Great food, fun atmosphere, and great service from Alex the Bartender.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mitzi Robles
Delicious Drinks, food and service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
L S
I wanted to like this restaurant. After some disappointing local experiences with prime rib, we saw prime rib on the menu here and thought we would give it a try. I ordered the New England Clam Chowder and felt it was one of the best I ever had. Chock full of ingredients with unusually large pieces of clams. The salad was OK, nothing special. Then came the prime rib. A generous sized piece that appeared to be done perfectly according to my request. My friend also got the PR, and was given a good sized end cut which he requested. But then, what a letdown. Both of our servings were among the toughest we've ever encountered. It hurt my teeth to chew. (My teeth are perfectly healthy, lol.) A real disappointment. I should mention, however that our waitress, Sarah was top notch.I doubt we'll be back. Still searching for that perfect prime rib, like those young guys looking for the perfect wave in that surfing movie years ago.Overall Grade C+
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
suzanne byman
Good Ole country place atmosp. I've eaten here at least five times in past year. If you're going on a Friday and want the prime rib You have to Reserve The rib At least a day in advance So they know how many to cook. Very good. Perfectly COOKED. The chicken sandwich was stellar. French onion soup was great! Appetizers- trifecto bland; onion rings-big n crispy, good ; BUT my once favorite potato skins were tiny, shriveled, and dry w a bit of cheddar on top.Oh, be careful of the floor in front of the ladies room, it's sunken in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Elizabeth A. Ridgeway
Our place for our weekly date night out. David’s food is amazing. All the staff is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Dip, Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese, Burger and Fries, Burger, Jockey Melt
Jennifer Fisher
Great local place. Fantastic bartender/waitress!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Scott G.
The horse and sulky near wurtsboro ny is a wonderful bar and grill! The food is always excellent and the workers are friendly. I have gone here many times for food or drinks or both. The shaved steak sandwich is one of my favorites but I have never had a bad choice here. All the local folks seem friendly but sometimes you just cannot get a seat at the bar. This is a very popular spot and the customer base is loyal. A very nice verity of pub food. From burgers to steak, sandwiches to appetizers and soups, no bad choices (even salads). I recommend this place highly for a nice local bar and grill experience. Easy to get to and hard to leave with comfortable atmosphere. Enjoy the lovey place if you are in the area or just passing through!!
Zeke Delmonico
Nice place, biker
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ginger A.
Great food and owners are fabulous. Fun place with friendly people. Recommend the eggplant and the fried chicken with pasta.
TheEdgeNYC
Just off Route 17 between Monticello and I-84 there is this hidden gem of a restaurant. I am sure the locals have known about this place for a while, but for us, travelling up to the central NY, stumbling upon this place was one of the highlights of our road trip. It was a little concerning that on a Friday afternoon, during lunch time, the restaurant was empty but, we are so glad we ate here. The food was great, the service was friendly. Definitely a place to go to if you are on Route 17 looking for a bite. It's a quick off, quick on, in either direction.
2nd time here in past 3 months. Again, the 1 waitress was also the bartender. Food was a zero. Alfredo chicken-pasty & dry. I tried 4 different pieces of chicken in my dish and had to discard them because I couldn't chew OR CUT THROUGH the piece! Friend ordered med rare steak and received well done. Her sides were spinach and carrots mixed (strange combo). The Pork Slider was finely ground up pork that was unrecognizable, tasted mushy and bland.Salads are good.
Jamie T.
We love this place. We found it when we moved to the area a year ago. The menu is great and they have wonderful deals throughout the week. Definitely try the salmon with the glaze.
Eric Horowitz
Great place. We descended on them with a crew of 20 preteen boys after a lacrosse tournament and they handled us like champs. Great wait staff, great food. Can’t wait to go again next year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Sulky Steak Salad, Burger
Katy G.
The food is SO DELICIOUS!!!! Service is very good, and quick and easy. Menu has many options and is easy to read. Not so easy to decide what to get though! The ambiance is amazing!
claudia ferrara
Nice place for a bar and some dining. Food was acceptable. Service was phenomenal.
