Carmel Diner staff are excellent. Food is served fast, hot and fresh. I really like the sausage links. Highly recommended
Lea S
Sandwich was not made as directed won't order anything to go anymore
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Daniel Chanofsky
Food was good and the server was especially helpful and courteous.
Daniel
Pricey, food is average
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
John Marino
Dietary restrictions: You'd have to tell waitress
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mouse Cake, Burger
Richard M
my friend took me here for lunch when I was visiting..... I was confused at first... when we pulled into the parking lot.. I saw the sign Carmel diner and resturant.. I didn't know if it was a diner or resturant.. if I was underdressed.... or over dressed...
But the food ....service was outstanding... I hope the next time I'm visiting my friend brings me here again
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Hamburger Deluxe with Fries, Mozzarella Sticks
Rickman Fan Forever
The food was great, my friend had chicken cacciatore and I had peanut butter stuffed French toast and all was delicious. We also had wonderful vanilla cappachinos. Thanks, we will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lorraine Zephir
It was the worst service we have ever received. The waitress was so confused, and asked over and over the same questions. She brought 1 thing out at a time, for each item that went with each meal, with long time spans in between. She got 2 of the 3 orders completely wrong. 1 order was editable although wrong, I asked for a salad platter with balsamic dressing, and I got a sandwich. The other order had the wrong bread, which the person does not like. We were not offered any kind of credit. That food went in the garbage. Even after the food came out, we still didn't have utensils, so I had to flag someone down to get them. We were offered another meal with the correct bread ,but at this point, being there so long with a toddler, we simply had to leave. Would NEVER go back. Waste of time and money and oh so agrravating! We still left a 20% tip, even though we didn't get a goodbye or thank you when given the bill.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Jacqueline Vita
This diner delivers a delicious meal. Their gyro and souvalki combo was prepared well and plentiful. The Chicken was moist and taziki sauce nice and tangy. The grilled salmon was cooked to optimal temperature and Brussel sprouts were sautéed and tender. Our meals came with soup or salad. The seafood bisque had plenty of shrimp. If you have an opportunity to be in Carmel, this diner will be happy to serve you a delicious meal. The attention and service by wait staff is above average! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeanne Morris
Stopped at this diner first time after new doctor in Mahopac. The best crabmeat stuffed mushrooms over portabella mushrooms in my life !!! Friend had a perfect large Reuben the best and I had a western egg sandwich and a delicious biscotti treat for the way home! Loved the excellent wait staff and other employees, very clean diner and enjoyed all the happy fish in the tank ! We will return ?
Excellent Hungry Man breakfast and full stack pancakes with hash browns and corned beef hash
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry L.
Amazing soup
Jean Logan
I love the walnut chicken salad. It is very filling and big. They fry the chicken breaded with the walnuts and it’s so tasty and delicious. My husband likes their breakfast. It’s usually hit or miss here with what you get but it’s always very reasonably priced. I also like the chicken and waffles and their chicken soup is very good. The decor could use some Updating but it’s an old place I am glad it’s still around after all these years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon and Eggs, Chicken Soup
Sassy C.
The only reason i give 1 star its bcz this diner as well as others around has lost its charm its tradition the fun of having to go at any hour afterhours to dine at any one of these establishments after an outing or a movie night, after the pandemic they started closing early at midnight totally understandable; but now 4yrs later they closing even earlier 9pm? Seriously? Totally sucks!! Bring back the tradition of the good old days where at 2am the diner was the place2go!…. So Sad the only thing available after 12 are the limited fast food places nearby…
elva adams
Enjoy eating at this Diner every month when I get together with a dear friend.
Carmel Diner staff are excellent. Food is served fast, hot and fresh. I really like the sausage links.
Highly recommended
Sandwich was not made as directed won't order anything to go anymore
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Food was good and the server was especially helpful and courteous.
Pricey, food is average
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Dietary restrictions: You'd have to tell waitress
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mouse Cake, Burger
my friend took me here for lunch when I was visiting..... I was confused at first... when we pulled into the parking lot.. I saw the sign Carmel diner and resturant..
I didn't know if it was a diner or resturant..
if I was underdressed.... or over dressed...
But the food ....service was outstanding...
I hope the next time I'm visiting my friend brings me here again
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Hamburger Deluxe with Fries, Mozzarella Sticks
The food was great, my friend had chicken cacciatore and I had peanut butter stuffed French toast and all was delicious. We also had wonderful vanilla cappachinos. Thanks, we will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was the worst service we have ever received. The waitress was so confused, and asked over and over the same questions. She brought 1 thing out at a time, for each item that went with each meal, with long time spans in between. She got 2 of the 3 orders completely wrong. 1 order was editable although wrong, I asked for a salad platter with balsamic dressing, and I got a sandwich. The other order had the wrong bread, which the person does not like. We were not offered any kind of credit. That food went in the garbage. Even after the food came out, we still didn't have utensils, so I had to flag someone down to get them. We were offered another meal with the correct bread ,but at this point, being there so long with a toddler, we simply had to leave. Would NEVER go back. Waste of time and money and oh so agrravating! We still left a 20% tip, even though we didn't get a goodbye or thank you when given the bill.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
This diner delivers a delicious meal. Their gyro and souvalki combo was prepared well and plentiful. The Chicken was moist and taziki sauce nice and tangy. The grilled salmon was cooked to optimal temperature and Brussel sprouts were sautéed and tender. Our meals came with soup or salad. The seafood bisque had plenty of shrimp. If you have an opportunity to be in Carmel, this diner will be happy to serve you a delicious meal. The attention and service by wait staff is above average! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped at this diner first time after new doctor in Mahopac. The best crabmeat stuffed mushrooms over portabella mushrooms in my life !!! Friend had a perfect large Reuben the best and I had a western egg sandwich and a delicious biscotti treat for the way home! Loved the excellent wait staff and other employees, very clean diner and enjoyed all the happy fish in the tank ! We will return ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent Hungry Man breakfast and full stack pancakes with hash browns and corned beef hash
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing soup
I love the walnut chicken salad. It is very filling and big. They fry the chicken breaded with the walnuts and it’s so tasty and delicious. My husband likes their breakfast. It’s usually hit or miss here with what you get but it’s always very reasonably priced. I also like the chicken and waffles and their chicken soup is very good. The decor could use some
Updating but it’s an old place I am glad it’s still around after all these years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon and Eggs, Chicken Soup
The only reason i give 1 star its bcz this diner as well as others around has lost its charm its tradition the fun of having to go at any hour afterhours to dine at any one of these establishments after an outing or a movie night, after the pandemic they started closing early at midnight totally understandable; but now 4yrs later they closing even earlier 9pm? Seriously? Totally sucks!! Bring back the tradition of the good old days where at 2am the diner was the place2go!…. So Sad the only thing available after 12 are the limited fast food places nearby…
Enjoy eating at this Diner every month when I get together with a dear friend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...