The Horse & Sulky Pub & Grill

$$ • Bar & Grill, American, Pubs

Hours:
206 Sarah Wells Trail, Campbell Hall
(845) 614-5928

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.4 (37)
Restaurantji Rating

Good Ole country place atmosp. I've eaten here at least five times in past year. If you're going on a Friday and want the prime rib You have to Reserve The rib At least a day in advance So they know how many to cook. Very good. Perfectly COOKED. The chicken sandwich was stellar. French onion soup was great! Appetizers- trifecto bland; onion rings-big n crispy, good ; BUT my once favorite potato skins were tiny, shriveled, and dry w a bit of cheddar on top.Oh, be careful of the...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

The horse and sulky near wurtsboro ny is a wonderful bar and grill! The food is always excellent and the workers are friendly. I have gone here many times for food or drinks or both. The shaved steak sandwich is one of my favorites but I have never had a bad choice here. All the local folks seem friendly but sometimes you just cannot get a seat at the bar. This is a very popular spot and the customer base is loyal. A very nice verity of pub food. From burgers to steak, sandwiches...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Just off Route 17 between Monticello and I-84 there is this hidden gem of a restaurant. I am sure the locals have known about this place for a while, but for us, travelling up to the central NY, stumbling upon this place was one of the highlights of our road trip. It was a little concerning that on a Friday afternoon, during lunch time, the restaurant was empty but, we are so glad we ate here. The food was great, the service was friendly. Definitely a place to go to if you are...read full review

More Reviews(168)

Ratings

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 12 - 9PM
Wednesday 12 - 9PM
Thursday 12PM - 12AM
Friday 12 - 10PM
Saturday 12 - 10PM
Sunday 12 - 9PM
Updated on: