Peppinos

31 Lower Main St, Callicoon
(845) 887-6767

Recent Reviews

Sort by
O4943UVroberts

Had a Friday early evening dinner, calamari app ,Mrs had salmon filet on a bed of spinach risotto and I had a veal franchise both were good. Our server was great. We enjoyed the meal.

kkaarrll

Took my extended family (7 people) out for a birthday party dinner. Arrived at our reservation time and were promptly seated, wait staff very professional and courteous. Decor a mix of Italian and halloween which worked in late October. Extensive menu of Italian classics. Most of us ordered veal or seafood and we were all pleased with quality, portion and presentation. The place was packed for saturday night but service kept up nicely without rushing us. Total tab for 7 including entrees, appetizers, desserts, bar tab and tip was $400 which figures out to about $57 per person. Which I thought ws very reasonable for our dinner. They have a patio for warm weather dining. Parking on the street in front of the restaurant is scarce but if you go around the block behind the restaurant there is a nice lot. I would not call this place ADA accessible as I did not see a designated parking spot nearby.

joycecC7124GS

Food was tasteless. Server did not serve bread, however she served plenty to her friends at the next table. No grated cheese on the table. Food was lukewarm. I did take the leftovers home and the next day they were awful too.

Lou Lampitelli

Always a pleasure experience. Our go to for great food , great server's. Thanks guys

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

GUSTAVO RAUL GONZALEZ PEREZ (GUS)

Food is good, the atmosphere is cozy but the service needs to improve a lot. The times they take to bring an order sometimes are over an hour.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Lorraine L L

Great service delicious food..we love the veal chop best ever! Just make sure to bring your appetite huge servings!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T C

Food was ok. Inside was a bit louder than I would like.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Beth Cooney

Well I’ve been going here for years however recently every time I go I’m more and more disappointed… tonight was the last straw they gave us bread that was so stale my kids wouldn’t even eat it… we ordered a pizza half with meatballs it came out and was clearly a reheated old pizza they threw some meatballs on … the service however is the best it’s been in years . It’s so sad to see the front of the house finally get it together and now the kitchen is falling short . It’s a family owned business and I hate giving a poor review and I hope they take the recent criticism to heart and work on their reputation!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Patricia Becker

Great food, sat outside on deck, good waitress.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

HATCHET JACK

Always a good time. Great bar seating. Miss millie bartending

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jerry NY Tint

The Stromboli ring is the way to go .. but don’t order it if your by yourself…

Lisa Fitzsimmons

We have enjoyed so many wonderful meals here .. those grilled & chilled shrimp= THE Shrimp cocktail of 2025!!! Their porterhouse steak was so delicious, tender and had absolutely the best flavor with the perfect cut of meat; second time a month later was good although much smaller and just too much added flavor. rosemary? thyme?? Just unnecessary and next time I will be sure to request NO extra flavas.. Chicken parm was completely enjoyed. Italian Wedding Soup and Salad always fantastic. Food and SANGRIA all delicious.. don't miss this place. Ask for Heidi’s table… you will want for anything as she knows you want it before you do, prompt in checking in, cocktail refills and so charming and pleasant! Prices are climate comparable but affordable, better without alcohol of course. Go and eat!! You WILL enjoy!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristin Tomaselli

I have been to countless Italian restaurants and consider myself to have pretty high standards when it comes to Italian cuisine. That being said, everything we had here was absolutely delicious. The bolognese and scampi are a MUST!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vitold Baranski

Plain pie was mediocre at best. A bit chewy, though the taste was fine. It’s a nice spot though and the service was quick

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Kelsey n

This restaurant was recommended by a friend. Thank God for friends! 10 stars for peppinos. Love the stuffed pizza. Stromboli is absolutely delicious. Dinners are huge and include your bread, soup or salad. Owners/employees are friendly and make you feel good. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...