Smalley's Inn

57 Gleneida Ave, Carmel Hamlet
(845) 225-4007

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Raymond Lachance

His place one out of business after 50 years

An Artist & A Kitchen

This restaurant has mastered its historical menu, written and rewritten by the pen of an aging general manager and to be typed set by the hand of its seasonal chef. The GHOSTS of the past, seem to be fermenting like fine wines in its rustic cellar.

HECT CHACON

Great food. Good service.

Balarini123

We ate there on Tuesday night . The place has been around for a while but the service and the food were excellent.

Angela D

Food was really good & portions were huge!

Leticia Rivera

Thursdays is primerib night. Absolutely delicious. Staff is friendly as well.

Punisher QRF

Interesting place. Not exactly what we expected but really nice employees, good food and an odd feel. Almost like someone's watching you...

Milo Erickson

The food is regularly fresh and yummy, employees gives awesome customer service. I liked how neat it is and mood. Will come visit again.

Donna Vitolo

Food was great,especially the calamari. Loved the Halloween decorations. Highly recommend you go there

DayTrip54468989442

The Steaks are to "DIE" for. The service is excellent. The prices are great and the GHOSTS don't bother me.

jayres125

Ive gotten several menu items over the years and nothing really stands out. The mashed potatoes are powdered, blah. The pasta is ok, big servings, decwnt seasoning. Wasn't too impressed with the salmon. But they have a killer eggplant salad!

Erin Bb

I'm only giving three stars because the owner, Tony, was a complete d__k. He was yelling at the help in front of customers, telling them to stop talking so much, "we need to get people in and out of here as quickly as possible." My husband and I have been going there for years. Stopped going because we felt we were discriminated against when we had dinner there with friends of ours that happened to be BLACK. Decided to go back after not eating there for years. It may be years before we go again. It's unfortunate, because the food is decent, but....................Treat your employees and customers with respect.

Ascarry01

Great fun having dinner at Smalley's. Had dirty martini and pumpkin ravioli. Both were perfect. Love love love all the Halloween decorations. As a treat while you are dinning Horror film characters come scare you. So much FUN!

Lorraine Mark

A real Spooktacular dine out experience! Great food and friendly service

Michael J. Steele

This is a great place to go see Halloween decorations while enjoying a good meal.

Loading...