Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place
(516) 877-7750

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shraddha Parmar

The food was good, but the service was quite disappointing. We waited about 10 minutes just to get menus and place our drink order, and when we were ready to leave, it took another 10 minutes for the server to bring us the check which never actually came. Despite there only being two other tables occupied, the server kept checking in on them while we were left waiting. After enough frustration, we eventually had to walk up to the counter ourselves to give our card for payment. It was a letdown, especially since we had been looking forward to trying this place every time we passed by. With better service, the experience could have been much more enjoyable.

Ryan Kim

Great place to go to, to get food, and amazing customer service

John Bruno

Pizza? Yes! But good Lord those chicken wings are something very special!

SS

Anthony's coal fired pizza, the name seemed nice and we thought the place would be rustic. But no, this was more like a rundown sports bar. A bunch of hillbillies were permanently stationed at the bar and sometimes were loud enough to distract us. The place did not feel that clean, especially the floors. On top of that, they forgot about our order. After waiting for a while we asked for it again, then they rushed to make the pie and guess what, it had raw tomato sauce all over it, which we had to scrape off to eat the remainder of what was left. Sorry but lot of scope for improvement guys. Thank you.

Alejandro Torres

Very delicious pizza. Mine wasn’t burned. Came out perfect. Cozy place. Paulie pie was great. Great atmosphere. Don’t see many places like this anymore. It’s casual. They had the football game on. Sound was good not too loud. Recommended.

AASH

Very good Al worker 👍👍

Reynaldo Leon

One of my favorite places to grab a bite.

Blake Tyler

Food is really good but service is spotty and slow. Got our apps before the drinks and had to ask for drinks and napkins.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Frank Singh

I like this chain pizza. This location always seems to be on point with the making of food with little wait time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 12 Inch Pizza, Original Wings

Azary Tamarov

Beautiful pizzeria, i was in rush got to enjoy my 2 slices on the go will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza

Alexandros H Kosmidis

They don't just serve amazing pizza but some of the best wings around. Quick bite but very tasty food and good service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 12 Inch Pizza, Original Wings, Roasted Wings

Anne La

Over-priced burnt pizza and a garlic clove. Ordered a pie for pick up. It was about $24. I had to re-enter the place to ask for plates and seasonings. They gave me 4 paper plates for a large pie and only red pepper seasonings. I said, "How about oregano and garlic?" She said, "we don't have oregano, but I can give you fresh garlic." I said, "Okay, that will do." She extended her hand to give me a GARLIC CLOVE. I said, "I didn't think that's what you went, so no," and I walked away confused, annoyed, and not wanting ever to go back EVER AGAIN. Was this a joke. Her trying to belittle me in public? What is wrong with this staff? This is why I don't stay to eat because they are sarcastic like this, and I don't appreciate it. For these high-end prices, they should be happy they have customers. Also, the crust was burnt again. COAL FIRED PIZZA doesn't mean that it has to be BURNT. This place should be called COAL BURNT PIZZA. Shameful!!!

Parking: Giant shared parking lot.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

alicia

Great pizza and excellent service from waitress johanny

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Wu

Best coal fired pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Jeremiah Bly

The food was good. The service was adequate. The biggest issue with this location is that there specials apply to take out only. For the same set of items in store you pay 20-30% more.

Family meal online $31, in store $37. I would recommend the pizza if you wanted to get take out. Dine in is not worth the extra cost.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: 12 Inch Pizza

Loading...

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514
(516) 877-7750