Cafe Formaggio

$$ • Italian

307 Old Country Rd, Carle Place
(516) 333-1718


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Cafe Formaggio

Have eaten from gluten free menu many times and have enjoyed it. Have not been here since last summer. I don't know if they changed owners or whatever but last night was terrible. We got in early before a show which is usually safer for a Celiac. Service was extremely slow. 2 of us have Celiac and ordered from GF menu. I ordered veal marsala with roasted potatoes and veggies which I have had before and loved. Only ate half as was not up to par. Took 40 minutes after full review
My first choice was the taglatelli ragu, but at 7:30 they were all out, as well as the gluten free bread. I ordered the capollini fra diavolo, which was delicious as was my calamari appetizer, but my wife's shrimp with risotto was very salty. Granted this was Valentine's day but you should not run out of items that early, especially when you are just offering a prefix menu. When we left at around 9:00, there was a large crowd, maybe 40 people, waiting to be seated, can't full review

Went here for a romantic dinner with my boyfriend the other night. The food was delicious, the sangria was so good and I'm picky with my sangria. the bread that was given when you sit down was my favorite. I can't wait to go back! Would definitely recommend for date night or even family night out.

More Reviews(176)


Monday 11:30AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 9:30PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 9:30PM
Friday 11:30AM - 10:30PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 10:30PM
Sunday 11:30AM - 9:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.