesn’t justify the steep NYC price tag!I wouldn’t order from this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Load More