Great food, fun atmosphere, and great service from Alex the Bartender.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious Drinks, food and service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to like this restaurant. After some disappointing local experiences with prime rib, we saw prime rib on the menu here and thought we would give it a try. I ordered the New England Clam Chowder and felt it was one of the best I ever had. Chock full of ingredients with unusually large pieces of clams. The salad was OK, nothing special. Then came the prime rib. A generous sized piece that appeared to be done perfectly according to my request. My friend also got the PR, and was given a good sized end cut which he requested. But then, what a letdown. Both of our servings were among the toughest we've ever encountered. It hurt my teeth to chew. (My teeth are perfectly healthy, lol.) A real disappointment. I should mention, however that our waitress, Sarah was top notch.I doubt we'll be back. Still searching for that perfect prime rib, like those young guys looking for the perfect wave in that surfing movie years ago.Overall Grade C+
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Good Ole country place atmosp. I've eaten here at least five times in past year. If you're going on a Friday and want the prime rib You have to Reserve The rib At least a day in advance So they know how many to cook. Very good. Perfectly COOKED. The chicken sandwich was stellar. French onion soup was great! Appetizers- trifecto bland; onion rings-big n crispy, good ; BUT my once favorite potato skins were tiny, shriveled, and dry w a bit of cheddar on top.Oh, be careful of the floor in front of the ladies room, it's sunken in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Our place for our weekly date night out. David’s food is amazing. All the staff is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Dip, Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese, Burger and Fries, Burger, Jockey Melt
Great local place. Fantastic bartender/waitress!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
The horse and sulky near wurtsboro ny is a wonderful bar and grill! The food is always excellent and the workers are friendly. I have gone here many times for food or drinks or both. The shaved steak sandwich is one of my favorites but I have never had a bad choice here. All the local folks seem friendly but sometimes you just cannot get a seat at the bar. This is a very popular spot and the customer base is loyal. A very nice verity of pub food. From burgers to steak, sandwiches to appetizers and soups, no bad choices (even salads). I recommend this place highly for a nice local bar and grill experience. Easy to get to and hard to leave with comfortable atmosphere. Enjoy the lovey place if you are in the area or just passing through!!
Nice place, biker
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and owners are fabulous. Fun place with friendly people. Recommend the eggplant and the fried chicken with pasta.
Just off Route 17 between Monticello and I-84 there is this hidden gem of a restaurant. I am sure the locals have known about this place for a while, but for us, travelling up to the central NY, stumbling upon this place was one of the highlights of our road trip. It was a little concerning that on a Friday afternoon, during lunch time, the restaurant was empty but, we are so glad we ate here. The food was great, the service was friendly. Definitely a place to go to if you are on Route 17 looking for a bite. It's a quick off, quick on, in either direction.
Restaurantji Recommends
2nd time here in past 3 months. Again, the 1 waitress was also the bartender. Food was a zero. Alfredo chicken-pasty & dry. I tried 4 different pieces of chicken in my dish and had to discard them because I couldn't chew OR CUT THROUGH the piece! Friend ordered med rare steak and received well done. Her sides were spinach and carrots mixed (strange combo). The Pork Slider was finely ground up pork that was unrecognizable, tasted mushy and bland.Salads are good.
We love this place. We found it when we moved to the area a year ago. The menu is great and they have wonderful deals throughout the week. Definitely try the salmon with the glaze.
Great place. We descended on them with a crew of 20 preteen boys after a lacrosse tournament and they handled us like champs. Great wait staff, great food. Can’t wait to go again next year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Sulky Steak Salad, Burger
The food is SO DELICIOUS!!!! Service is very good, and quick and easy. Menu has many options and is easy to read. Not so easy to decide what to get though! The ambiance is amazing!
Nice place for a bar and some dining. Food was acceptable. Service was phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Sulky Steak Salad, Chicken Parmesan, Chardonnay, Burger, Mashed Potatoes, Fries