Castile Cider Mill

29 E Park Rd, Castile
(585) 493-5928

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Colleen Michalczak

Cider didnt stay fresh as long as it has in past.

Kim Southard

Cute little place. Hot cider and cider slushies available also!

Miranda Fuller

I have always had a positive experience here. The Cider slushies are a must. The variety of products they offer has really grown too. I love the Castile cider Mill.

Pilar Galvis

The apple cider fry cakes are phenomenal! I don't usually like anything like a donut, but these are worth it. Didn't get any cider, but now I wish I did. I also wish I bought some fry cakes to bring home :(

Jamie Smith

It was very good, the flavors of the hard cider were delicious, plan on going back next year with my friend

michelle knapp

Small but has charm. Cider slushy are great. Cider ver tastee. Good donut also..

Adam Bodratti

Great cider mill! We like going for fresh cider, fresh made doughnuts, and to try their hard ciders!

Shuang Zhong

By far the best apple cider donut! We don't have this good of apple cider donuts in NYC. My daughter graduated this May 2024, Miss my trips up to visit my daughter in Geneseo. Always my "to go place" when I visit! Too Bad this shop is closed by November!

Christie Giberson

Bit pricey but in today's world everything is. Definitely worth it!!!! Always fresh, warm, and so delicious!!! Missed them the other 2x I was pregnant but thankfully I can now indulge lol. Welcome bk!!!!

Patrick McCabe

The cider is refrigerated when you purchase , that’s a wonderful touch. Fresh! Apples are wonderful, the cider fried cakes are the best. Three Falls cider was excellent. It would be helpful if they had a handicap ramp to the facility! That would accommodate those of us that need accessibility! We will return for your wonderful cider fried cakes and cider.

Shelby Mayville

Love this little place. They have the best cider around! Have driven almost 2 hrs just to get some!

Mark Phillippi

Best cider in NY

Jeff Draper

Great down-home cider & donuts!

Carol Berner

Best fry cakes and cider

Bruce Cook

The donuts were very hard as if they were days old and the cider tasted like it was turning. I won’t be back anytime soon!

Loading...